Legacy Pizza & Bakery

We went and got our Recbar Reader cookies today, and the lady who helped us was extremely friendly and kind. We had actually never heard of Legacy Pizza before this, and already had lunch plans for today, but we will definitely be returning. Top tier customer service… not to mention the cookies were DELICIOUS!!

Ordered from legacy many times! Never an issue with food quality or service. I really appreciate the many different offerings they bring to downtown. And everything I’ve had so far has been great! Hands down would recommend to anyone wondering.

A local pizzareia serving sandwiches, strombolis, pizza, calzones, pasta dishes and desserts like bread pudding and cannolis. The Rob pizza was a thin crust pizza with crust so soft and full of flavor, with an abundant amount of toppings and cheese. The meatball sub was loaded with 6 meatballs, marinara sauce and two types of cheeses. The bread it was served on was baked fresh today. The calzone was remarkable with the addition of four different cheeses. We love supporting independent, local establishments like this hidden gem.

Awesome place. Friendly staff and wonderful food!

Amazing people and company!!! Have plans to eat there but so far absolutely amazing! They have partnered and donated gift cards for our back to school backpack giveaway which is a free event and they went above and beyond!! Absolutely recommend them and will be having dinner there regularly because from what I hear their pizza is the best in the tri-state area!

Once again Legacy holds up! The food is always served hot and delicious, and the desserts (including seasonal) are fantastic!

On our walk from Delaware to California, my boyfriend and I were just a couple of sweaty hikers making our way into New Albany when we came across Legacy Pizza, a great place to sit down, cool off, and have an early dinner. Everything was great, we thought it was cool and different that they have spaghetti squash dishes. The freshly baked bread was amazing, I wish that I had enough room in my stomach to try one of their desserts as well. Great food, great service!

We had two different pizzas: the cheeseburger and a BYO. Both of them delicious with perfect topping ratios and surprisingly light crusts but not thin. Loved it. We also had dessert that did not disappoint: a snickers cheesecake and the pistachio cannoli 10/10-I can’t wait to go back!

We loved this place! We brought our baby and toddler along with a couple of our friends for lunch. They accommodated us with a large round booth. The server was very kind, attentive and helpful as we decided what we wanted. My husband and I ordered a classic pizza. It was delicious as everything from the crust, sauce, cheese and toppings were fresh. After our meal, the server brought our daughter some fruit snacks. We are already planning our next trip there.

We had the calzones for dinner and they were incredible. Curbside service was wonderful. All ingredients are very flavorful and fresh. I highly recommend Legacy. I will be back very soon.

I didnt go in to eat but when I pulled up to curbside I didnt wait to get my order. It was pretty fast and the food is amazing. I've never had a new York style pizza but I could imagine this is what it is for sure. Got the large works and it was amazing also had brownies and those were good too! I will be back again!

Once again Legacy was amazing. I ordered something new tonight and it didn't disappoint. If you like pineapple on your pizza the Hurricane is for you. The pineapple was sweet and the red onions and pepperdews balanced it out beautifully. And as always the pistachio cannoli was outstanding!!!

Legacy is one of our favorite places! There are so many great options on the menu that never disappoint ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We just moved to New Albany and came here to try the “baked spaghetti” based on a review we saw, I was super sad that there was no baked spaghetti and that they wouldn’t make one despite there being other baked pastas 😭 BUT on the bright side- we absolutely loved the calzone, cannoli, and tiramisu. I will say though, don’t be afraid to use strong espresso for the tiramisu! The coffee flavor is very light, still delicious and very fresh though. We will be coming back for more calzones or to try a pizza, plus we must try more bakery treats!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

We love Legacy! Everything is always delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5