24 Best Italian Restaurants near Fishers

“Outstanding service. Phenomenal food! From the bread/appetizers to the meal and tiramisu dessert 👌🏻 We were absolutely amazed by with every bite. I can’t wait to go back.“

“Thin crust pizza. 9.0. Was very good. Need one in Muncie Indiana.“

“Great place with amazing staff! I called and asked a bunch of question. The staff member went to his manager and made sure all of my questions were answered. I ordered two gluten free pizzas for delivery to a public area and they were able to accommodate it. The delivery driver was fantastic! The pizzas were delicious!“

“Puccini always has delicious food. That’s what counts. Sometimes this restaurant gets a bit overwhelmed because it gets so busy. But the wait staff (at the moment) is courteous! There seems to be a lot of turnover. But I think that’s indicative of any restaurant right now. They can’t get good help because they don’t pay their staff well. Thank you to the wait staff.“

“Wonderful food Beautiful atmosphere Great service Lovely place for date night“

“We had a great dinner tonight to celebrate my birthday! It was our first time there but will not be our last! Our server, Taylor Swift, was awesome!!“

“Celebrated our son's birthday. Our daughter who is vegan was with us. They were very accommodating to her dietary restrictions. Holly our server was so helpful finding out any info we needed and assisting everyone. Thank you for a great dining experience.“

“3rd time here and each visit was excellent. Great food. We like 1/2 price wine Tuesdays! Def worth a visit“

“Homey but upscale atmosphere at the same time. Quite busy when I went but they fit us in even tho our reservation was for the wrong time. The complimentary bread had a wonderfully crunchy crust. The eggplant and portabello mushroom spaghetti with capers and green and black olives was unlike anything I’ve had before—what fun to try something new! It was so flavorful! And the portion size lasted for two meals. Would get again.“

“So good, all around. Great service. Excellent food.“

“These calzones are HUGE and packed with so much flavor! 12/10 👍🏻“

“My wife and I had an incredible experience tonight at @matteo’s. Excellent options and fantastic value. Jordan our waiter was very knowledgeable and went above and beyond to make our dinner that much special! Will be back again!“

“Excellent Food and service. We will definitely be back!!“

“My husband and I went to Italy for our honeymoon and their food definitely took us back! The food was authentic, delicious, excelent service, and the chef was amazing and very heartwarming. If you love Italian fine dining food, this is the spot. Grazie mille 🇮🇹“

“Outstanding service. Phenomenal food! From the bread/appetizers to the meal and tiramisu dessert 👌🏻 We were absolutely amazed by with every bite. I can’t wait to go back.“

“Best Italian food in Carmel. Everything is made from scratch and the service was amazing. Very friendly staff. Will visit again before heading back to Phoenix. Thank you for a wonderful experience and evening.“

“Awesome Food and we had an amazing server, Maggie! This is the first time we've gone to Olive Garden as a family in a while, and it was a wonderful experience! My dad and my grandma were surprised and pleased by the choice between salad and soup, and we almost got full of bread by the time our entrees arrived. Maggie was so attentive and intuitive, she brought refills for our drinks and asked if we wanted more salad and breadsticks before we could even ask her! Plus she was very patient even when we asked to switch out drinks or when we took long on the details of our orders. Genuinely made me so happy, and I thank her so much, please give that woman a raise!!! (my younger brother wants to say something ➡️) I love the game in the tablet. and foods taste good.“

“Our server Sandra was so attentive to us. We were having a memorial lunch for our pup we just lost. We felt well taken care of even if she didn't know our circumstances of coming in. Our glasses were always full and we were well taken care of from start to finish. Thank you Sandra.“

“Absolutely DELICIOUS! This is one of our favorite pizza places. The meat lovers w/ Prosciutto pizza is our fav! Make sure to also get the bianca focaccia cheesy bread and add garlic to it! 🤤😋“

“I recently visited Kinsey's Italian Cafe and was very impressed with both the food and service. The restaurant has a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable right away. The menu offers a great variety of Italian favorites, and everything tasted fresh and homemade. The pizza, pasta, and garlic knots were especially delicious, with generous portions that provide great value. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure our dining experience was enjoyable from start to finish. Whether you're dining in or carrying out, Kinsey's is a fantastic local spot for authentic Italian comfort food. I will definitely be returning and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for quality Italian cuisine in the McCordsville area.“

“Love their food and can’t wait to return. Everything we had was delicious. Farmer’s Market salad was delicious and the pepperoni stick was so good.“

“Christine made the most incredible Italian Millefoglie dessert for 180 guests at my daughter’s wedding. It was a beautiful attraction set on on its own table at the reception. Guests raved about its freshness and taste. I highly recommend Stacco House if you are searching for something unique as well as delicious. Christine created a masterpiece with her attention to detail, and her professionalism was extraordinary.“

“I am from Chicago having just moved to Noblesville in May of 2025. I KNOW Italian food....trust me! Michaelangelo's is as good as any Italian food I have ever eaten in Chicago over the past 50 years if not BETTER!! Their minestrone is the absolute BEST minestrone I have ever eaten. What a blessing to have Michaelangelo's 10 minutes from my house. By best to all, Steve Whipple“

“Girrrrrrrrrl. Walk, run, sprint to get this tiramisu ❤️“