Brooklyn and The Butcher

This is always one of the best restaurants in Southern Indiana. If you have not been please go and try it out. Really cool place with good food!!

Food and drinks were very delicious. Food came out in a good timely manner. Little louder than expected but overall good dining experience. Would dine here again. Catered very well to the wife for her birthday. Ahi tuna was extremely delicious

Absolutely perfect first time experience! Steak cooked to perfection! Creamy Boursin potatoes were mouth watering! Roasted mushrooms were simple yet amazing! I'm already to come back! Wonderful server as well! I will visit again soon!

Cozy booth, great service and a delicious dinner made for a wonderful anniversary dinner. Thanks for a memorable evening.

Tiffany was amazing! She was so sweet. The service was amazing! The food was just as fantastic as I remember. Perfect date night place. Highly recommend Tiffany. She was absolutely amazing!

This was booked for my son and his girlfriend for prom. They loved it and said the food was great!

Food was outstanding. Service was superb. Very good menu. Steaks were prepared !s ordered. Celebrated granddaughter 's 16th birthday crew made it special for her. Recommend the steaks and the service. Dessert was interesting!

We love to sneak off to the bar seating at B&B. This visit did not disappoint, great drinks, conversation. Only thing negative was wifey's steak, while cooked to order, with a yummy sauce, the meat was cold. Come on, B&B, it's steak, it's what you do!

My husband and I ate at Brooklyn and The Butcher for our 5th wedding anniversary in February and liked it so much we went back for my birthday. We had a 6pm reservation, but arrived early to enjoy happy hour in the bar. Dinner included fresh bread and Wednesdays are half off wine so we got a bottle. We both had steak cooked to perfection and shared several sides including mac and cheese and probably the best brussel sprouts (our server's recommendation) I've ever had. Service was great. There was even a happy birthday card on the table for me from the staff. Brooklyn and The Butcher has definitely become one of our favorites!

Our experience was outstanding! The food was out of this world. The tuna tartare had just the right heat. My fillet was cooked to perfection! The chocolate mousse and ice cream was the sweetest finale!

The hostess was very nice and accommodating. The waiter took forever to take our order. He was hanging out with the kitchen staff that you could see bc their kitchen window is right there in the back dining room. They were all goofing off. We almost left. We went ahead and ordered the tea chicken. It was okay, the broccoli was so hard it was hard to chew. The Chicken was good but the price was sky high for this meal at $32. The steak was dry and bland. The macaroni and cheese was too greasy probably bc of all the extra cheese it had in it. I thought I was going to choke on the Mac n cheese..it was that cheesy. The twice baked potato could of been better.. no sour cream and butter was brought out. The place was nice inside. It would be a good place for a Romantic dinner if you don't dine in the back area where there is a picture of a cow and it's steak parts and where you see the kitchen staff playing around while you're hungry waiting to be waited on.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

My favorite steakhouse in the entire Kentuckiana area! You will spend some money here. But the steak is so delicious I ate my.left overs the next day, cold! And they were still amazing. I had the Oscar Filet! To-die-for!!! So great. And the service is always a

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Filet Mignon Oscar Style with Baked Potato, Caesar Salad

Great place! Food and service always on point.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Charred Octopus

Food was excellent. Large portions on the appetizer. Most fine dining steakhouses you get two bites on the appetizer. Ahi Tuna starter was phenomenal. Our server was perfect. Offered suggestions for various items. We will go back again!

Love the quiet of bar area for early dining. Even enjoyable when well behaved bar patrons arrived. Wonderful extra touch dessert to celebrate my wife's birthday. Will definitely be back soon.