Stopped here for dinner on a Sunday night while in Muncie. Good burger. Waitress talked me into a larger sized beer. I was very happy. Sunday night football was on. I will return.
Stachia B.
What's up with all of the bland menu changes? This location used to never disappoint. The last time we ate here, my husband & I left feeling annoyed, like we paid WAY too much for our mediocre food and my favorite fish tacos weren't on the menu anymore. Don't fix it if it's not broken, y'all. Our most recent visit was probably the last.
Dale O.
I've been here off and on over the years. The food is good but the service is reliably bad. Especially irritating is snotty waitresses that eavesdrop on your conversations and comment instead of serving the food. Sadly this is standard for restaurants in the village.
Kim K.
We had a great dinner tonight! We had a party of 7 which included 2 kids. They not only sat us easily, our waitress and the staff were all extremely friendly and helpful!
Renee G.
Introducing my children to the Village night life we chose to dine at Scotty's. Upon entering the eatery my eyes were immediately drawn to the uniquely decorated dinning area. It had the feel of a fun pub dinning experience but well maintained with an ambiance not too loud for a family to enjoy the experience in. The staff was smart enough to rush and get my children's order immediately so as to get it cooking and out to my children in a timely fashion. Only one true improvement needed is the water seems to taste off. Glasses of water and glasses of soda both seemed to taste off. I could taste a bit of metal or rust in my drink. Aside from this a very enjoyable experience that I would recommend in a heart beat to return to
Cortney M.
We frequently have lunch or dinner at Scotty's. Nice location on BSU campus. We like the cajun bison burger, black bean veggie burger and BBQ ranch salad with grilled chicken! They have lots of good salad, burger and wrap choices for lunch or dinner. Nice size portions. Also, they have a BOGO colts special this fall that we have used a few times and the rewards program is worth signing up for if you'll be dining frequently. Good kids meal options, $2 on Tuesday and Sunday.
Selena C.
This pub was delicious. I have zero complaints. Our server was awesome. She even brought samples of the bbq sauce out so we could see if we liked it. There were 5 of us, 3 were kids. We all fit more than comfortably into the large booth. The atmosphere was nice for kids. The music was up, but not too loud and people felt comfortable talking. Everyone enjoyed their food and the children ate without complaint. I would suggest the Piggy Mac Grillled Cheese. It was SO delicious! Layers and layers of flavor. 2 kinds of cheese so it's super melty. Add the mac and cheese and pulled pork and you have yourself a brand new craving! Nothing fell flat! Our family is brand new to Muncie, but we will be regulars at this establishment! SO GOOD!
Jackson H.
Excellent visit. I had never went to a Scotty's before, so the experience was cool. Our waitress was super chill, and regularly checked on us for drink refills, etc. My friends and I split an order of the pretzel bites app. I was surprised how good this was. I personally ordered the veggie burger wrap with waffle fries. The wrap was a crumbled veggie burger, melted cheese, pico, lettuce, and chipotle ranch. Very good, if not better, than most veggie burgers I've had. We dined outside, which was a very nice experience. It wasn't busy at all (Tuesday evening). I really liked the interior space. It had an industrial sports bar vibe w/ dimmed lighting fixtures. The experience was entirely what I expected, given I really like Three Wise Men in downtown Muncie, and Scotty's owns that restaurant brand as well. I highly recommend this place.
Zaria D.
I had the opportunity to go to this spot for lunch while visiting Ball State. It was extremely busy so was only able to sit outside. The server was nice and helpful with information about the menu. Since it was so busy there were delays but not anything that I think she could control. I ordered this yummy Parmesan chicken wrap and waffle fries. Also ordered the buffalo chicken dip for an appetizer. It came out fast and was really good. It took awhile for the wrap to come out so had to get it to go. The wrap was delicious. It was a very flavorful sandwich. The waffle fries were not really hot but they were good. I would return to try other menu items if back in Muncie. The food was good and full of flavor. The server was nice and able to provide suggestions on menu items. Overall good experience.
Molly R.
Brittany was an awesome server!! I wish the employees besides Brittany would wear more modest shorts and pants. I enjoyed my Sherman's special burger and loaded fries and my friend loved her guacamole burger and loaded fries, too. We will come again. I recommend !!!!
Even worse than last time. The restaurant was crowded but 50 minutes for a burger is not acceptable. Our server was good but the cook was not. The manager said "that's just the way it is." We'll actually, if it is, then you should at least comp us some beers or an app. Hopefully I read my review when I'm in Muncie next year and never return.
Darin B.
Scotty's really struggled tonight. It took 75 minutes for us to get our food. We are normally huge fans of Scotty's but not tonight. The manager was too busy chatting with other people at the bar and other tables to come explain any delays as he never came to our table. When the food finally came out 1/2 of it had obviously been done for quite some time and was not fresh or good. The consolation prize from our waitress was 2 small $.25 bowls of ice cream. Come on Scotty's you can do better. It will be a while before we come back.
David T.
Above par example of a college sports bar. The service is always excellent and the food is fresh and in ample servings. I think the bone-in wings might be the best I have had anywhere.
Tracie Lowe
Great burgers, and the cheese curds appetizer was excellent! Friendly service, and $4.00 tap selection was strong. We'll be back!
Paul Ward
This place has a great atmosphere and amazing food. I've even taken my kids here for lunch. They love it too. It's better food than most other restaurants in the same price range.
Stopped here for dinner on a Sunday night while in Muncie. Good burger. Waitress talked me into a larger sized beer. I was very happy. Sunday night football was on. I will return.
What's up with all of the bland menu changes? This location used to never disappoint. The last time we ate here, my husband & I left feeling annoyed, like we paid WAY too much for our mediocre food and my favorite fish tacos weren't on the menu anymore. Don't fix it if it's not broken, y'all. Our most recent visit was probably the last.
I've been here off and on over the years. The food is good but the service is reliably bad. Especially irritating is snotty waitresses that eavesdrop on your conversations and comment instead of serving the food. Sadly this is standard for restaurants in the village.
We had a great dinner tonight! We had a party of 7 which included 2 kids. They not only sat us easily, our waitress and the staff were all extremely friendly and helpful!
Introducing my children to the Village night life we chose to dine at Scotty's. Upon entering the eatery my eyes were immediately drawn to the uniquely decorated dinning area. It had the feel of a fun pub dinning experience but well maintained with an ambiance not too loud for a family to enjoy the experience in. The staff was smart enough to rush and get my children's order immediately so as to get it cooking and out to my children in a timely fashion. Only one true improvement needed is the water seems to taste off. Glasses of water and glasses of soda both seemed to taste off. I could taste a bit of metal or rust in my drink. Aside from this a very enjoyable experience that I would recommend in a heart beat to return to
We frequently have lunch or dinner at Scotty's. Nice location on BSU campus. We like the cajun bison burger, black bean veggie burger and BBQ ranch salad with grilled chicken! They have lots of good salad, burger and wrap choices for lunch or dinner. Nice size portions. Also, they have a BOGO colts special this fall that we have used a few times and the rewards program is worth signing up for if you'll be dining frequently. Good kids meal options, $2 on Tuesday and Sunday.
This pub was delicious. I have zero complaints. Our server was awesome. She even brought samples of the bbq sauce out so we could see if we liked it. There were 5 of us, 3 were kids. We all fit more than comfortably into the large booth. The atmosphere was nice for kids. The music was up, but not too loud and people felt comfortable talking. Everyone enjoyed their food and the children ate without complaint. I would suggest the Piggy Mac Grillled Cheese. It was SO delicious! Layers and layers of flavor. 2 kinds of cheese so it's super melty. Add the mac and cheese and pulled pork and you have yourself a brand new craving! Nothing fell flat! Our family is brand new to Muncie, but we will be regulars at this establishment! SO GOOD!
Excellent visit. I had never went to a Scotty's before, so the experience was cool. Our waitress was super chill, and regularly checked on us for drink refills, etc. My friends and I split an order of the pretzel bites app. I was surprised how good this was. I personally ordered the veggie burger wrap with waffle fries. The wrap was a crumbled veggie burger, melted cheese, pico, lettuce, and chipotle ranch. Very good, if not better, than most veggie burgers I've had. We dined outside, which was a very nice experience. It wasn't busy at all (Tuesday evening). I really liked the interior space. It had an industrial sports bar vibe w/ dimmed lighting fixtures. The experience was entirely what I expected, given I really like Three Wise Men in downtown Muncie, and Scotty's owns that restaurant brand as well. I highly recommend this place.
I had the opportunity to go to this spot for lunch while visiting Ball State. It was extremely busy so was only able to sit outside. The server was nice and helpful with information about the menu. Since it was so busy there were delays but not anything that I think she could control. I ordered this yummy Parmesan chicken wrap and waffle fries. Also ordered the buffalo chicken dip for an appetizer. It came out fast and was really good. It took awhile for the wrap to come out so had to get it to go. The wrap was delicious. It was a very flavorful sandwich. The waffle fries were not really hot but they were good. I would return to try other menu items if back in Muncie. The food was good and full of flavor. The server was nice and able to provide suggestions on menu items. Overall good experience.
Brittany was an awesome server!! I wish the employees besides Brittany would wear more modest shorts and pants. I enjoyed my Sherman's special burger and loaded fries and my friend loved her guacamole burger and loaded fries, too. We will come again. I recommend !!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Even worse than last time. The restaurant was crowded but 50 minutes for a burger is not acceptable. Our server was good but the cook was not. The manager said "that's just the way it is." We'll actually, if it is, then you should at least comp us some beers or an app. Hopefully I read my review when I'm in Muncie next year and never return.
Scotty's really struggled tonight. It took 75 minutes for us to get our food. We are normally huge fans of Scotty's but not tonight. The manager was too busy chatting with other people at the bar and other tables to come explain any delays as he never came to our table. When the food finally came out 1/2 of it had obviously been done for quite some time and was not fresh or good. The consolation prize from our waitress was 2 small $.25 bowls of ice cream. Come on Scotty's you can do better. It will be a while before we come back.
Above par example of a college sports bar. The service is always excellent and the food is fresh and in ample servings. I think the bone-in wings might be the best I have had anywhere.
Great burgers, and the cheese curds appetizer was excellent! Friendly service, and $4.00 tap selection was strong. We'll be back!
This place has a great atmosphere and amazing food. I've even taken my kids here for lunch. They love it too. It's better food than most other restaurants in the same price range.