Gray Brothers Cafeteria
CLOSED$ •
About Gray Brothers Cafeteria
Gray Brothers Cafeteria Reviews
The food is not like it use to be. The green beans and mashed potatoes were SUPER salty. We went around 1pm and they were out of certain foods but they were still listed online that you can order. The staff was also not very friendly at all. I use to LOVE going to Grays, it’s so sad how much it has changed.
Ordered a cheesecake with strawberry topping. It cost $38, had a big hole in the middle and some weird cheap strawberry drizzle on it, not actual strawberry topping. So disappointed.
Great food and great service
Ratings
Menu
Gray Brothers Cafeteria offers a variety of comforting dishes, including chicken and noodles, mashed potatoes, au gratin potatoes, and a selection of pies. The restaurant provides easy curbside pickup and friendly service. While portions may be small, the food is generally good, with the strawberry pie being a standout. Vegetarian options, such as green beans and corn, are also available.
The cafeteria-style dining experience allows customers to choose from a delicious array of food items. Customers can enjoy a free slice of pie on certain days, although the alacart prices must be considered. The meatloaf, stuffed peppers, and chicken noodles are particularly popular dishes, and the coconut cream pie is a favorite. The location, just off Highway 67, makes it a convenient stop for travelers.
The restaurant's homemade noodles, cooked to perfection, are a highlight, and the generous portions of chicken or beef chunks are a draw for many customers. The fresh yeast rolls and the "freakin awesome" corn are also praised by diners.