28 Best American Restaurants in Fishers

“well first bad meal ever at B33. onion rings not cooked enough. ordered traditional hot wings they brought teriyaki hot, pizza had thrown on top raw peppers and tomatoes. we were too worn out to push issues from Indy 500. mentioned to waitress no compensation offered even said " I don't know what the wings looked like, and never saw a pizza B33 look like that. been there 5 times before to flawless meals but this one was disappointing. 1 star.“

“I love all the lunch salads and dinner options for everyone! Have not had a bad meal! There are Al many options!“

“We’ll definitely be back for an encore!“

“Los chilaquiles!!! Muuuuuuuuy ricos!!👏🏻👌🏻🙌🏻🙏🏻“

“This year I decided to enjoy Christmas Day and make it easier on my Grandchildren by ordering the Prime Rib Heat n' Serve Family Dinner. Everyone was pleased and enjoyed the day with the babies, Isaac and Aeris. It was delicious. The only recommendation I would make is better dinner rolls. 👍🙂🎁🎄😋“

““Fishing for Hopliments” was delicious.

Ordered a to-go order of boneless wings. Bartender even looked in the bag to double check the order. Got back to the hotel and they were bone-in wings. Very disappointed.“

“There is a huge lack of sports bars in the area. This place is the quintessential one!“

“Good brew, beyond friendly staff, family atmosphere. Must visit!“

“Great food, excellent service, nice atmosphere, enjoyed stopping here!“

“Went for the first time yesterday for our anniversary lunch date. Our server was amazing and gave us some great recommendations. The food was some of the best I have ever eaten, very bite was FABULOUS! we had stuffed mushrooms, black garlic Caesar salad, Pecan Chicken, and the lemon pepper chicken sandwich with the chips and dip. Everything was absolutely delicious! We will definitely be back.“

“My family and I had a great time here. The service was great. The food was good! The burger and wings were top notch.“

“food was great, and nice kids day activities and special prices!“

“I've been knowing Tony for a few years the only thing I can say is Tony really has a family restaurant me and my family have breakfast at Tony's every Sunday morning g for the past few years and we feel like we are truly part of the family 👍😁.“

“Great plans to stop for a quick drink or a bite to eat. First time here and had a great experience. Bartender and management were very engaging and welcoming. Pork chop seemed a little small but it had great flavor and I was very happy. Thanks again“

“Ordered food at the drive thru on 5/13/26 @ 9 pm, employee unchanged one of the orders, I said clearly one single butterburger combo, got the cheese right this time but entered a dbl butterburger instead. Topping and condiments were scarce, drink tasted watered down and very little carbonation in the Coke. Very disappointed. The last three times I've stopped at a Culvers they unchanged because they half listen or don't omit cheese when asked.“

“Great Fri night poker games 4-6 tables go from 430 to midnight..friendly patriotic atmosphere..snowflake free..Won the raffle last night..(every Friday progressive raffle till winner takes all..got over $100k several times..dart boards..pool tables..great foods..the finest of people here!Kids can play darts, free tables for rummy or spades players..Pot limit Omaha gets going around 4pmOther tables all no limit holdem..bomb pots every hour“

“Aicyla was the best server we have had at Applebee's, ever! She was friendly, knowledgeable of the menu, and attentive. It was a pleasure to talk to her and she was professional and prompt from start to finish. I'll tell everyone I know to ask for her when they visit the 96th St location. The manger was awesome too! She was friendly and professional while seating us. And so positive and welcoming of our compliments we shared regarding Aicyla. By far the best restaurant experience my husband and I have had in a very long time!“

“We really enjoyed our time at Derailed. Excellent service, delicious food, lovely atmosphere. We were celebrating 2 birthdays and they brought out 2 amazing desserts to share. Wonderful experience all around. Rafael was an incredible, kind server who deserves a shout out. We will be back soon.“

“Mike was our server! fantastic service! Great food and friendlies atmosphere! Mike was amazing and would recommend 100% to anyone.“

“This food is so so good top tier food especially the butter biscuits omggggg!! But even better the people are good hearted individuals I thank God he made Jordan my server cause we had some deep conversations and he really touched my heart with what I'm going through I couldn't thank him more for providing me with his service and love I recommend this restaurant everyday of the week if Jordan is going to be my server please ask for him when you come here youll thank me later !! 10/10“

“Tilly outstanding service and personable“

“People that write bad reviews about this place children and afraid of their own shadow. It’s the kind of people that seek out (and cause) problems. If you want a place to have a few beers (or a lot), this is your jam. Friendly and attentive staff with food that is a step above the traditional “bar food.” Dont believe the negative BS. If you want to be you while having drinks, this is your neighborhood bar.“

“the best place to hang out“

“you should make fried zucchini...yummy“

“Great food at what seems like pre-inflation Bidenomics pricing. Very nice to be able to feed my family of four at a nice sit down breakfast for around $50-$60, fast and thoughtful servers. Highly recommend!!“

“Excellent burgers 🍔 & shakes“

“Staff was very friendly and breakfast was quick and timely. IHOP is always overpriced but it’s still good pancakes. The background music was a little bit too loud and distracting for a very early breakfast without a lot of people in the restaurant.
UPDATE: I came back the next week early in the morning and the music was much quieter. It was a significantly more pleasant wake-up experience! Thank you!“