We are big fans of their New York style pizza. We usually get bacon and sausage on our pizza, but today we decided to try beef and bacon and get this-unlike a lot of pizza places where it feels and tastes like with the beef that said place just cooked it up and threw it on the pie with no seasonings or just used salt and pepper--Little Angelos flavored the beef with actual seasonings and it was good, a nice balance of flavor and not too salty at all. I am also really partial to their pizza sauce because its not overly salty and it has a nice flavor.
It's hard to find a place in the area that kind of checks all the boxes for me even though i like all types of crust- some places just dont do theirs well or their sauce is off or their toppings are wrong. This place does everything they do right in the pizza department.
If i had one criticism or complaint it would be their online ordering absolutely DOES NOT work if you want custom toppings of 2 or more. So that would be it. But they're usually available on the phone for pickup orders and they have a drive-thru window so its not really inconvenient in the slightest.
Denisa Selby
My husband and I love this place. It's small but it's never been busy when we have went. The service and food has always been really good and our kids LOVE the pizza!
John Roberts
Wonderful food, good portions, great service.
Lynn Washburn
Food was excellent as was the service. Will come again. Was in Evansville for a Dr appointment on Valentines day and was able to get a table.
Thomas
Ordered take out pizza they said they were busy and would take 30-45 mins, I said ok I’ll wait. Well I waited and waited finally went to ghe girl who took my order told her is my takeout order done it’s been over an hour, she seemed surprised I didn’t get it. She went to the kitchen came out with the pizza, guess what the pizza must have been sitting there a long time it was cold. For some reason she must have thought the pizza would just magically fly out to me
Janis Beasley
Kailyn was our server. She was pleasant and was efficient . Food was tasty!
Jerome Dwanyen Mhango
Just had lunch here today! I had the Chicken, Shrimp, and Scallops Fettuccine Alfredo at Little Angelo’s, and I have to say, it was hands down the best I’ve ever had! The creamy Alfredo sauce was perfectly rich and decadent, complementing the tender chicken, succulent shrimp, and perfectly seared scallops. Every bite was a burst of flavor, with the pasta cooked to perfection. The portion size was generous, and the service was excellent; friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. If you’re looking for authentic, delicious Italian food, Little Angelo’s is a must-visit! I’ll definitely be coming back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Smith
Had lunch at this cute restaurant. Sat in the bar area and was attended to by our friendly waitress who made the perfect recommendation (portobello mushroom ravioli). Had a great experience, the food was fantastic, and Hamzeh visited our table for a short chat - a nice touch.
Safety Dan
Seriously not worth the inflated prices. The Italian dressing is amazing but everything else was nothing to wright home about. The mozzarella sticks were cold in the middle, the garlic rolls were hard and cold, the shrimp appetizer was very fishy..... and the chicken parm were 4 tiny pieces of chicken tenders which were soooo soggy from the red sauce. Had to try the place after being told that it was not good. Will never return here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ghenny Uzcategui
Bad place and environment. The staff isn't friendly. Low quality and little quantity of food. In addition, you should pay mandatory 20% tips and, 3% fee if you want to pay with your card. No Restaurant in area has these rules and, they're better in all as this place.
My kids are picky eaters and they loved everything! Everything was delicious and the waitress we had was super nice and great at her job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daft Nko
While in town visiting a friend, they brought me here to eat. A decent meal at a decent price and very delicious garlic rolls. Our meal was delayed due to issues in the kitchen, but our waitress did her best to salvage our visit. She was very apologetic and kind, despite being called numerous cruel names and cussed at by someone in the kitchen, which at times we could overhear. I can’t remember our waitress’ name now, but I hope she’s okay and the boss takes care of the rude kitchen staff member.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls, Shrimp Parmigiana with Angel Hair Pasta
Randy Appler
Food good. Bad black flies around, and terrible in restroom . Pitcher catching water from leaking toilet. Safety issue,and health issues!
jbethel11
The food is always great here and the atmosphere is inviting. However the service is terrible. It has taken several bad experiences for me to finally post a review. Probably because the food itself has outweighed the service issues but not anymore. Every time I order carry out something is forgotten. Usually small like a side salad or some rolls. I have not encountered a smiling attentive or even nearly prompt staff member since visiting this restaurant. This time, after waiting for the waitress to finish her vape session, she brought out my order all in a plastic sack and just handed to me without saying a word. She stared at me briefly before saying “what!” I said I am missing a pizza, yes a whole 16” pizza right on the receipt and order ticket. She stormed off back to the kitchen and grabbed the pizza and then, as fast as I have ever seen a waitress here move, came toward me and tossed the pizza on the counter without saying a word and took back off through the kitchen doors. I average $60 a carry out and we get carry out at least twice a month. Not a big loss for this store. Thanks to the waitress working last night with really dark black hair I will not be returning. She is also the reason I don’t add tips without having been provided the service first.
We are big fans of their New York style pizza. We usually get bacon and sausage on our pizza, but today we decided to try beef and bacon and get this-unlike a lot of pizza places where it feels and tastes like with the beef that said place just cooked it up and threw it on the pie with no seasonings or just used salt and pepper--Little Angelos flavored the beef with actual seasonings and it was good, a nice balance of flavor and not too salty at all. I am also really partial to their pizza sauce because its not overly salty and it has a nice flavor.
It's hard to find a place in the area that kind of checks all the boxes for me even though i like all types of crust- some places just dont do theirs well or their sauce is off or their toppings are wrong. This place does everything they do right in the pizza department.
If i had one criticism or complaint it would be their online ordering absolutely DOES NOT work if you want custom toppings of 2 or more. So that would be it. But they're usually available on the phone for pickup orders and they have a drive-thru window so its not really inconvenient in the slightest.
My husband and I love this place. It's small but it's never been busy when we have went. The service and food has always been really good and our kids LOVE the pizza!
Wonderful food, good portions, great service.
Food was excellent as was the service. Will come again. Was in Evansville for a Dr appointment on Valentines day and was able to get a table.
Ordered take out pizza they said they were busy and would take 30-45 mins, I said ok I’ll wait. Well I waited and waited finally went to ghe girl who took my order told her is my takeout order done it’s been over an hour, she seemed surprised I didn’t get it. She went to the kitchen came out with the pizza, guess what the pizza must have been sitting there a long time it was cold. For some reason she must have thought the pizza would just magically fly out to me
Kailyn was our server. She was pleasant and was efficient . Food was tasty!
Just had lunch here today! I had the Chicken, Shrimp, and Scallops Fettuccine Alfredo at Little Angelo’s, and I have to say, it was hands down the best I’ve ever had! The creamy Alfredo sauce was perfectly rich and decadent, complementing the tender chicken, succulent shrimp, and perfectly seared scallops. Every bite was a burst of flavor, with the pasta cooked to perfection. The portion size was generous, and the service was excellent; friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. If you’re looking for authentic, delicious Italian food, Little Angelo’s is a must-visit! I’ll definitely be coming back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had lunch at this cute restaurant. Sat in the bar area and was attended to by our friendly waitress who made the perfect recommendation (portobello mushroom ravioli). Had a great experience, the food was fantastic, and Hamzeh visited our table for a short chat - a nice touch.
Seriously not worth the inflated prices. The Italian dressing is amazing but everything else was nothing to wright home about. The mozzarella sticks were cold in the middle, the garlic rolls were hard and cold, the shrimp appetizer was very fishy..... and the chicken parm were 4 tiny pieces of chicken tenders which were soooo soggy from the red sauce. Had to try the place after being told that it was not good. Will never return here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Bad place and environment. The staff isn't friendly. Low quality and little quantity of food. In addition, you should pay mandatory 20% tips and, 3% fee if you want to pay with your card. No Restaurant in area has these rules and, they're better in all as this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Alfredo
My kids are picky eaters and they loved everything! Everything was delicious and the waitress we had was super nice and great at her job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While in town visiting a friend, they brought me here to eat. A decent meal at a decent price and very delicious garlic rolls. Our meal was delayed due to issues in the kitchen, but our waitress did her best to salvage our visit. She was very apologetic and kind, despite being called numerous cruel names and cussed at by someone in the kitchen, which at times we could overhear. I can’t remember our waitress’ name now, but I hope she’s okay and the boss takes care of the rude kitchen staff member.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls, Shrimp Parmigiana with Angel Hair Pasta
Food good. Bad black flies around, and terrible in restroom . Pitcher catching water from leaking toilet. Safety issue,and health issues!
The food is always great here and the atmosphere is inviting. However the service is terrible. It has taken several bad experiences for me to finally post a review. Probably because the food itself has outweighed the service issues but not anymore. Every time I order carry out something is forgotten. Usually small like a side salad or some rolls. I have not encountered a smiling attentive or even nearly prompt staff member since visiting this restaurant. This time, after waiting for the waitress to finish her vape session, she brought out my order all in a plastic sack and just handed to me without saying a word. She stared at me briefly before saying “what!” I said I am missing a pizza, yes a whole 16” pizza right on the receipt and order ticket. She stormed off back to the kitchen and grabbed the pizza and then, as fast as I have ever seen a waitress here move, came toward me and tossed the pizza on the counter without saying a word and took back off through the kitchen doors. I average $60 a carry out and we get carry out at least twice a month. Not a big loss for this store. Thanks to the waitress working last night with really dark black hair I will not be returning. She is also the reason I don’t add tips without having been provided the service first.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls
Loading...