29 Best American Restaurants in Carmel

“We had a table of 8 for my grandsons birthday. I had the cheese burger, medium well. Great taste. Cooked to perfection. Someone had the catfish and liked it. This person is very particular about their food and gave it high praise. No complaints from anyone and my son is a chef in his own rights.“

“Great food and great service! 5/5 would highly recommend“

“We took my boyfriend’s mother and her friend here to celebrate their birthdays last month. The food was great, the atmosphere and decor were dazzling, and the customer service was top notch. We especially loved the cake, chicken piccata, and the soup. We will definitely be back.“

“Great Ruben. Loved it. I was in carmel for my son's high-school graduation from Indiana ag an tech. Wife an I had time to kill while waiting on start time. We Came here an really enjoyed it. Amanda was a great server. We are from Columbus Indiana. So it will be a while before we can get back up.“

“Traveling from Michigan and came across Upland Brewing. Stopped in for a beer and a quick snack. The Juiced in Time Haze IPA and Two of Tarts sour were both amazing. The staff were great! And the food was tasty, we will definitely be back and highly recommend if you’re in the area.“

“Kailyn was our server. She was very friendly and had a beautiful smile. She made some good suggestions as well! The million dollar potatoes were slightly undercooked for me, but my friend said she preferred them that way lol It was a little chilly inside.“

“Divvy is one of my favorite places to go for an evening out! I always have a wonderful time. The food is delicious, the service is exceptional and the atmosphere is wonderful. I look forward to the next time I get to go! I can't wait to try the brunch!“

“Wonderful lunch and waiter Rick. Thank you“

“Once again a world class experience with Dawn at Muldoon’s. We love coming to Muldoon’s for the food, the service, the experience and especially to see Dawn. She makes the visit special every time! Thank you Muldoon’s for being a pilar of the of the Carmel community and thank you again Dawn! P.S. order the banana cream pie and thank me later #Rockstar“

“Great food Excellent portions“

“Without having a restaurant in Fort Wayne anymore, we tend to stop at this location when we get close. The beef Manhattan is among my favorite meals in my life. Consistent and super delicious almost every time. The pies are fantastic. I personally love the coconut cream pie and the lemon cream pie. All are top notch. Always a good selection of comfort food entrees available and look fantastic. I leave happy and look forward to my next trip through Indy.“

“Love the variety on the menu, the multiple dining areas and the way the history of the building has been preserved. Woodys has been a favorite of mine in downtown Carmel for a while now!“

“We live in Noblesville but get carry-out at the Carmel location and are never disappointed. We love the pecan crusted chicken salad and the salmon with Brussels sprouts and pan-fried rice. And their Ranch dressing is great.“

“My favorite restaurant inside of Sun King Carmel by far. I miss their mussels something fierce, but I've found in the past that their smashburger really satisfies. This time, however, it was not a smashburger. The patties were definitely not smashed, did not have the signature crispy edges of a smashburger, and both were even still pink in the middle. If you want to see how a smashburger is done right, go to Sun King Fishers and look what One Trick Pony is doing. Still, I'm going to keep coming back and will definitely order another "smashburger" because it's delicious.“

“Great food and environment! We love the down home music too!💕💕“

“We have been frequently going to Sunrise for over 25 years! We love it!“

“I've been wanting to go here for awhile! on an early Saturday afternoon, we finally went. everyone was very pleasant and patient with our family (toddler and infant.) although we didn't have to use the changing table in the bathroom, it was appreciated that they had one. the service was prompt and the food was absolutely delicious. we had the pulled pork sandwich, salmon salad, and kids Mac and cheese with beans/rice. no complaints! our waitress Sue was fantastic. we will be back!“

“The Kitchen at Pickle on Penn is an absolute gem - every meal I’ve had has been delicious, and the service is always quick and friendly. The upbeat atmosphere and welcoming staff make it a place you’ll want to come back to again. Highly recommend!“

“The food here is absolutely FANTASTIC, scratch kitchen perfection. Great service and atmosphere! You cannot go wrong here.“

“I was passing through with 3 little kids (hungry, tired, cranky... kids) and clearly had my hands full as a solo parent for the night. The staff was so patient with us and the general manager was even kind enough to help us to our seats and bring over a high chair for our little one. We had a fantastic meal and enjoyed some dessert afterwards. The place is clean and the folks are friendly. We felt safe and welcome. Nice franchise and amazing employees. We will definitely come back when we are next in the Carmel area.“

“Came in with a group, we had the upstairs room then told we had to be gone by 7pm We reserved the room at 515. So with that said, servers ok. Food came at 645. Manager told the group that we need to be out by then. 7pm because it was reserved for another group at 7. He told us that the staff didn’t inform him about it. Really kinda not our problem at that time. We were 30+ strong. Kids and all. I walked out at 715. Doesn’t seem right. Not mad but a concern with staff and communication. Food good, service ok, slow at times , restaurant was not totally full. I could see open tables. Yes I would come back, but come on. The manager should have known of the situation and made a plan B the weather was in the 70’s they could have used the courtyard. Ok sorry done.“

“I absolutely love Roots! I have never had a bad meal from there. The atmosphere is always great and the service is exceptional. I highly recommend them to everyone I can.“

“The ambiance is perfect for a date although I wouldve liked for a sectioned off area since they are located so close to the door. The wind and snow made the seating area very cold. However the drinks they served us did eventually warm us to a comfortable temperature. The food was prepared perfectly and with the good portion size you are able to get full. Although I can never eat all my food in puble
public so I was further please when J was able to reheat my ffod and it still tasted incredible. 8 out of 10 for sure. I gave them an 8 simply because i went for the devour menu and there were only two course actually bc the dessert was extra, we got it and it was good but still extra.“

“Excellent food. Lots of Mexican restaurants around but not a lot of standouts. This one is superb. Our go to for Mexican cuisine“

“We only stopped by for a beer. The service was excellent. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. The food looked good but we already ate. Ordered the Church Milk Stout and it was delicious and smooth. At over 6% one was enough. Tried the Jack Ringo. Very hot finish!“

“Had an amazing time. Lija and Melissa are amazing bartenders, but the whole staff is super friendly (I couldn’t possibly name everyone), that really provided not only great service, but a great experience. I would recommend to anyone to go visit the Goat and enjoy the whole experience.“

“I loved this place. We visited for the first time! I ordered food but forgot to mention removing steak in the chicken shrimp pasta. They immediately replaced it for me and got a new one. The service is incredible. Thanks for the good experience!“

“Food was very good.
Service was excellent. We had a Shawn
Sunday afternoon. He took very good care of the four of us in our group. When we come back to Applebees we hope to have Shawn again. He deserves 5 stars.
Thank you.
Clara & James Curry“