22 Best Italian Restaurants near Fishers

Sangiovese Ristorante Italian • $$$
9708 District, North Street Ste 920, Fishers

“Outstanding service. Phenomenal food! From the bread/appetizers to the meal and tiramisu dessert 👌🏻 We were absolutely amazed by with every bite. I can’t wait to go back.“

4.4 Superb399 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
11785 Commercial Drive, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Eugene Supreme
Corner Pizza
Jet Wings
Hawaiian
NY Style
Jet 10
Salads
Thin

“Thin crust pizza. 9.0. Was very good. Need one in Muncie Indiana.“

4.2 Good188 Reviews
Monical's Pizza of Fishers Pizza • $
14099 Mundy Drive, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Garden Fresh Salad
Garlic Cheese Bread
Thin Crust Pizza
Veggie 14 lrg
Deluxe 8
Deluxe
Chef

“Great place with amazing staff! I called and asked a bunch of question. The staff member went to his manager and made sure all of my questions were answered. I ordered two gluten free pizzas for delivery to a public area and they were able to accommodate it. The delivery driver was fantastic! The pizzas were delicious!“

4.1 Good193 Reviews
Puccini's Pizza Pasta-Fishers Pizza • $
8993 East 116th Street, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Chicken Alfredo
Queen of Hearts
Campfire Pizza
Caesar Salad
Cheese Bread
Dinner Salad
Bread Sticks
Breadsticks
BBQ Chicken

“Puccini’s in Fishers is one of our favorite pizza spots!

Our absolute favorite is the Loaded Potato Pizza! It is seriously AMAZING! I do like bacon, but I always get my half without it, and it’s still one of my favorites.

We also tried the spinach dip, and it was really good! It comes with bread, which was delicious, although I do wish they offered chips with it too. Either way, I’ll definitely order it again!

Everything was great, and the food was delicious. Definitely recommend Puccini’s Fishers!“

3.7 Good282 Reviews
Ambrosia Italian • $$
5903 North College Avenue, Indianapolis - 9.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo w Chicken
Appetizer - Calamari
New York Cheesecake
Ravioli Della Mamma
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala
Chocolate Cake
Fried Calamari
Pollo Marsala
Bruschetta

“Wonderful food Beautiful atmosphere Great service Lovely place for date night“

4.6 Superb449 Reviews
The Italian House Italian • $$
219 Park Street, Westfield - 8.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken \u0026 Prosciutto Tortellini
Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Parmesan Crusted Grouper
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Sausage Orecchiette
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Veal Saltimbocca
Chicken Piccata
Halibut Piccata

“We had a great dinner tonight to celebrate my birthday! It was our first time there but will not be our last! Our server, Taylor Swift, was awesome!!“

4.6 Superb1019 Reviews
Capri Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
2602 Ruth Drive, Indianapolis - 7.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tortelloni Alla Papalina
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Linguine Alla Vongole
Melanzane Parmigiana
Fettucina Del Golfo
Spaghetti Bolognese
Lemon Ricotta Cake
Rigatoni Boscaiola
Piemontese Salad
Calamari Fritti

“Celebrated our son's birthday. Our daughter who is vegan was with us. They were very accommodating to her dietary restrictions. Holly our server was so helpful finding out any info we needed and assisting everyone. Thank you for a great dining experience.“

4.6 Superb736 Reviews
Pasto Italiano Restaurant & Bar Italian • $$
3150 IN-32, Westfield - 7.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bread Dipping Sauces
Superb Italian Wine
Spaghetti Bolognese
Penne Pesto Limone
Cabernet Sauvignon
Patsy’S Meatball
Meatball Appetizer
Linguine Alfredo
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta Al Dente

“Excellent Food and service. We will definitely be back!!“

4.7 Superb267 Reviews
Portofino Italian
11206 Fall Creek Road, Indianapolis - 3.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Fore-Roasted Chicken
Peppercorn Crusted Filet
Crab and Salmon Roulade
Risotto Fruitti Di Mare
Smoked Salmon Rosette
Roasted Rack of Lamb
Salmon Crab Roulade
Beet Arugula Salad
Zabaglione Brulee
Risotto Milanese

“My husband and I went to Italy for our honeymoon and their food definitely took us back! The food was authentic, delicious, excelent service, and the chef was amazing and very heartwarming. If you love Italian fine dining food, this is the spot. Grazie mille 🇮🇹“

4.8 Superb143 Reviews
Amore! Italian Kitchen Italian • $$
9757 Fall Creek Road, Indianapolis - 4.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Stuffed Zucchini Appetizer
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chocolate Chip Cannolis
Creamy Tuscan Skillet
Blueberry Cheesecake
Brown Butter Gnocchi
Creamy Dijon Chicken
Sweet Potato Gnocchi
Eggplant Parmigiana

“3rd time here and each visit was excellent. Great food. We like 1/2 price wine Tuesdays! Def worth a visit“

4.6 Superb311 Reviews
Mama Carolla's Italian • $$
1031 East 54th Street, Indianapolis - 9.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Creme Brulee w Raspberry Topping
Chicken Parmesan Penne Pasta
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Holly's Artichoke Fritters
Antipasti - Fried Ravioli
Salad with Cesar Dressing
Rosemary Chicken Lasagna
Veal Marsala Angel Hair
Soup - Soup of the Day
Tiramisu Made in House

“Homey but upscale atmosphere at the same time. Quite busy when I went but they fit us in even tho our reservation was for the wrong time. The complimentary bread had a wonderfully crunchy crust. The eggplant and portabello mushroom spaghetti with capers and green and black olives was unlike anything I’ve had before—what fun to try something new! It was so flavorful! And the portion size lasted for two meals. Would get again.“

4.6 Superb298 Reviews
Matteo's Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
40 North 9th Street, Noblesville - 6.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Ravioli and Potato Croquettes
Tagliatella Alla Tarantella
Mostaccioli Bolognese
Tortellini Matteo’S
Canoli and Cheesecake
Ravioli Maria Rosa
Bruschetta Fresca
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari Fritti
Chicken Lasagne

“My wife and I had an incredible experience tonight at @matteo’s. Excellent options and fantastic value. Jordan our waiter was very knowledgeable and went above and beyond to make our dinner that much special! Will be back again!“

4.3 Superb585 Reviews
Sauce on the Side Italian • $
12751 North Pennsylvania Street Ste 130, Carmel - 7.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cocka Doodle Noodle Calzone
Meet Me in St Louie Calzone
Create Your Own Calzone
Nutella Banana Calzone
Meat Me in St Louie
Apple Pie Calzone
Buffalo Chicken
Fatty B Calzone
Roasty Toasty
Ceasar Salad

“These calzones are HUGE and packed with so much flavor! 12/10 👍🏻“

4.6 Superb275 Reviews
Maggiano's Little Italy Italian • $$
3550 East 86th Street, Indianapolis - 5.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chef kb's Lobster Carbonara
Balsamic Tomato Bruschetta
Mushroom Ravioli Al Forno
New York Style Cheesecake
Our Riserva Veal Parmesan
Taylor Street Baked Ziti
Chocolate Zuccotto Cake
Chocolate Layered Cake
Our Famous Rigatoni D
New York Cheesecake

“So good, all around. Great service. Excellent food.“

4.5 Superb499 Reviews
Sangiovese Ristorante Italian • $$
2727 East 86th Street Suite 110, Indianapolis - 6.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli- Started in Before I Remembered a Picture
Triple Chocolate Mousse Cake
Red Snapper with Crab Meat
Tortellini Alla Effie
Spaghetti Fra Diavlo
Linguini Bosco Mare
Risotto of the Day
Shrimp Tortellini
Cisco's Meatballs
Chicken Marsala

“Outstanding service. Phenomenal food! From the bread/appetizers to the meal and tiramisu dessert 👌🏻 We were absolutely amazed by with every bite. I can’t wait to go back.“

4.5 Superb349 Reviews
Ristorante Roma Italian • $$
89 Veterans Way, Carmel - 6.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brassfield Volcano Ridge Eruption Lake County California
Brussel Sprouts Al Pecorino
Pappardelle Alla Boscaiola
Filetto Al Gorgonzola
Spaghetti Carbonara
Calamari E Polenta
Chocolate Mousse
Insalata Caprese
Seafood Alfredo
Fried Calamari

“Best Italian food in Carmel. Everything is made from scratch and the service was amazing. Very friendly staff. Will visit again before heading back to Phoenix. Thank you for a wonderful experience and evening.“

4.4 Superb426 Reviews
Kinsey's Italian Cafe Italian • $
6383 W Broadway A-D, McCordsville - 6.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine with Chicken and Garlic Knots
Deep Fried Fish Platter with Fries
Lasagna w Extra Sauce and Cheese
Seafood Pasta with Shrimp
Cheese Burger with Fries
Spaghetti and Meat Balls
Pepperoni Breadsticks
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Cacciatore

“Food was very good, portion sizes were also good. Service was fast, friendly, and attentive without being overbearing. Overall a good pizza/Italian restaurant. Not fancy, so not so much an upscale place as a family place. Overall I'd say 4.5,but that's not an option.“

4.5 Superb143 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
13285 Tegler Drive, Noblesville - 5.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Tie Mousse Cake Chocolate Cake Dark Chocolate Cheesecake and Creamy Custard with Icing
Spaghetti Topped with Your Choice of Homemade Marinara or Meat Sauce Prepared Fresh Daily
Chicken & Gnocchi a Creamy Soup Made with Roasted Chicken Italian Dumplings and Spinach
Sangrias Made with a Blend of Chilled Wine Fresh Fruit and a Splash of Fruit Juices
Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Minestrone Fresh Vegetables Beans and Pasta in a Light Tomato Broth
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Bread Sticks with Alfredo Sauce
Mousse De Chocolate Cheesecake

“We always order To-Go and it has been a great experience! Just perhaps if Olive Garden - or this location - would go back to how the potatoes used to be cut for the Zuppa. The long, large pieces can be overwhelming in the soup. More kale, less huge potatoes slices!“

4.4 Superb309 Reviews
I Tre Mori Italian • $$
8220 E 106th St Ste 200, Indianapolis - 1.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers’S Pizza Prosciutto Di Parma
Spaghetti with Homemade Beef Meatballs
Meat Lover's Pizza with Prosciutto
Mini Chocolate Chips Cannoli
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Pizza Prosciutto & Brie
Mini Cannoli Chocolate
Eggplant Parmigiana
Pizza Delicata White
Bianca Cheesy Bread

“Absolutely DELICIOUS! This is one of our favorite pizza places. The meat lovers w/ Prosciutto pizza is our fav! Make sure to also get the bianca focaccia cheesy bread and add garlic to it! 🤤😋“

4.4 Superb226 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
6130 East 82nd Street, Indianapolis - 4.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Chicken Gnocchi Soup and Breadsticks
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Create Your Own Pasta
Salad and Breadsticks
Shrimp Fritto Misto
Chicken Parmigiana
Fried Mozzarella

“Natalie was absolutely amazing! She was so kind, welcoming, accommodating, and attentive from beginning to end. She consistently checked in on us, made sure we had everything we needed, and provided exceptional service throughout our entire visit. You can tell she genuinely cares about making sure her guests have a great experience. She truly made our dinner that much more enjoyable!

If you’re visiting Olive Garden, definitely ask for Natalie, you’ll be in great hands! We truly appreciated her wonderful service and will absolutely be back.“

4.1 Good237 Reviews
Michaelangelo’s Italian Bistro Italian • $
550 Westfield Road, Noblesville - 6.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

All-You-Can-Eat Soup Salad and Breadsticks
All You Can Eat Soup Salad Breadsticks
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Create Your Own Pasta
Build Your Own Pasta
Italian Wedding Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Scallopini
Tortellini Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks

“I am from Chicago having just moved to Noblesville in May of 2025. I KNOW Italian food....trust me! Michaelangelo's is as good as any Italian food I have ever eaten in Chicago over the past 50 years if not BETTER!! Their minestrone is the absolute BEST minestrone I have ever eaten. What a blessing to have Michaelangelo's 10 minutes from my house. By best to all, Steve Whipple“

4.3 Superb263 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $
8601 River Crossing Boulevard, Indianapolis - 5.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Piada with Grilled Chicken
Power Bowl with Salmon Addedd
Carbonara with Grilled Chicken
Carbonara with Crispy Chicken
Loaded Mac \u0026 Cheese
The Farmers Market Salad
Pepperoni Piada Stick
Farmer's Market Salad
Farmer's Salad Market
Chef's Favorite Piada

“Love their food and can’t wait to return. Everything we had was delicious. Farmer’s Market salad was delicious and the pepperoni stick was so good.“

4.2 Good183 Reviews

You May Also Like