Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery

Food was amazing!! Service was less than stellar. No refills on our drinks and only checked on us once.

The pizza is great. However, when the beer starts tasting like vinegar, it's time to flush the keg. The Bulldog and the stout were drinkable, and I struggled with the blonde. Seriously guys. Quit trying to pass vinegar off as beer. I always try a Brewski tray to see if the situation has improved, but 3 or 4 always taste like beer from a stripper's ass crack. As much as I hate to say it, Mich Ultra is a safe bet.

I was at Turonis in Newburgh last Sunday the 18th. Picking up a medium pizza with beef and extra cheese and cheese bread. I took it to my 87 year old Mom who is a resident at Newburgh healthcare. She loves Turonis pizza. Sorry to say we opened it and it was burned! She was so disappointed and so was I since I just paid for all of it. I've called several times and they keep telling me there's nothing they can do and they will give the message to the manager when she comes in. She must not be there often because I've heard nothing from her. It's an understatement to say how bad customer service is at Turonis in Newburgh. My phone number is 270-860-5354 and I'll also post a picture. I would appreciate a call back and a refund.

We spent 60 dollars for food that was burnt and cold. The kids cheese pizza was burnt about an inch around the crust, leaving only a small edible portion. The fries were absolutely disgusting (burnt and cold). The other 2 pizzas were not up to the standard for this restaurant. They were overcooked and served cold.

Stopped by Turonis Newburgh for a House Special pizza and one of their craft brews the Honey Blonde. The pizza was flavorful and the beer was great! Highly recommended trying out this local pizzeria!!

Best pizza in town, everyone needs to come here. Tastes like real legit pizza! I recommend the meaty pizza.

Great pizza, but needs a website that allows online ordering. C'mon man, this is 2025.

Pizzas are always fantastic, the service doesn't disappoint, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting! Highly recommend!!

Great pizza, nice people, with a cozy feel. Visited this location many many times, they are plentiful with their toppings and the quality is still good. I’ve visited all their locations, and they are all great, but I’ve had this one the most. It is a bit pricy though, but leftovers are great!

The service and atmosphere are decent but the food is not too good.You’d think it be the same as the other ones but it’s not. It’s always undercooked and never any good the only good thing is the brownie. If you’re looking for good cooked pizza don’t come here go to the one in downtown Evansville.

Though I’ve had several fine experiences at this location, tonight’s was extremely unfavorable. I ordered a house special with no olives or mushrooms & breadsticks (for pickup).

After I got the pizza home, I realized part of the pizza was burnt, and they forgot the pepperoncinis. I called to see if there was anything they could do, and they said I could come back & they’d give me the pepperoncinis; I could also bring back the pizza and they’d remake it or give me a refund. Those were my only choices.

I chose the last option.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Way way way overpriced!!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Good beer and pizza. I stop by every time I'm in town for a Thunder bolt and a pie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This would be where one goes to be robbed in Newburgh. One large carry out pizza should never cost $42. no way, that's insane. I've eaten here before, I know for a fact the pizza ain't that good. Someone is making a killing, here.

I thoroughly enjoy their food & service everytime I eat here, typically once per month. Highly recommend their "house special" pizza and a side of cheesy bread.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stromboli, Pizza