Y-Not Pizza & Lounge
45 E Main St, New Palestine
(317) 861-5225
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Calzone with Onion and Mozzarella
Breadsticks with 4 Oz Cheese or Marinara
Chicken Tenders with a Side of Sauce
Boneless Hot Wings with One Dressing
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Create Your Own Calzone
Boneless Hotwing Sub
Pretzel Breadsticks
Nacho Cheese Fries
Two Toppings Pizza
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
First time there. The pizza is worth another trip, but they got my name wrong on my phone in order. The girl corrected it, but another guy behind the counter accused me of already picking up a pizza. When he was corrected by a female coworker, he didn't apologize and just walked away. Bad vibes.
The pepperoni rolls are the best! I get them weekly. Yummy. Tony, the owner, is a doll. He is kind, gentle and loves his pizza joint.
They need to be open earlier in the day pretty please!
They need to be open earlier in the day pretty please!
Man the pizza is amazing the service though always sucks. And the building itself is like falling apart in places.My real gripe is with the rude older woman who works in the kitchen and the fact that they charge an extra percentile to process card payments. I tried to suggest other payment processors and she got huffy with me like I had insulted her. Idk I'll order carryout here but I'll wait for other people to cash me out.
You May Also Like
The New Pal Pub - 19 S Bittner Rd
![]()
American, Bar, Comfort Food, Vegetarian
Smokin’ Barrel BBQ NEW PAL - 28 E Main St
![]()
Barbeque, Venues & Event Spaces
The Nopal - 38 W Main St
![]()
Mexican