Restaurants in New Castle

Best Restaurants in New Castle

Grill't 535 N Memorial Dr, New Castle Barbecue • $

Customers` Favorites

French Fries
Loaded Fries
Half Rack of Ribs
Spicy BBQ
Seasoned Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Southern Green Beans
Macaroni and Cheese
Smoke N Barrel Pulled Chicken

“What an experience! Friendly, welcoming, and warm are a few adjectives I would use. Jesus’ light shines through them and the food is great. When I go back I will ask for sauce on the side because I like to dip my ribs in sauce. Great place to have a beautiful experience!?”

5 Superb121 Reviews
Park Restaurant 1651 S Memorial Dr, New Castle American • $

Customers` Favorites

Onion Rings
Country Fried Steak
Peanut Butter Pie
Side Salad
Chicken and Noodles

“came for the fried chicken, stayed for the absolutely phenomenal service! Tonya was a real delight and took great care of us. I left very full and very happy. it's pretty rare to find a great meal for under $30 for 2 people these days, but this restaurant did it. I am most definitely coming back with an appetite!Kid-friendliness: kids menu with plenty of options even for picky peters and penelopes :)”

4.6 Superb111 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Dog
Wine Topper

“And I've been there about 4 or 5 times it's a really nice place with really awesome drinks he will try to make you whatever he can and it's good to taste different things they have different flavors of beer cider all kinds and they have a wine slush machine you just have to go there and check it out if you passed it up on broad Street you need to watch for it and go in there and visit it's a nice place to sit back and gather your thoughts not a bunch of loud rude people and they even have things set up outside where you can drink out there on the patio they both put their whole heart and everything they do”

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Pizza King 2500 Broad St, New Castle Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Meat Pizza
Royal Feast Pizza with Bread Sticks
Royal Feast with Extra Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks with Cheese
Medium Pepperoni Pizza
A Friend Eating Pizza
Small Sausage Pizza

“Tip: order light sauce. Otherwise this place piles on the toppings and makes their food amazing. Probably some of the most friendly staff I've encountered. Definitely my pick in town.”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews

“Been trying to get my hands on her food for weeks now. Made a stop today on Madison Street in Muncie. Trust and believe; I was not disappointed. I bought the Jerky Chicken Tacos and they are ???!!. So different from any other Taco you have EVER had. I also brought the Pineapple Glazed Chicken dinner. It comes with the rice& beans and your choice of an additional side. I chose the fried cabbage. This dish was on point also. the rice is perfectly cooked well seasoned and not to sweet. The cabbage is spicy, semi sweet and cooked to perfection with still a little crunch to the cabbage. The pinicle of the meal was the Pineapple Glazed Chicken. Fall off the bone done, succulent, sweet spicy and ohhh so juicy. Talk about a real Nap Time Meal. lol. I will be visiting them again soon.”

5 Superb18 Reviews
Mad Hyena Bar & Grill 1538 Indiana Ave, New Castle Bar & Grill • $

Customers` Favorites

Bologna and American
Sandwich with Chips
Mozzarella Sticks
Waffle Cut Fries
Hot Cheese Balls
Chicken Tenders
Fried Mushrooms
Cheese Sandwich
Onion Rings

“Walked in and felt immediately welcome. Locally-owned small business, recently upgraded, food was great, beer was cold. Will def go back anytime we are in New Castle.”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews
China Castle 2929 S 14th St, New Castle Food • $$

Customers` Favorites

Sweet and Sour Chicken
Shrimp Fried Rice
Honey Chicken
Crab Rangoon
Wonton Soup
甜酸鸡Sweet & Sour Chicken
Shrimp & Chicken Hunan Style
Boneless Spare Ribs
Seafood Delight
Hot & Sour Soup

“Outstanding food and service!!! Ordered a General Tso’s Chicken and it was packed full!!! Huge portion and flavor was great!!! Less than 10 min. to wait!!!! Great experience once again!”

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Old Ice House Tavern 1550 Walnut St, New Castle Bar & Grill • $

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich
Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich
Beer Battered Pickle Chips
Steak Sandwich with Bacon
Jalapeno Cheddar Bites
Hamburger Cheeseburger
Fried Mushrooms

“This bar is a local tradition for New Castle. There are regulars at the counter each day. They have pool tables, a juke box and a lively atmosphere. I sampled the steak sandwich and WOW. They have meat from Rihms locker, and mix it with cheese and onions on a buttery grilled bun. Excellent diner style steak sandwich. The decor is ecclectic and plenty to look at while you have your beer. It reminds me of the Toby Keith song, "I love this bar." There are bikers, farmers, firemen, hippies, chain smokers and boozers. You can go here to laugh and have a conversation with a stranger, or sit in silence at the bar with a drink. It is a true classic "dive bar". It is locally owned, and you can tell that the owner truly cares about her patrons. We stopped in on the evening of Thanksgiving. I thought it was so neat that the owner had assembled a Thanksgiving dinner for all of her normal patrons. You don't find a family, "we are all in this together" atmosphere like that very often anymore. Warning: they do allow smoking.”

4.5 Superb36 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

2 lb Cod Fish Sandwich
lb Breaded Tenderloin
Lays Potato Chips
Hot Cheese Balls
Sausage Sandwich
1 2 lb Hamburger
Fried Mushrooms
Chicken Planks
Scooter Wings
Mini Corndogs

“Food is fresh and delicious! No sauce needed for the steak. Pretty busy on a Wednesday! I see why now!!!Friendly fun atmosphereThe new owner treats ya like ya been friends forever!Definitely feel welcomed!!”

4.9 Superb15 Reviews
Temptations 2001 S Memorial Dr, New Castle American • $

Customers` Favorites

Mashed Potatoes Mashed Potatoes
Noodles Chicken Pot Pie
Tenderloin Sandwich
Macaroni Salad
Beef Manhattan
Baked Beans
Cobb Salad
W Gravy

“We rented "The Gather" for family Thanksgiving." It was very nice, clean and comfortable and perfect for our family. We will diffently be renting it again. Very well decorated.”

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
L&K Produce 2419 IN-3, New Castle Donuts • $

“Love getting fresh produce here. Always great. Always feel like my business is appreciated. Got sweet corn this past weekend. Some of the best I have ever had. Also got several other things. If you want good produce at a good price, you definitely need to check them out!”

4.7 Superb18 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Fried Ice Cream
Jalisco Fajita
Steak Fajitas
Cheese Dip
Chicken Fajita Burrito and the Side Topping Tasted Like Soap
Beef Soft Tacos with Extra Hot Sauce
Unlimited Chips and Salsa
Tacos De Carne Asada
Fajita Los Amigos

“We arrived at the restaurant a little after 1:00 pm. The front door was jammed with people checking out and another couple and ourselves waiting to get in. We were promptly seated and asked what we would like to drink. Our drinks were served in less than 5 min with our salsa and warm chips. Our order was taken and it wasn't 15 min our meals were served. Our waiter checked with us several times to see if we needed anything else. Our meals were delicious! We had to ask for take home containers as our portions were huge. We live approximately 17 miles from this restaurant and it is worth the trip! Nothing comes close to Los Amigos in our town. Highly recommend!”

4.3 Superb53 Reviews
Culver’s 605 S Memorial Dr, New Castle American • $

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Chicken Sandwich Combo

“This is the best quick service restaurant in New Castle! My wife and I chose Culver’s for a quick dinner tonight and we were thoroughly impressed. Food was great, service was exceptional and the whole dine in experience was a pleasure. The pretzel bites are a must!”

4.2 Good82 Reviews


Primo 1326 Broad St, New Castle Italian • $

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Breadsticks with Alfredo
Caesar Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Baked Spaghetti
Margarita Pizza

“Booked the restaurant for a party. Everything was set up and food was prepared as ordered and delicious. 80 people served. Had a great experience. Highly recommend for get togethers. Husband and I have returned several times for meals. We have not been disappointed. We will be returning soon. Check out their new pizza menu.”

4.3 Superb33 Reviews
Early Bird Diner 211 S 15th St, New Castle American • $

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Sticks
Country Fried Steak or Chicken
Onion Rings

“We went to the Early Bird Cafe today for breakfast. It was pretty good; I ate the biscuits and gravy. Hubby ate a burger and fries. Coffee was weak but everything else was good ?!”

4.3 Superb21 Reviews

More Restaurants in New Castle

The Press Coffee Co 225 S 14th St, New Castle Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

Mocha Latte and Honey Latte

“A regular favorite of mine! The seasonal lattes are always great, but their daily brew, Americanos, matcha lattes, and cold brews are good too! I appreciate the latte art <3”

4.9 Superb40 Reviews
Whitetail Sweet Shop 2020 S Memorial Dr Ste I, New Castle Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Sundae
Raspberry Truffle

“In Newcastle for a kart race and we wanted some ice cream so we went here. Awesome staff very modern while still feeling “homey” and comfortable. The ice cream tacos were super good and they made a little girls day by making a custom ice cream bowl so she wouldn’t have to make any hard choices!”

4.9 Superb31 Reviews

“We love going to see Christine and get delicious treats so I knew we had to order custom cookies for my oldest’s birthday and she knocked it out of the park. They are delicious and decorated perfectly!”

5 Superb7 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Salad Croissant

“I've lived in New Castle for about a year and a half and I regret that it's taken me so long to try this place out. It is wonderful! The grab and go food is so delicious and convenient! I got the chicken salad and veggies with house ranch. I wanted to try everything! It all looked so good! I'll be a regular!”

4.8 Superb6 Reviews

“Clean, friendly and great food!Best times on Friday nights, good place to unwind..They also have a great selection of beer and wines.Only place in town I will go!”

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Ky's American Bistro 1333 Broad St, New Castle American • $

Customers` Favorites

Salad Bar

“My family and I decided we would try out this new restaurant that everyone has been raving about, Ky’s American Bistro and let me just tell you, we were very impressed with everything. The food was AMAZING and the service was just as great! Their salad bar is PHENOMENAL, they had two options of fresh greens, lots of fresh toppings and plenty of little side such as potato salad and pudding to go with it. They make the salad bar all new with fresh items everyday! We were also pleased to learn from a waiter that anything not eaten from the salad bar during the day is donated to a local shelter in town for people to enjoy! So not only is the food good but the owner is such a blessing to those people in need! Love the decor, loved the calm atmosphere! Will be back again soonKid-friendliness: I love their kids menu, it has great options! Also the young man who seated us had an amazing idea to place us at a table in front of the window so our little guy could watch the cars to keep him entertained! What a smart idea!”

4.3 Superb8 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Taco Pizza
Kids Spaghetti
Cheese Pizza
Veggie Grinder
Roast Beef Grinder
Mancinos Stromboli
Meatball Grinder
Breadsticks with Cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch

“My main go-to restaurant in New Castle! Love their grinders, pizza and breadsticks! PS for all restaurants- please consider sanitizing items such as menus and salt/pepper/cheese shakers between customers, thanks”

4 Good63 Reviews
Cafe Royal 1451 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

Cafe Royal
Breakfast Sandwich
Club Sandwich

“Everything was great. They also set up outside tables and chairs for viewing the eclipse at no charge. They also stayed open for extended hours to support this event. There was no charge for parking or using outside items. Others in the area were charging a premium for similar services.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options.”

4 Good30 Reviews
Ming's Garden 119 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Chinese • $

Customers` Favorites

Popcorn Chicken
Fortune Cookies
Egg Roll
Black Pepper Chicken
Hunan Shrimp
Spring Roll
Chicken Stick

“Anybody that says this place ain't good is lying to themselves, simple world ending prices go up but atleast I can gorge on some crab Ragoon and banana pudding at the same time. Doing good things for this city.(calling out sarah)”

3.9 Good45 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Also a Beef Taco Salad
Happy Birthday to Me
Chicken Quesadillas
Tacos and Rice
Poblano Steak
Esteak Salad

“Kid-friendliness: The food here is always fresh and hot. The servings are very good and the owners always greet us with a smile. I might add that the service here is extremely fast with little to no wait. Why do fast food when you can get dine in or carry out here in the same time frame”

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Sned's 1914 I Ave, New Castle Barbecue • $

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Pulled Pork Tacos
Chicken Tenders
Smoked Pulled Pork Nachos
Cheese Balls and Skinnies
Chicken Tender Basket
Pulled Pork Sliders
Large Onion Rings
Hot Cheese Balls

“Ordered for 4 people and got enough for 2 meals out of it! I had the dirty burger and loaded wedges, wife got the club and loaded wedges, son chicken fingers loaded fries, and daughter smoked mac and cheese and loaded fries. Was all GREAT, but I gotta say, that mac and cheese was killer!! Check this place out, you won't be disappointed!!”

3.9 Good28 Reviews
Twin Lions 1327 Broad St, New Castle Bar • $$

“Cathy and I had a great time last evening at Twin Lions! Great soups, outstanding atmosphere and excellent drinks. Terri and her team made us feel right at home! 5 Stars+!!”

3.8 Good4 Reviews
Ming's Buffet Indiana Ave, New Castle Chinese • $

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Meet with Pasta

“Anybody that says this place ain't good is lying to themselves, simple world ending prices go up but atleast I can gorge on some crab Ragoon and banana pudding at the same time. Doing good things for this city.(calling out sarah)”

3.8 Good43 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Potato Wedges
Chicken Strips
Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Gallon of Sweet Tea
Suppose to Be Some Kind of Gravy
Famous Chicken Sandwich Combo
Regular Livers or Gizzards
Spicy Jumbo Dippers Meal
2 Piece Breast Strip Meal

“I had a wonderful experience at this Lee’s location yesterday with my spouse. One of the workers told us that we were going to each get another piece of chicken to our three-piece meals. We each already had more than three, but we got another big piece each as she said what we got were small pieces. She went above and beyond to give us a great experience.Additionally, the potato wedges, coleslaw, and biscuit were good.”

3.8 Good48 Reviews
Weenee World 601 N Memorial Dr, New Castle Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Corn Dog
Onion Rings
Banana Split
Deep Fried
Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich
Chocolate Ice Cream

“I always make a stop here when visiting the area. It's very popular and busy right now with summer around the corner, but the food and ice cream is worth every second in line. Staff always friendly, efficient, and orders come out accurate and hot (or cold depending, lol) The jumbo breaded tenderloins are amazing! I love the onion rings! Generous size and amount of chili on coney dogs. I've never been disappointed in my order here.”

3.8 Good84 Reviews
Domino's Pizza 609 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Tater Tots
Pepperoni Pizza
Lava Cake

“We ordered a pizza and they just brought us the wrong one. No big deal. They remade our whole order and brought us deserts and a drink we didn’t order plus an extra pizza. Wasn’t even that big of a deal we just wanted to get the right one. They were back within like 15 mins with the right one and extra.”

3.7 Good40 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Meat Feast Pizza
Pepperoni Feast
Nacho Cheese

“It's a take-out only place. Pizza King is spread throughout Indiana. It's more costly than chain pizza restaurants.

3.6 Good21 Reviews
Hot Head Burritos 1480 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Mexican • $

Customers` Favorites

Cheetos Flamin

“I really like this place. Their mango habanero sauce is amazing.I struggle with the price. It seems like, for 2 people, the price is always high. After saying that though, we still like this place and still spend the money for the food.I have Celiac Disease so, I always get a bowl. The staff always change their gloves and help keep things as safe as the can.We’ll be back.”

3.7 Good42 Reviews
El Chile Poblano 3015 S 14th St, New Castle Mexican • $

Customers` Favorites

House Margaritas
Texas Fajitas Fresh Off the Stove
Enchilada and Quesadilla
El Grande Margherita
Taco Chile Relleno
Fajitas Hawaiian
Taco & Enchilada

“Excellent friendly service, food, margaritas. Instant chips and salsa. House Margarita as of this review tastes excellent and the small size - under $5. Will be back!”

3.7 Good54 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Sexy Lobster Roll
California Roll
Fried Rice
Miso Soup and Salad with Ginger Dressing
Salad with Ginger Dressing and Miso Soup
Dynamite Roll and Godzilla Roll
Lunch Chicken Teriyaki Bento
Spicy Salmon Roll
Eel Cucumber Roll

“Fantastic food! Took a while to get the food but we had a big party and it was worth the wait! Wish the upper windows on the eastern side were more shaded. Other than that it was very delightful and the staff was super friendly!”

3.6 Good27 Reviews
Long John Silver's 520 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Fast Food • $

Customers` Favorites

French Fries
6pc Grilled Shrimp Basket
Hushpuppies 6 Hushpuppies
Fish & Shrimp Platter
12 Piece Family Meal
Fish N Chicken
Fried Shrimp
1 PC Chicken

“The outside parking area was clean and clear of trash and debris. The restaurant was clean and easy to move around in. The employees were friendly and helpful and prompt in taking our orders and delivering our food hot at our table. Great dinning experience!”

3.6 Good36 Reviews
Scooter's Coffee 1705 S Memorial Dr, New Castle Coffee Shops • $

Customers` Favorites

Everything Sausage Egg Bagel

“I brought my wife here approximately three months ago for the first time. I had always heard good things and thought it would be a nice change. Our first visit was phenomenal and we loved everything about it. We have continued to come back ever since and have loved every visit since. There is something for everyone and the food and drinks are amazing. I highly recommend Scooters Coffee.Kid-friendliness: They include multiple items on the menu for the kids including drinks and snacks.”

3.6 Good47 Reviews