Brooklyn and The Butcher

We have gone here for dinner with friends and family numerous times and always enjoyed our time. We recently had a company dinner here also and Charles and Hannah were great to work with throughout the process!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason the server was attentive and friendly and helpful. We shared a filet Brooklyn style with carrots and red potatoes. Carrots were good but not the best I’ve ever had. But very edible. Cream potatoes were some of best we have had. Steak was cooked perfect. They gave us a post card with a note for anniversary which was nice touch. Drinks were overpriced in my opinion for the amount received. Had the bourbon colada. Was very very good but with the amount of ice it literally made for a few sips Atmosphere for 6 pm on Sunday was perfect. Quaint and fairly quiet I have been here in past where is us obnoxiously loud. Anyway I would recommend based on the overall experience and will go back again in the future.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

One of the best steakhouses we've ever eaten at. Friendly service and great steaks. Have been back and will go back again..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food, great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Came here for mine and my spouses anniversary dinner, and was greeted with a custom greeting card on the table, the atmosphere was 10/10, the food was DIVINE, and everything there that we got was amazing. If I could give it a higher rating, I would, I cannot recommend this place enough if you're planning something big, and want to splurge a little bit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went there on our anniversary and the atmosphere- food- drinks were just outstanding!!!!! We LOVED it!! Highly recommend the place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The meal was great. Our server, Alexis, was fantastic. She was so bubbly and friendly we wanted to invite her to join us! A couple of areas for improvement: 1-increased signage and direction for those who cannot negotiate the stairs at the main entrance, 2-maybe have larger parties compete for noise on the same room and a separate room for smaller, less loud parties. Otherwise, we had a great time and I won't let it be so long before I am back there again!

We came here for our 12th anniversary dinner. First time here. Alexis was our server and she was extremely nice with a ton of enthusiasm and made us feel like family. We enjoyed everything about our dinner except the fact that they sat us next to a 10 top of ladies who extremely loud. We should of asked to move but didn't. We would recommend this place to anyone looking for a great dinner and Alexis even brought us some chocolate covered strawberries for desert on the house. Alexis gets 10 Stars. Thank you Alexis, we might see you again. Stephanie & Patrick

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

First, I want to highlight the positives of our visit. We were greeted and seated promptly upon arrival, and after a brief wait, our server took our drink order. Both beverages were excellent, and the crab cake appetizer was delicious — a strong start to the evening.

However, as the meal went on, several issues arose that impacted our overall experience. When it came time to order entrées, we were hoping for more detailed guidance, but our server seemed unfamiliar with the menu and mostly shared personal preferences rather than helpful recommendations. We both ordered the filet mignon, accompanied by macaroni and cheese and Brussels sprouts.

The salads served before the main course were disappointing, as the lettuce had pink edges — an indication it was beginning to spoil. When our entrées arrived, my husband’s steak was slightly overcooked, though mine was cooked to my liking. Our primary concern, however, was the flavor and quality of the steaks. As frequent guests at high-end steakhouses in the Louisville area, we had high expectations for a $50 filet. Unfortunately, the steaks lacked seasoning, were somewhat dry (despite being cooked to medium), and ultimately did not meet the standard we anticipated.

The macaroni and cheese was also underwhelming — quite bland and lacking depth of flavor. On a more positive note, the Brussels sprouts were excellent. For dessert, I was excited to try the raspberry cheesecake, but it tasted more like a pre-made frozen option than a house-made dessert, which was disappointing.

I did attempt to reach out to management before posting this review but received no response. While there were some enjoyable aspects of our visit, the overall experience did not match the quality or value we expected, especially given the price point.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

My time here was wonderful. The food/drink were great and the waiter, Jason, was so attentive and patient with all my needs. The experience and atmosphere was a 10/10. Great place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing steak house, check it out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My wife and I went here for our first date before we were married, andnow we go whenever she wants the most amazing steak in the state.
This place has been one of my favorite places since I first went years ago after they opened. Great food, amazing drink options, and the atmosphere 👌
But the service is flawless!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had a great time here for our anniversary, the server Alexis was very friendly and offered up good recommendations. The charcuterie board as an appetizer was wonderful, and the prime ribeye was cooked to perfection. The side dishes were great too, and were plenty big for a filling meal. Since it was our anniversary they gave us a pair of chocolate covered strawberries at no charge too. Would recommend dining here for anytime or a special occasion.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Service was not good. Water spilled on me as he poured water and didn't apologize of clean up. For the price of the food I didn't think it was worth it personally. Not a place I think I'll go back to. Does have a very nice interior.