Hilby’s Bar and Grill

1718 I Ave, New Castle
(765) 529-9711

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

2 lb Cod Fish Sandwich

lb Breaded Tenderloin

Lays Potato Chips

Hot Cheese Balls

Sausage Sandwich

1 2 lb Hamburger

Fried Mushrooms

Chicken Planks

Scooter Wings

Mini Corndogs

Photos

+16 photos

+15 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Food was good with an amazing drink menu. We went out there on a Saturday night, and stayed for a few hours. Not much of a crowd, but also not complaining. The drinks and food were very affordable

Kid-friendliness: It's a bar.

December 2024

This place is great! Way better than the other bars in town. No better bar to hangout at than one that is clean and has a good atmosphere. To top it off the food is amazing. I’ve never been disappointed.

September 2024

I really wanted to be able to give them higher marks, but I just can't. Four of us stopped in about 9 on a Friday night. Only 1 person at the bar. Bartender was friendly. Young man was cooking. We ordered drinks, apps and burgers, wings, burrito. The drinks were in very small cups, Crown Royal was $6. Ok, if it came in a grown-up cup. Draft beer was stale/skunked. Apps came out, pickle straws and mushrooms. Both tasty and reasonably priced. Burgers and wings came out. Both...

August 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in New Castle, IN

Hilby’s Bar and Grill

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Hilby’s Bar and Grill