29 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fishers

“Love coming to this place. Staff is always courteous and attentive. Place is always clean. Food is always great. Love the Big Daddy Pizza and of course have to get the salad bar Everytime we come. Thank Noble Romans for always providing a great experience.“

“If you like Indian food and pizza, you’ll love this place. We had the baked masala chips, and a large half chicken tikka, half tandoori chicken pizza. Everything was amazing!“

“First time here tonight. Family raves for the fantastic deep dish pizza and the great salad bar. Stellar staff, wonderful atmosphere. We will be returning very soon!“

“They always have fantastic food but tonight they got me on the excellent service. I was having an issue with the app and so I called in the order. First of all, they answered the phone which rarely happens in restaurants anymore. They were very helpful and took care of my order over the phone. Not once did they make me feel like I was bothering them by not using the app or texting my order. I forgot something so I called back a few minutes later and again they politely took care of my request. Kudos to the staff at Jets Pizza Olio Road in Fishers!“

“Had a retirement party here. Great staff. Nathan, Manager was fantastic to work with! Food was presented well, clean dining room, and chill atmosphere.“

“Great food, best Indian food I have had“

“Growing up, I went here frequently to get their “Mini Murphs.” The other day my mom surprised me with a Mini Murph, and it brought back this staple from my childhood. My entire family has always enjoyed eating from here. It’s a great option for families and those on a budget.“

“Great food fast service welcome to the neighborhood. Nothing else like it for miles.“

“So sad the Allisonville location closed. Papa Murphy’s has been my go to for years. Just recently I started ordering the dairy free cheese and it’s delicious. Guess I will be going to the Olio location from now on. Its a little more of a drive but worth it.“

“Pizza was great! Wings were barely bite size and extremely tiny. Overpriced for there size.“

“well first bad meal ever at B33. onion rings not cooked enough. ordered traditional hot wings they brought teriyaki hot, pizza had thrown on top raw peppers and tomatoes. we were too worn out to push issues from Indy 500. mentioned to waitress no compensation offered even said " I don't know what the wings looked like, and never saw a pizza B33 look like that. been there 5 times before to flawless meals but this one was disappointing. 1 star.“

“Thin crust pizza. 9.0. Was very good. Need one in Muncie Indiana.“

“Came in with my daughter for dinner. 1st time at this location and will most definitely be back. My daughter got the chicken alfredo with bread stix and I got a personal pan meat lovers. Both were very good!

Shout out to the young lady that helped us at the counter!!!! Nevaeh is absolutely WONDERFUL!!! Great personality and spot on customer service!!

The kitchen and BOH staff were really awesome too! Working nonstop on a busy Friday night with great service and positive attitudes. 😊“

“Great place with amazing staff! I called and asked a bunch of question. The staff member went to his manager and made sure all of my questions were answered. I ordered two gluten free pizzas for delivery to a public area and they were able to accommodate it. The delivery driver was fantastic! The pizzas were delicious!“

“Good food and great service“

“Great wings and Pizza! So many tvs to watch! Great place to be!“

“These are some of the kindest employees ever. My son takes tae kwon do next door I'm often dropping in. They always greet me with a smile and are so welcoming. Kindness matters and I appreciate your kindness so very much.“

“Love this place. Food is good. People are awesome. Bathrooms are clean.“

“Their pizza is almost always very good. This time we had an issue picking up our pre-paid carry-out order. The crew at the counter couldn't find my name in their computer system. It's "Geoff". Even after telling them it was "two small pizzas, to be ready at 6:20", they said they didn't have the order. Finally, one of them looked on their rack for carry out orders. The ONLY pizzas sitting on the rack were for "Geoff".“

“We order regularly from our local Domino’s; besides the pizza we enjoy our interaction with our delivery driver Ron. He is very polite and always delivers our pizza on time and our total experience is enhanced with his kindness and customer friendly service.“

“We was greeted and waited on by a very courteous and friendly staff. The place was spotless including the fully visible kitchen. The prices are very affordable and portions was spot on. We had the garlic cheese bread for an appetizer, 4 pops, and a 14 inch medium razorback pizza that included pepperoni, smoked sausage, and bacon. Our bill was $41. We will go back the next time we visit Fishers, In.“

“I have been there twice now and both times, employees were very nice, the restaurant was super clean, and best of all, the personal pan pizza was so hot and fresh, exactly how I remember it being years ago. I had stopped going to pizza hut in general for many years. My friend invited me, so I decided to go. So very glad I did. Good job!“

“I want to say thank you very much for recognizing the fishers post office today and sending us pizza. It was very nice and I want to say thank you from the bottom of my heart. the pizza was wonderful“

“Beer was 5 star. Would love to see more non-IPA options, but quality was good on everything we tried.
Food was also excellent quality. However I suggest that the steak used on the cheese steak sandwich either gets chopped or slow cooked for a long time - it is impossible to eat as a sandwich. Tasted great, but wrong texture for a hand held.
One other issue is the chairs are not comfortable and feel unstable.
Final suggestion for the manager - you should put a basket of your potato chips on every table when guests arrive, and upsell cheese and other sauces. Chips were very good, but your fries were also worth the extra cost“

“What can I say- it’s Blaze Pizza - Always great! I’ve been a fan of Blaze Pizza for years, even before I was vegan. I really appreciate that they offer vegan cheese, so I can continue to enjoy this place. The chorizo is vegan as well. A great place to bring my kids- it’s one of their favorites! Updated from previous review on 2026-02-15“

“Friendly folks at counter and great all round service. It's a storefront location apparently geared for more carryout than dine in, but there are tables and seating for 15~20 folks.
My ONLY gripe is only bottled drinks, no fountain.
The service more than made up for the drink selection.“

“Placed order for pickup at the Fishers Indiana location only to get there and the pizza & breadsticks were burnt. The lard a$$ said it's not burnt that all their pizza and breadsticks are cooked like that. She was rude, unprofessional, argumentative and lippy. She has NO business working with the public!! 😡“

“Very relaxed environment, clean and never super crowded. The employees were very nice and they will help you with whatever they can! the food is amazing and I would say that this is in the top 3 best pizza in the Indianapolis area! I stopped by because I was coming home from Walmart and wanted to grab something before I got home, I ordered a small thin crust and I was only planning on having 2 of the slices and saving the rest but once I started eating that pizza I didn't stop until the whole pizza was gone 😅 but it was worth it! Stop in and see for yourself I was glad I did and you'll be glad you did too!“