Over the Top Bakery Cafe
112 N Main St, North Liberty
(574) 656-3321
Customers' Favorites
Apple Fritter
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Sheet Cake
Doughnut
Wrap
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I have used over the top bakery for years now for special family events and they have never disappointed. I have had some pretty unique design request and they have always gone above my expectations. Thank you again for another great order. Would recommend over and over again.
I own The Cornerstone at Cedar wedding venue in Bourbon, Indiana. We enjoy cupcakes every weekend from different bakeries, but these are definitely some of the best cupcakes. They are moist, and the frosting is perfect . Job well done!
This bakery has THE BEST plain cheesecake, topped with strawberries, I’ve ever had! I ordered the cheesecake because it’s my nephew’s favorite and we were celebrating his birthday. Everyone thought it was so light and creamy and it was topped with enough strawberries for every bite. It didn’t last long! The only downside is they don’t sell individual slices, as of this review, because I know others who would like to try it vs having to order an entire cake. I’ll be...
You May Also Like
Home Towns Pizza - 210 West Maple Avenue
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Sandwich Shop, Bar
Subway - 511 Roosevelt Rd
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food