The Taste Of Tradition Bakery

13302 Irving Rd, New Haven
(260) 413-1166

Recent Reviews

Kim Freiburger

We took home a blueberry pie that was the best I've ever tasted! This is a do again!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Timothy Vogel

Amish bakery that is very much worth the

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Lehman

The finest quality. Well worth it.

Adam Shotzman

Well if you want your mouth to water as soon as entering the building.... you found the place. Best pies with the most amazing, tantalizing, magnificent cinnamon rolls!!! I had 2 gone before I left the parking lot the first time there. ?

Taylor Caldwell

I know they be helping with the food boxes here in fort Wayne and them red velvet cupcakes to die for

Local Guide

Too be honest, I'm not sure why anyone would give this place less than a 5 star review. I've never been a big fan of pies but the pies at this place are beyond amazing IMHO

Denise Knowles

We bought 50 small pies for our Christmas party.The pies were amazing. The crust is so delicious you could eat it plain.10 stars isn't enough.You have a new loyal customer, and I am excited to try everything.

Jasper Higgins

The shop where I work gets baked goods from here for the employees on Fridays. It's always good!

Linda

Good baked items! Pies, cookies, cinnamon rolls. The pumpkin pie and soft sugar cookies were wonderful. They sell fresh eggs too. The place is spotless!It's a drive for me but well worth the drive.You might want to call first to see if they have what you want, I get the feeling they sell out fast.

Jessica Gianelloni

Hands down, this is the best bakery in Fort Wayne. All the pies are delicious, but the sugar creme is my favorite. You won't find cinnamon rolls that are better anywhere in the entire country. They sell out fast so it's best to make an order a day or two before you go so they have what you are looking for. Trust me, It's worth the little drive for the deliciousness that awaits you here.

Madison Parker Cruz

The cinnamon rolls are the best I've ever had!! The PIES?, the cookies??, everything that comes out of the building is top notch!!!

Kathy Jackson

Nice people great pie. Got the sweet dill pickles for the first time and they are delish nice and crunchy.

matt black

Too be honest, I'm not sure why anyone would give this place less than a 5 star review. I've never been a big fan of pies but the pies at this place are beyond amazing IMHO

Jeremy Spray

Wonderful place to get home made bread,pies, jams, cookies. Lg and small pies: Blueberry, cherry, sugar creme, apple, peach, strawberry rhubarb, peacan. Molasses cookies, chocolate chip,sugar cookie, oatmeal cookie. Really friendly people.

Jeff Belknap

Rich cinamon breakfast rolls and oatmeal raisin cookies. All natural ingredients.

Load More