Restaurants in New Castle

“Grill't serves delicious barbecue, with options like the popular pulled hog sandwich combo, which features finely chopped and piled-high meat. The restaurant is known for its friendly service, with the owner and his mom often engaging with customers to ensure a pleasant dining experience. Whether you're a meat-lover or a parent looking for a kid-friendly spot, Grill't is a great choice.”

“Park Restaurant offers delicious meals such as veggie omelette and fried chicken. The servers provide phenomenal service, making customers feel delighted. The restaurant provides a kids menu with various options. Despite some minor order mishaps, the tasty food and friendly service make it worth the visit. Customers highly recommend trying their lunch and dinner menus.”

“China Castle serves outstanding food with generous portions and great flavor. Orders are ready quickly, often in under 15 minutes, and are accurately prepared. Their menu items, such as General Tso's Chicken, come with a substantial serving size and plenty of meat. Online ordering is available, and the prices are reasonable. Overall, China Castle provides a great experience with fresh and delicious Chinese food.”

“The Blue River Taphouse is a welcoming spot with a wide variety of drinks, including different flavors of beer, cider, and wine. The atmosphere is relaxed and quiet, making it a great place to unwind and gather one's thoughts. The owners are friendly and dedicated to their craft. The menu is limited, but the chili dogs are a highlight. The taphouse also features local art and a mural about the beer-making process. It's a great spot to visit on Thursdays for trivia nights.”

“Pizza King is a popular restaurant known for its delicious pizza and friendly service. The restaurant is a must-visit in Indiana, offering a variety of options such as the Original Sub and the Royal Feast. They also have vegetarian pizzas and salads for those with dietary restrictions. While they do not deliver, customers can opt for carry-out. The restaurant is kid-friendly and wheelchair accessible, making it a great choice for families. Pizza King's unique pizza cut and amazing service have made it a favorite for many, including those who travel from out of state.”

“Los Amigos Mexican Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with its prompt service, delicious meals, and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is known for its warm chips, flavorful salsa, and generous portions that often require take-home containers. Customers praise the polite and attentive staff, who ensure a satisfactory visit. The restaurant is described as kid-friendly, with a menu catering to young diners, and wheelchair accessible, with a ramp at the entrance. Overall, Los Amigos Mexican Restaurant is a highly recommended destination for authentic Mexican cuisine and a pleasant dining experience.”

“Ta-Jays Caribbean Delight is a popular spot on Madison Street in Muncie, Indiana. Their Jerky Chicken Tacos are a standout, offering a unique flavor profile. The Pineapple Glazed Chicken dinner is also a must-try, featuring perfectly cooked rice and beans, a spicy and semi-sweet fried cabbage side, and tender, juicy chicken. Other options include beef patty and j*** pork and chicken meals with collard greens and rice and beans. The owners are welcoming and kind, making it a great spot to dine.”

“Temptations offers top-quality food at affordable prices with excellent service. Visitors praise the welcoming atmosphere and fast food service. The vegetable soup with chicken wrap is a standout dish. The restaurant's rental space, "The Gather," is clean, comfortable, and well-decorated. Located in New Castle, it's a must-visit for those in the area, with a friendly and efficient staff that ensures a great dining experience.”

“Old Ice House Tavern is a local tradition in New Castle, known for its lively atmosphere and eclectic decor. This classic "dive bar" has a dedicated following of regulars, including bikers, farmers, firemen, hippies, and chain smokers. The tavern offers a variety of fare, including the popular steak sandwich, made with meat from Rihms locker, and the breaded tenderloin. Breakfast options, such as biscuits and gravy, are also a hit. With a "family, we are all in this together" atmosphere and a warm welcome from the owner, Old Ice House Tavern is a true gem.”

“L&K Produce offers a wide range of fresh produce, including flavorful patties and sweet corn. Their produce is always fresh and of high quality, with options like freeze-dried peaches and beef tongue. The team is appreciated and valued, making customers feel welcome and appreciated. Overall, L&K Produce provides excellent produce and a great experience at a good price.”

“The Mad Hyena Bar & Grill is a locally-owned small business that has recently been upgraded. The restaurant offers great food and cold beer in a welcoming atmosphere. The owners and employees are friendly and provide an enjoyable experience for customers. While there may have been some issues with licensing and regulations, the overall reviews indicate it is a popular and well-liked establishment.”

“Hilby's Bar and Grill offers a welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff, including the new owner who treats customers like old friends. The food is fresh and delicious, with no need for sauce on the steak. The bar serves reasonably priced drinks, and the music is a mix of classic rock and karaoke.”

“Primo, a restaurant with a very neat and beautiful interior, offers an enjoyable dining experience with great food and helpful, friendly employees. The tenderloin and salad are praised as delicious, while the wild mushroom ravioli is described as spectacular, with rich, creamy mushrooms and a surprising sweetness from the marinated mushrooms on top. The Cajun chicken penne and Cajun shrimp pasta are also noted for their excellent flavor and spice. The breadsticks with Alfredo are excellent, and the restaurant has a wide selection of bottled and draft beers. While the water is not recommended, the overall experience at Primo is consistently enjoyable.”

“Ky's Kreations Lunch Box in New Castle offers delicious grab-and-go food, ideal for a quick and satisfying meal. The chicken salad, whether served with veggies and house ranch or on a bed of spinach in a fruit plate, receives high praise for its flavorful and creamy taste. The portion is generous, and customers appreciate the freshness of the ingredients. The owners are noted for their friendliness and helpfulness. This charming eatery is sure to turn first-time visitors into regulars.”

“The Early Bird Diner is a charming restaurant known for its kind staff and consistent food quality. Popular menu items include biscuits and gravy, burgers, fries, and pancakes. The pancakes are particularly praised for their consistent temperature, size, and texture. The customer base is generally friendly, but can be loud. While the coffee may be weak, the sweet iced tea is highly recommended. The diner is a bit pricier than others, but the big portions and excellent quality make it worth it. Unfortunately, it is not open all day.”

“The Press Coffee Co. is a popular spot for coffee lovers, offering a variety of drinks including seasonal lattes, Americanos, matcha lattes, and cold brews. The coffee shop provides a cozy atmosphere with plenty of seating, light snacks, and free WiFi. Friendly and knowledgeable staff serve high-quality specialty drinks, like the unique White Mocha.”

“Whitetail Sweet Shop is a modern and cozy destination offering delicious treats and friendly service. With a wide variety of options, including ice cream tacos and custom bowls, this shop is sure to lift your spirits and leave you with a smile.”

“Christine's Creative Cookie Co. offers a delightful experience with huge, shareable cookies that are soft, rich, and delicious. The shop is beautifully decorated, and the owner creates edible works of art. Custom orders are available for special occasions, and the owner is a joy to work with, making it a great destination for kids and adults alike.”

“Cafe Royal is a popular spot for great food and drinks. They offer gluten-free options and exceptional coffee, including delicious matcha lattes. The breakfast menu is also a highlight. The cafe goes above and beyond, with amenities like outdoor seating for special events and no charge for parking or outside items. Friendly staff, like Laine, provide excellent service and insider recommendations.”

“Culver's is a highly-regarded quick service restaurant in New Castle, offering exceptional service and a pleasing dine-in experience. The food is great, with standout dishes like pretzel bites and cheeseburgers. Friendly and inviting employees, coupled with a well-structured building, make for a pleasant dining experience with no bad experiences reported.”

“Came for class of 2014 reunion! Never been here until now and it's beautiful! Got a huge side of some great onion rings and enjoyed the animal and porch natural feel and the service was one point friendly and gave updates for the wait. Great place ?”

“Mancinos Pizzas and Grinders in New Castle is a local favorite spot for delicious grinders, pizza, and breadsticks. Customers appreciate the buy 2 combo deal, as well as the phenomenal cheesy garlic bread and amazing salad with candied nuts. The ambiance is simple, with orders taken at the counter. While it can get busy, the wait times are reasonable. Some concerns were raised about the parking lot during lunchtime, but the owners showed exceptional kindness by personally shoveling and cleaning the area to assist customers, especially those with mobility challenges. The restaurant's dedication to customer care and tasty food make it a top choice in the area.”

“Top Hat Two - Pizza King is a take-out only spot with limited parking. While pricier than chain pizza restaurants, it's known for its generous toppings and delicious crust. The Royal Feast is a standout option, impressing out-of-state visitors with its abundance of toppings and hot, tasty flavor.”

“Ky’s American Bistro is a fantastic addition to downtown New Castle, praised for its amazing food and great service. The restaurant boasts a phenomenal custom-built salad bar with fresh greens, lots of fresh toppings, and sides like potato salad and pudding, all refreshed daily. Any leftover items are generously donated to a local shelter. The décor is lovely, featuring elements from the building's history as the former Starette movie theatre and seating from the Princess Theatre. The menu caters to every taste, including highly recommended dishes like boom boom shrimp, parmesan crusted chicken breast, and breaded tenderloin, as well as vegetarian and vegan options. Families appreciate the kid-friendly menu and thoughtful seating arrangements. The friendly staff and affordable prices make it a must-visit.”

“El Chile Poblano Mexican Restaurant offers fresh, hot food with fast service and friendly owners. The cozy atmosphere and fair prices make it a favorite spot for Mexican cuisine. While it may get busy with only one server during the day, the quick cooks ensure delicious, filling meals. Kids can enjoy American options like chicken and fries, along with Mexican dishes. Popular choices include the Hawaiian Fajitas and spicy hot burrito.”

“Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken is a welcoming restaurant with friendly staff who go above and beyond to provide a great experience. The food is consistently good, with options like the three-piece meals, potato wedges, coleslaw, and biscuit, as well as juicy chicken breast tenders. The menu offers a variety of options, and even the green beans are recommended. Priced fairly, this restaurant is a great stop with no complaints.”

“Long John Silver's is a fantastic restaurant that offers a great dining experience. The food is crispy and crunchy, with a perfect balance of grease and fat. The service is prompt and friendly, with employees who are quick to take orders and deliver hot food to the table. The environment is clean and easy to navigate, with a clean parking area outside. Diners can enjoy a variety of meals, including the fish, chicken, shrimp platter with green beans and slaw, as well as fish tacos with light Baja sauce. Overall, Long John Silver's is a kid-friendly spot with a great atmosphere and delicious food.”

“Sake Japanese Restaurant Hibachi & Sushi offers tasty food, with a variety of options that don't disappoint. The service can be hit or miss, with some servers being friendly and attentive, while others may come across as rude or unenthusiastic. The atmosphere is plain and can be quite empty, but it can also get busy with large parties. The restaurant could benefit from more shade in certain areas and has seen a decrease in food quality due to inflation. However, prices are considered fair. Despite the rising prices and decline in quality, it remains the only sushi place in the area for some customers.”

“Ming's Garden is a popular restaurant known for its delicious and varied menu. The crab Ragoon and banana pudding are standout dishes, and the popcorn chicken on rice is a must-try. The restaurant offers a wide selection of beef, pork, chicken, and seafood options, as well as sushi. Desserts such as cream puffs, chocolate cake, and pudding are available, although some reviewers found them to be less impressive. The restaurant is known for its fresh and tasty Chinese classics, and the staff is always friendly. Prices are reasonable, with lunch for two costing around $30 or less. The fried wontons are highly recommended. Parking is available, and reviewers suggest trying the fried wontons as a satisfying appetizer.”

“Weenee World is a popular stop with delicious food and ice cream. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring accurate and hot orders. The jumbo breaded tenderloins are amazing, and the onion rings are a favorite. The coney dogs have a generous amount of chili. The restaurant also offers small rides for kids. Visitors love the cheesecurds, bacon cheeseburger, fried hotdogs, and tater tots. Don't miss out on their shakes!”

“Domino's Pizza is known for their delicious pizzas, with 95% of the time being really good. Despite occasional mishaps like forgetting sauces, they are quick to fix any errors when notified. Customers appreciate the deals and fairly cheap prices offered by the restaurant. One reviewer mentioned a negative experience with a lazy delivery driver, but acknowledged that the staff promptly remade the order and provided extra items to rectify the mistake. Overall, Domino's Pizza is a go-to place for tasty pizzas and good deals, with occasional hiccups that are quickly resolved.”

“Ming's Buffet offers a variety of dishes, including chicken and vegetarian options. The dinner buffet is best enjoyed around 5pm when the food is fresh. Parking is available in a shared strip mall. The buffet features dishes like crab Ragoon and banana pudding. The quality of the food is consistently better than expected at a buffet.”

“El Chile Poblano offers excellent friendly service, delicious food, and great margaritas. The restaurant provides instant chips and salsa, and its House Margarita is a great value at under $5. The amount of food served is well worth the price, and the atmosphere is welcoming. The staff is great, and the beer prices are amazing. The restaurant is popular, even on weeknights, and is a great spot for a quick dinner or a stop along the highway.”

“Pizza King is a restaurant known for its great food, with delicious pizzas and breadsticks. While the service can be hit-or-miss, some customers have had positive experiences, even driving long distances to visit this location. However, others have reported issues with training and treatment from management. Despite this, the food remains a highlight, with breadsticks being a particular favorite.”

“Scooter's Coffee is a favorite among locals, offering something for everyone. They serve amazing food and drinks, including holiday drinks, iced lattes, blended coffee, and sweet treats like sugar cookies. The kid-friendly menu includes options for kids, making it a great spot for families. With exceptional drinks and a welcoming atmosphere, Scooter's Coffee is a highly recommended spot.”