Monroe Pizza Company

250 N Main St, Oakland City
(812) 749-3292

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brady King

Wow. Just wow….

Fantastic pizza from a fantastic crew. Perhaps the most exemplary mom-and-pop pizza joint, from display to devour. Super clean, super tasty.

The only thing I didn’t like - I couldn’t eat more !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Brock

Best pizza joint in the area easily!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Norrington

The food was really good to night thank

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alice Titus

To be honest, my first impression of this pizza shop was that the pizza I got was great, both in terms of cooking and the color of the pizza👍

Jacqueline Hardin

The first time my family ordered from there was definitely mediocre, and the price didn’t reflect the price online, no biggie, brushed it off as maybe the website hasn’t updated. Gave them another try last night, and oh my gosh. The pizza and dessert pizza was absolutely delicious. The order was correct, (we had a special request on the pizza), we definitely will be ordering again!

Food: 5

Kimi Stanton

Didn't give us our whole order then tried to say we didn't order part of it.

Service: 1

Georgie Richey

My mom ordered 5 thing and only got 4 when, she called they said she never ordered the 5th thing. The woman on the phone was very rude. NEVER ORDERING HERE AGAIN!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

chris lynn

Zero stars across the board waited 2 hours for my family's order had to call and then was delivered cold burnt and bread sticks were hard as a rock and when complaining was offered a credit only and was offered no explanation or apology they no longer care about serving there community with pride. It's outdated and time for it to go before someone gets deathly sick from it

Carissa Brown

I went to pick up my order and the lady was very rude and unfriendly it made the simple transaction tense and uncomfortable. She wouldn't hand me my card instead tossed it on the counter and was giving me nasty glances. This is the 3rd time I ordered here and will be my last moms diner pizza is better in my opinion anyways.

Emily Hoskins

Some of the best pizza ever! Delivery is always fast too.

Steve Tignor

House made dough and hand tossed, great food all around.

Charles Stock

Very good service always pleased with food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza

Soso Cupid

My first time trying this pizza with my family was yesterday I had it delivered and they were fast, friendly, and careful. Me, my daughter, and my boyfriend loveeeeee the pizza and the girl on the phone recommended the s’mores desert and boy was she right!!!!! So freaking good!!!!. My daughter loves pizza but with her only being 1 she tends to play with her food and throw it around but with this pizza she ate every single bite and the sweets!!!! Today we just had to re order it. When I called to place another delivery it’s like the girl remembered me from yesterday she already knew what I was after and my location!!!!! My fave pizza place now and I recommend the smores desert and now they cherry one it’s so so so good!!!! And cheap!!!!!!

Kid-friendliness: My one year old loved every bite and she is extremely picky specially with her pizza so that must say a lot!!! Her first time ever finishing a food menu on her own!!!! And when the guy delivered it yesterday my daughter ran out to greet him and he was so sweet and kind to her she had an amazing time. And today my dog ran out (he is trained without a leash) and he jumped on the delivery man but I apologized and the delivery man was so kind even played with the doggo

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Mozzarella Bread, Dessert Pizza

Missa Deffendall

Absolutely love them!!!! They NEVER disappoint!!! Always go above and beyond for my special dietary needs and have never once made me feel like it was an inconvenience!!!!

Dietary restrictions: They have never once made me feel like my restrictions were an inconvenience and have always been accommodating !!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Philly Steak & Cheese Sub, Deluxe Pizza, Meat Pizza, Baked Spaghetti, Dessert Pizza, Breadsticks

Monalweisling

We had ham and cheese and Philly steak. The price was extremely low. The taste was great.. I would rather pay more and had more meat on sandwiches. Really scanty on meat and cheese... Which is the reason it will not become a regular place for us to eat.The service was good. We were impressed with how hard the kids worked in the back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Loading...