Baby Mae's

1817 Gray Brook Ln, New Albany
(812) 914-7040

Recent Reviews

Shawnee

Food is always on point! Business hours are subject to change but when I see that flashing OPEN sign it's on.

Daniel Caldwell

Decent food and you could really taste the smoke, but be sure not to get there too early because everything will not be ready.

mark mcghee

The employees are rude. The manager is the worst. I consider spending my money in there, until I seen how they treat the homeless who just needed a shelter, so they set at the tables that have a roof. Yet they weren't bothering nobody but they were told to leave in the pouring rain told they were being a nuisance to the customers. It shouldn't be legal to treat people this way but yet they think because they own a restaurant they're allowed to treat people however they want.

Mustafa Zaimah

I had the "NUKE BURGER!!!" OFF THE CHAIN!!! DELICIOUS!!! I normally get the chicken wings but I tried the CATFISH NUGGETS... EXCELLENT TASTY BATTER!!! REAL NICE!!! ???

Lex H

Love Love their pulled pork sandwich and the banana ? pudding is the bomb ? . The cashier was so helpful being it was my first time ordering. The price our very affordable for the amount of food you get!

Tylus

Just went there for the first time. Ordered a rib dinner with fries and baked beans. Got brisket with mac n cheese and green beans. Sadly I don't like mac n cheese or green beans and I'm not a big fan of brisket not that I hate it. Decided to just eat because I had to get back to work and mac n cheese was cold. I was the only person there too. Should have checked my order but I was in a hurry so I didn't notice til I was across town. Not a great first experience, probably won't return..

Nutty Auto (Nutty auto)

Food smells great food is bussin but whats not great is when you pick up a order and one of the guys there’s says we don’t do door dash and slams the window on me and I knocked on the window and he said what I said don’t slam the window on me I was asking something he than said to leave I don’t know if he was having a bad day or just doesn’t like work he looks 50 something certain staff disrespectful the one lady there helped me and was very kind overall I will go back for another tasty ? burger

Scott Scarboro

A thin slice of brisket mostly gristle on two pieces of wonder bread. Barely any BBQ sauce. Meat tasted freezer burnt. $11 no sides. Wings... Not crispy, no seasoning, bland and served cold. Worst BBQ ever.

Yvette Klingman

Not the best.act like you need them I don't wont return.go see for yourself.nothin to write home about.there are other places

Tiffany Wilson

Terrible Service , attitude, they run out of menu items and the food isn’t good spend your money elsewhere

Robert Ghozt Robinson

the food was wonderful the service was great the prices were Fair I would recommend this to anyone

Syree Boutiette

Food was good, but the customer service was horrible. I went there excited to support local and was greeted by being ignored then asked “what do you want”. I tried to save the conversation by being friendly but was continuously shut down by a disgusting attitude. I wish the customer service was better because I did like my meal. But I can’t bring myself to return having been treated the way I was. Work on your friendliness, I’m sure your customer base would pick up if you’d just be kind.

Michael Yerkes

We just had lunch at Baby Mae's Sellersburg and I would highly recommend it. Food was delicious and very well priced! They have everything from Pork to Fish and more! The staff were very friendly and helpful! Cannot wait to visit them again!

Stacie davis

Betty Mae's BBQ awesome place Shady, cool peaceful area to sit. Plenty of parking service was wonderful very nice and friendly and the pulled pork and coleslaw, man it was good definitely will be coming back

william Deitsch

Are catfish fillets are excellent brisket was very good although I found a bone! But then again I could probably find a bone-in anyting. He needs some help down there working. Seems like nice people.

Load More