Brooklyn and The Butcher
148 E Market St, New Albany
(812) 590-2646
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Outstanding Food and Service as always ! Thank you for a Great Birthday dinner for my wife and mother..
It's a little on the pricier side, but overall a nice experience, especially for a special dinner. Service was very friendly and pacing of food and drink delivery was spot on. The salad, steak and sides were great. The add-on shrimp to the steak was not great. Shrimp had zero taste.
Whatever seasoning was used on the steak really threw off the flavor for me. Just keep the seasoning simple
We came for our anniversary. The butcher board is always a must with the amazing honey goat cheese. Ribeye was flavorful and tender. Everyone has to try the Brussels sprouts; they are the best I've ever had.
Our first experience did not disappoint. Mackenzie was our fabulous server. The food was delicious and the price was on point. Will be back again!
Food was OUTSTANDING! Waitress (Amanda) was AWESOME!!! Most definitely one of the BEST restaurants my wife and I have been to in a sometime. Definitely be back soon.
Very relaxing and delicious food. Service excellent. Loved that background music and noise was subtle enough to have conversations with others at our table.
The restaurant was not busy at all for a Friday evening at 7:30. But we waited forever for waters and to place our order. When we finally saw the server they kept apologizing as there was a party of 20 in the basement. It took forever to finally get our food and it was not great They did nothing to make up for the slow service filling tickets took about 1.5 hours. Too many good steak places around. They need to make changes and need to make them quick
Servers Amanda and Alex are fabulous. They go above and beyond to make your dining experience special.
Service was phenomenal and food and drinks were very good. Really enjoyed the tuna tartare.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is always one of the best restaurants in Southern Indiana. If you have not been please go and try it out. Really cool place with good food!!
Food and drinks were very delicious. Food came out in a good timely manner. Little louder than expected but overall good dining experience. Would dine here again. Catered very well to the wife for her birthday. Ahi tuna was extremely delicious
Absolutely perfect first time experience! Steak cooked to perfection! Creamy Boursin potatoes were mouth watering! Roasted mushrooms were simple yet amazing! I'm already to come back! Wonderful server as well! I will visit again soon!
Cozy booth, great service and a delicious dinner made for a wonderful anniversary dinner. Thanks for a memorable evening.
Tiffany was amazing! She was so sweet. The service was amazing! The food was just as fantastic as I remember. Perfect date night place. Highly recommend Tiffany. She was absolutely amazing!
Loading...