New Age Baking Company

125 E Michigan St, New Carlisle
(574) 988-0068

Recent Reviews

Kandace O.

Met the owner and her brother-in-law, first time visiting. They were so nice and when I had to run back in to get a special request after I had already left they gave it to me on the house. Great people. Great donuts. And I cannot wait to try the cannolis!

Cary Smith

The doughnuts are the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut

Alana Boothe

My family is obsessed with these donuts, they're HUGE! The breakfast pizza is another obsession of ours. For Christmas this year, we got a platter of sugar cookies... o.m.g. new obsession!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Bailey

Very friendly!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut

Kim Ham

I tried twice to give our local bakery business and twice I had to go elsewhere to make my purchase. I called last week to see if they had or could make a coconut cream pie - whoever answered the phone didn’t know and had to check then told me very rudely no. A couple years ago I called to inquire about a banana cake & they had to check because they weren’t sure and I was told it was a “specialty cake” and that a 9” round cake would be $65.00. So much for supporting a local small town business.

Service: 1

Mr. Smarts

Always more than pleased with any products from New Age baking. If you haven't had a breakfast pizza from them, you are missing out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut, Cinnamon Roll, Apple Fritter, Birthday Cake

Tyler Ryder

Genuinely the best donuts i've ever had.

Andrew P.

Dropped by here on a Saturday morning on our way to South Bend as we were looking for some quick morning sugar to wake us up. The lady working the desk was nice. Our group all got a donut each. I found my donut to be solid, but definitely not the best I've ever had. I will say that the sizing of the donuts is a little larger than I'm used to so I think you get a good bang for your buck.

Toni Harris

Literally the BEST cinnamon rolls ever! They even have chocolate chip cookies! Not to mention the donuts are nearly the size of my head! Such a treat! ??

Ashley Smith

My husband and I absolutely love this place! The breakfast pizza is to die for!

Marjorie Olah

Real organized lots of sugar. Muffins are great also.

Brenda Catchings

You can feel the love in the food, the owners are amazing and make you feel like family! The donuts are delectably delicious!!

Kelli G.

We were excited to see the bakery was open today so we decided to indulge ourselves and support a small local business. What a disappointment. We got 6 specialty donuts, 2 long johns, 2 Bismarck, and 2 jelly. It was $15 for the 6 of them but ok, small business and good donuts are worth it right? Boy were we wrong!!! such a disappointment!!!!! They jelly ones were fair at best, the other 4 were awful. Filling was nonexistent, less than a tablespoon!! I pulled it apart to see if there was anything in there. They were dry and crust, tastes worse than day old. I've never had yeast donuts that were so dry they were crumbly when your tried to eat them. Truely a disappointment and waste of money.

Robert Buscher

The Donuts are awesome and so are the people who own and operate the business. Best donuts around.

Jeffery Rucker

Great donuts,,go early they sell them fast

Load More