8 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Castle

“We go here all the time. The food is always 🔥. we always get a 16" royal feast with o mushroom or onion Apparently they didn't hear the onions part tonight but the manager( i think she said her name was Carol)was awesome and asked if I wanted a small discount or said she would remake it. I said it was all good and gave her a better tip lol. its fricking 🔥 🔥 😆“

“Made a quick stop for pizza at this local restaurant and ordered a medium cheese and sausage with Alfredo sauce. Wow! I wish I lived closer. It was delicious and everyone was extremely polite. Waited maybe 20 minutes to eat. Great place ! Highly recommend.“

“the best pizza in indiana!!! never once in 40 years have we gotten bad service or pizza...with a track record like that where can you go wrong!!! too bad they don't make a 24 inch!!!“

“I went there the other day and the order I was picking up wasn’t ready yet. The gm knew I was annoyed but she handled it so well. She broke out conversation with me and knew exactly how to change me from being annoyed to being friendly. They definitely picked a great gm and she was working and helping out just like the employees.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Manager Makayla hung up on me! I only requested a number to headquarters to ask about their online service. She was rude and short tempered. The food is always great and the drivers always prompt and courteous.
Response: It is a five for the crew, BUT the manager need phone etiquette coaching at the very least. I hope you can resolve her issues.“

“They are super nice and I have been down on my luck lately and they gave me a free pizza on my birthday. I was shocked when I heard a knock at the door because I had almost no money.“

“Good pizza at a great price I definitely would recommend“