6 Best American Restaurants near New Castle

“We like the food here,just wish they would post the specials on Facebook earlier.“

“Inga and the ladies at Temptations are great—they provide fast service, and the food is always fantastic. This is home cooking at a restaurant.“

“I hope the Management Team reads this… I have been beyond impressed with the staff at the New Castle Culver’s. It is evident Management has taken a great deal of time training the staff to be customer friendly. When ordering staff guide you to choices. As many of us hesitate in making choices the response is “we want you to be happy and please take your time”. Food delivery is prompt. As we leave we always get a positive comment like “have a great day” or “ thank you for visiting us”. What is most impressive is these are often young adults who are learning customer service which is being reinforced obviously by the owners and Management Team. I might also add the environment is spotless. We don’t go to Culver’s often but when we do I leave smiling. BTW the grand babies LOVE the ice cream with the kids meals.“

“Went here with a group of friends and had one of those nights you talk about for years. The food was absolutely top notch — seriously, do not skip the fish sandwich, it was next-level OMG! The vibe was fun, welcoming, and energetic without feeling chaotic. I felt accepted. Karaoke took the night to another level with the competition, and had everyone laughing, singing, and just having a blast. You can tell the staff and owners truly take pride in this place — the service was great, the atmosphere felt intentional, and it honestly felt like they wanted everyone there to have a good time. From the food to the music to the people, everything just clicked. We’ll never forget the night we had and will 100% be back.“

“You would expect a place like this in New Castle, but this is a great place to grab a bite to eat and they are never so busy that you can't find a seat. Service is a bit slow, but it's always great tasting fresh food and it's stuff you can't get anywhere else in that city.“

“Absolutely amazing service from Shania B.!
​Stopped by Applebee's and had a fantastic experience. The food was good, and the Voodoo Ranger was excellent, but the absolute highlight of the night was our server/bartender, Shania B. She was absolutely amazing! Shania was super knowledgeable, attentive to every little detail, and brought an incredible energy that made it feel so fun to be back home. Honestly, I wish more places in my hometown had this much class and attention to detail.

​This Applebee's is still one of my favorite places to stop. Being here always brings back great memories of when it first opened, when the guys and I used to hit up Happy Hour daily back in our 20s. It’s awesome to see that the vibe and the service are still top-tier. Ask for Shania if you go—she’s the best!

Big Love, DJ Mixmaster Jazzy Jay“