Christine’s Creative Cookie Co.

2011 Bundy Ave Suite 7, New Castle
(317) 910-2827

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dante Raffaelli

Absolutely great she made custom Super Bowl cookies for my son’s birthday party. Great job definitely would recommend.

Emma Voisard

I definitely recommend Christine. She is super sweet and has great customer service!! She does beautiful and tasty work she made my cake and cookies for my wedding and everything was perfect!!

Denise Miller-Thompson

AMAZING!!!!!!! That is all there is to say!!!!!

Kyle Goolsby

$5 for a cookie sounds worse on paper than the actual experience! It's a HUGE cookie you can share or let everyone try a bite and sample multiple and they're all so GOOD! Def going back so many things still to try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chelsea Spradlin

We love going to see Christine and get delicious treats so I knew we had to order custom cookies for my oldest’s birthday and she knocked it out of the park. They are delicious and decorated perfectly!

Jessica Mitchell

Her shop is beautiful and everything is a super treat! My kid especially loves her cookies. They are so soft and rich I can't wait to try the cheese cakes and different goodies!The owner is as sweet as pie and a joy to work with! She really does makes works of edible art!

Kid-friendliness: I've had her make cookies for multiple occasions and she makes whatever you could imagine

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christy Ragle

My coworker just picked up goodies from this bakery for our team and the products are amazing! Support this wonderful, talented local bakery!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shanna Johnson Broyles

The almond vanilla cupcakes! From the insanely moist cake to the amazing almond flavored icing all the down to the sugary sprinkles… Do NOT sleep on this flavor. It is anything, but “vanilla.”

David Spencer

Awesome cookies and cheesecake!!! Coooookies!!! Headed there now!

Aubrey Lindsey

I adore Christine and her bakery is the cutest! From the color scheme to the decor, it's stunning. The wide array of sweet treats is something our town needed. You MUST try a cheesecake cup. The best I've ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...