23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Carmel

Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse Pizza • $
2430 E 146th St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Breadsticks & Beer Cheese Quesos
Breadsticks with Cheese
Side of Pizza Butter
Buffalo Chicken Which
Hot Skillet Cookie
Baked Goat Cheese
Thai Island Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
3 Soft Pretzels
Crafters Wings

“If you want awesome pizza, wings and breadsticks this is your place! Erica is the best bartender! They have awesome servers also, Sebastián, and John are great. Javi is at the front of the house making sure it runs smoothly. Highly recommend giving them a try.“

4.7 Superb265 Reviews
Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub Pizza • $
1438 W Main St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo with Garlic Bread
Margherita Pizza with Black Olives
Hand-Rolled Breadsticks with Dip
Sausage Pepperoni and Mushroom
Hawaiian Luau and Meaty Mafioso
Garlic Parmesan Chicken Wings
Breadsticks and Wine Flight
Crustless Pizza Specialty
Alfredo the Chicken Pizza
Veggie Max Pizza

“If you find yourself in Carmel, Indiana, make sure to stop by Noble Romans Pizza and Pub - you won't be disappointed! This location is a true standout with its charming decor and friendly staff. The moment you walk in, you're greeted with the delicious aroma of their freshly baked pizzas.Whether you're working remotely or catching up with friends, Noble Romans in Carmel provides the perfect setting. The menu offers a fantastic variety of pizzas and pub fare that cater to every taste. The service is exceptional, and the overall vibe is inviting and lively.I can't recommend Noble Romans Pizza and Pub in Carmel enough. It's a must-visit spot for anyone looking for a top-notch dining experience in the area!“

4.7 Superb178 Reviews
Pies & Pints - Carmel, IN Pizza • $
14550 Clay Terrace Blvd Suite 100, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom and Roasted Garlic
Mexican Street Corn Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Skins
House Salad
Char

“Visited this place almost a year later. Love the food and selection of beers n wine.love their potato skin pie. Jus so yummy, and they have good salads as well. The server was good and loved the casual atmosphere. Will definitely go back. It's my comfort food kinda place.“

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
Fat Dan's Chicago-Style Deli, Carmel Pizza • $
840 W Main St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Fat Dan’S Og Smoked Jumbo Wings
Pepperoni and Mozzarella Sticks
Double Brother Fat Burger
The Italian Beef Sandwich
Brisket Sandwich
Meatloaf Sandwich
NY Fat Burger
Crispy Fries
French Fries
Ghost Burger

“Fat Dan's is great! The location is easy to get in and out of and there's ample parking. The beer selection is fairly broad, the food choices are plentiful, and the service is excellent! The meatloaf sandwich and the Flat Dan smash burger were so so good!“

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Osteria by Fabio Viviani Pizza •
11505 Illinois St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Salmon Farro Risotto
Orange Cannoli Cheesecake
Truffle Parmesan Fries
Chicken Thigh Marsala
Pistachio Cake Slice
Mediterranean Salad
Braised Pork Shank
Cast Iron Focaccia
Steak and Potatoes
Smokey Highlander

“Went to Osteria for a Birthday dinner. I ordered the special Ribeye that was offered that evening and it came not cooked as requested. We could not be more pleased with what Osteria did in the name of service recovery. Our server Kiley was unbelievable, she made sure the mistake was more than fixed as did the General Manager Laurie Cambell. Everyone makes mistakes its what you do to fix them that leaves a lasting impression. A great experience.“

4.1 Good263 Reviews
Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop Pizza • $
1732 E 116th St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Breadsticks with Cheese
Slice of Sausage Pizza
Homemade Breadsticks
Chicago Italian Beef
Panini Sandwiches
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Salad
Gyro Platter
Meat Pizza

“This is a unique, old-school local pizza place. In all the best ways, Greek Tony’s reminds me of the pizza restaurants that I went to 40 years ago. How did I not know about this place! The pizza, breadsticks and salad were all delicious, and the service was fast and friendly. The restaurant decor is hockey-themed and conveys the history of the restaurant’s founder. What’s not to love?“

4.2 Good87 Reviews
Tucci's Carmel Italian • $$$
11 City Center Dr, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Maryland Style Lump Crab Cakes
Mango Serrano Tuna Stack
Braised Short Ribs
Chicken Parmesan
Seared Sea Bass
Sauteed Spinach
Calamari Fries
Herb Rolls
Rigatoni
Lasagna

“The original evening plan was for the Mrs. & I to play laser tag, but there was an hour wait until the next game.. what to do? Easy..eat of course! Tucci's was right around the corner & since we hadn't been in awhile.. why not? We hadn't been because even though they're pretty good, they had limited seafood selections, & we're pescatarian. Much to our surprise, they'd made some tasty additions to their menu since we were there last. The staff was friendly & actually remembered us from the last time we were there.. after playing laser tag..?With the cool atmosphere, & more for us to choose from on the menu now, we'll probably be back again sooner than later.. my best guess is.. it'll probably be the next time we go play laser tag..???Dietary restrictions: My wife has a few dietary restrictions, but they've always been more than willing to modify her dish to make sure it was to her liking.Parking: I've never had a problem finding free parking on the street or directly across the street in a big free lot.“

4 Good302 Reviews
Mellow Mushroom Carmel Pizza • $
2340 E 116th St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Vegan Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
GF Mighty Meaty Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Special Pizza
BYO or Cheese Pizza
Holy Shiitake Pie
Pizza by the Slice
Mellow Mushroom
Personal Pizza

“Fantastic food! Fantastic service! Fantastic atmosphere!This is one of my regular spots, reliable for a great meal, great beer selection, and amazing pizza. The staff is absolutely fantastic Carissa, Victoria, and Katie always take great care of us. Excellent (and updated) atmosphere. My favorite place to go.Dietary restrictions: Dairy free cheese and tempeh options. Very accommodating“

4.1 Good62 Reviews
Roselli’s Pizza Pizza • $
4335 W 106th St # 100, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Marinara
Classic Combo Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicago Style Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Chopped Salad
Roselli
Sausage

“Pizza here is definitely the best Chicago style pizza I've had outside Milwaukee and Chicago. Very good. The buffet looks amazing with options for all styles of pizza they serve. I come here every year for my Daughters bball regional tournaments.“

4 Good83 Reviews
Blaze Pizza Pizza • $
12697 N Pennsylvania St Suite 140, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Large
Pepperoni Pizza
Custom Pizza
Cheesy Bread
Simple Pie
Pesto

“Blaze pizza if you haven’t tried it you are missing out. Craving fast food by not burgers tacos or chicken? Try blaze quick delicious fast fired pizza by a real fire. They offer different sauces and toppings as well as a cauliflower option. Do not skimp on the oregano and sea salt so much added flavor. The staff was working overtime yesterday for pi day and were killing it. I hope they were thanked again and again for their hard work. Great service makes great food. Ps don’t leave without the ooo gooy melted snore. Yum“

3.9 Good96 Reviews
Puccini's Pizza Pasta-Carmel Pizza • $$
Meridian Village Plaza, 13674 N Meridian St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Artichoke Dip
Fettuccine Alfredo
Garlic Cheese Bread
Campfire Pizza
Garlic Bread
Small Pizza
Campfire
Lasagna
Salad

“Puccinis is our favorite go-to restaurant. So many wonderful memories have been made over delicious food at Puccini’s. I love that my kids get to experience a local spot with their friends (and my friends) and get that awesome hometown feel. There are two employees who *regularly* go above and beyond for us. They treat us so well and are always on top of everything we need before we can ask. Puccini’s days are the highlight of our week! My personal favorites are the sweet little razor back and the salads, the homemade ranch is great!“

3.9 Good55 Reviews
Pizza King Pizza • $
301 E Carmel Dr, Carmel

“So it was our first time visiting Pizza King. Had a great experience. Customer service was great. The quality of the food was great, they don't mind piling on the toppings. The wait wasn't long, your usual 15 minute wait.The funny thing was the employee (not sure if he was the manager or not) said he messed up on the pizza. Maybe the small corner perhaps it happened when he tried to get the pizza out the over. He apologized so many times plus made a small pizza made how we wanted it on the house.We weren't looking for anything free. We accepted his apology. He didn't have to do that buy he did and we were absolutely grateful for that.I recommend this location. And we will return.Thank you for great food and great service. We need more places like this.“

3.9 Good50 Reviews
Bazbeaux Pizza (Carmel) Pizza • $
111 W Main St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Spinach Salad
Mexican Pizza
Colossus Pizza
Garden Pizza
Burnt Pizza
Colossus

“First time here on Mar 2, 2024. The staff openly apologized for being understaffed. The wait with a three year old in the party was a bit challenging. The 15 minute wait to be seated was 35, and another 45 to get the food. Better to be completely open about the wait times right up front. Unscientifically, we noted that the carry out orders seemed to be prioritized over the dine in customers.The food was excellent even if it was touching right at the edge of overpriced. We had 4 different pizzas and they were all well done. I'm a Jersey boy and this was the best pizza I've had in a very long time.“

3.8 Good106 Reviews
King Dough Pizza • $
12505 Old Meridian St Suite 170, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Hot Honey Sesame Mild Wings
Grape & Gorgonzola Pizza
Chicken Caesar Salad
Hive Mind Pizza VG
Pizza Margherita
Pepperoni Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Destroyer Pizza
Big Boy Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“Our son lives in Indy so my wife and I go down to visit as often as we can. He picks the places to eat. He always picks amazing places. This one is no different. It's in Carmel so it's a little bougie hipster in style, but it's busy and peaceful. The service is out of this world, polite, and answered our "newbie" questions. We asked if we could "customize" a pizza due to not liking a particular ingredient, instead of flat out saying "no" they explained how it would have to be done in order to accomplish this. Asked if we still wanted it made different, we answered in the affirmative and the pizza was awesome. They say there are no bad pizzas, my wife and kids can say yes there are, but if you want an amazing pizza check this place out it's well worth it.Parking: It's in market of Carmel so lots of business and apartments. Parking is not plentiful, but if you're willing to walk a half bit not too bad.“

3.8 Good101 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1441 S Guilford Rd Suite 110 Ste 110, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Ultimate Pepperoni Feast
Parmesan Bread Bites
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Wings

“Ordered Domino's tonight. The order did take longer than usual and I was missing some sauces however the delivery driver, Darius, made up for that. The food was still warm and he was very sweet and apologized and offered to get my order comped. The employees at this store have always been wonderful and are the reason I continue to order. But please remember the sauces guys“

3.8 Good74 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
465 E Carmel Dr, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Mozzarella Cheese on Top
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Baked Super Family Meal
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Carbonara
Baked Spaghetti
Pepperoni Pizza
Two Breadsticks
Lunch Special

“A group of us had dinner on 3/17 in Carmel and the entire staff went above and beyond with fast, friendly services. The food was excellent and the service was phenomenal. Kudos to the entire Sunday afternoon team.Parking: Parking was accessible and enough for our team of around 15.Kid-friendliness: The kids were catered to in a friendly atmosphere.“

3.8 Good49 Reviews
Bella Pizzeria - Carmel Pizza • $
14550 Clay Terrace Blvd, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Slices
Cheese Pizza
Plain 2 pcs

“I was actually surprised that this pizza joint is good. Ha, we were just walking around and decided to try it since they have individual slices. And you know what?! We're coming back for more. It's actually in our top 5 favorite pizza joints. It was tasty and perfectly crispy. Delish. Oh the staff was great too. They were friendly and nice. We can also sit down and the ambiance was great too.“

3.8 Good37 Reviews
Greek's Pizzeria West Carmel Pizza Delivery • $
12703 Meeting House Rd, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
The Garden Supreme
Pepperoni Pizza
Five Cheese
Greek

“Liked this restaurant though I went there to only pick up an online order for family. Love their pizzas .. so do my children, daughters in law and even grand children !! Family likes their pizzas and we frequently order here. Liked their service with smile even for just delivery ..Parking: Street parking right opposite restaurant is available but cannot be sure if too many people visit same time (though I did not experience).“

3.8 Good36 Reviews
Puccinis rest Pizza • $$
13686 N Meridian St, Carmel

“Puccinis is our favorite go-to restaurant. So many wonderful memories have been made over delicious food at Puccini’s. I love that my kids get to experience a local spot with their friends (and my friends) and get that awesome hometown feel. There are two employees who *regularly* go above and beyond for us. They treat us so well and are always on top of everything we need before we can ask. Puccini’s days are the highlight of our week! My personal favorites are the sweet little razor back and the salads, the homemade ranch is great!“

3.8 Good20 Reviews
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria Pizza Takeaway • $
11435 Spring Mill Rd Unit 170, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

The Malnati Chicago Classic Pizza
Deep Dish Chicago Classic Pizza
Deep Dish Pepperoni
Deep Dish Sausage
Chicken Wings
Garlic Bread
Thin

“I was in the mood for pizza one night and I noticed on Uber Eats that Lou Malnati's was having a buy one get one free on pizzas. I jumped on the offer. I have been to the actual location and it is very nice. The ambiance is definitely Italian themed and the decor is very nice. The service is wonderful and the staff definitely make you feel like you are in Italy. I ordered the small deep dish cheese and pepperoni pizza. It was wonderful. I do not have deep dish pizza very often, but when I do, it is a pure treat to myself. Lou Malnati's uses wonderful spices and ingredients in their deep dish pizza that makes it taste so unique from other pizzas. It is a true Chicago deep dish style pizza and is worth every penny you spend on the meal. If you want to treat yourself to a wonderful pizza, go to Lou Malnati's. You will pay a pretty penny, but it is worth it!“

3.7 Good72 Reviews
HotBox Pizza Pizza • $
4400 Weston Pointe Dr #160, Carmel

“Not a bad place for lunch. Decent pizza and a nice salad. I got the \"Lunch Box\" which is the special. Along with that you get a reusable cup and two tootsie rolls (which was kind of cute). My biggest complaint was the music was a weird electronic smooth jazz. Other than that, it was a nice stop.“

3.6 Good13 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
2764 E 146th St, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“I typically order from the store once a week now for the past several months. Service is adequate and the pizza is very good, albeit pricey. I have only ever had a couple of instances where I’ve needed to call to find out what happened to my pizza. Usually received it within about 20 minutes after. One of the better pizza joints in town.“

3.6 Good25 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
1950 E Greyhound Pass, Carmel

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Artichoke Baking Required
Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza
Garden Veggie Pizza
Create Your Own
Cowboy Pizza

“Great staff. They're very helpful and polite. Logan & Shelton did a great job making my pizzas. Shelton rang me & almost got me to buy some cookie dough. Did you know you can eat Papa Murphy's cookie dough RAW because it is NOT made with eggs. 👍 Papa Murphy's has fantastic deals throughout every week - Tuesday is $10 large pizzas, Friday is $5 large pepperoni/sausage/ham thin crust pizzas. Take 'em & bake 'em baby!“

3.5 Good12 Reviews
Loading...
map Map