7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Connersville

“I eat a lot of pizza. I've been a lot of places. . I've never tasted any pizza anywhere that even remotely compares to what I get right here.. Absolutely Awesome!!!“

“Love pizza sticks. Chef salads great sandwiches“

“Excellent food and service today at Connersville location!!“

“Got me some of my favorite food. Just wanted to say to the server that you did an awesome job Sweetheart and that the wait was well worth it and always is. You were the ONLY server tonight and the kitchen was short staffed too but, y’all did a great job. I hope that you see this post and know that. The whole staff did a great job and I appreciate the pleasant experience. It’s not often I get to come back to Connersville but, I always do get some Pizza King while I am here. To the customer who was rude, loud and made a complete fool of himself: clearly you have never worked in the food industry and have no patience, sympathy or grace. I understand that your food was cold (as does everyone in the building) You don’t have to get hateful or loud. They fixed it and in my opinion made it right and still somehow you managed to continue to complain to the lady who was with you. Do better Sir. Be grateful and appreciative because they did show up to work and were doing the best they could.“

“Only had few minutes to grab some food & saw Little Ceasars there & pulled in saw a poster of a small meal & ordered & BOOM he got it together & I was out the door in literally 2 minutes! I got the pizza puffs thingys 4n a box!! They were fresh & my new fave there!“

“On December 6th 2025 my wife and I drove from Indianapolis to dine at our favorite restaurant in Connersville. There is no other Pizza King like the one on western Avenue. Are waitress was kind and friendly and my tacos 🌮 were awesome. Thank you Pizza King keep up your 5 star reputation.“

“Best Hawaiian I've had in a long time. BBQ with chicken, bacon, Canadian ham, pineapples, banana peppers, and black olives or onions. Or both! Try a vegie pizza too. Bells, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, and spinach with marinade. Top it with pepperoni if you need a meat. Only thing negative I can say is the pepperoncinis that come with the pizzas are terrible. Dry and taste off. Thats why I'm giving 4 stars. It's like that at every store and it's why I just buy a jar from a market instead. Otherwise you can't beat BIG Papa's pizza. Cheese stuffed EVERY TIME! 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕“