Totally Baked Sweets, LLC

1305 W Mulberry St ste b, Salem
(812) 844-2831

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lydia Hanlin

I ordered a Baby Shark cake for my daughter’s first birthday, and it came out amazing!! Was exactly what I asked for. Plus the cake and icing was extremely good! It’s hard to find a cake that isn’t dry. This was very moist, and the icing was great! I definitely recommend

Samantha Holliday

I stopped by today and got some goodies to munch on while watching the Derby. Everything was so AMAZING 🤩 The brownies were the BOMB 💣

Chelsea Koenig

Got a variety of cookies today and OH EM GEE sooooo yummy! Definitely going back soon. 🥰🩷

Caitlin Strange

10/10 on the Smash cake and Cupcakes she made for my Daughter's Birthday! Kinsley turns a WILD ONE tomorrow!

Brooklynn Michael Tankersley

Needed a cake quick and she was very accommodating.The cake was absolutely beautiful and taste amazing 10/10 recommend.

Jessica Humphrey

This place is Delicious! So very clean! And the staff is so very friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LeaAnn Williams

Wonderful, MacKenzie baked a gluten free cake for my daughter. My daughter said it is the best cake she has ever eaten!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Cindy Morris

I love this place. Service is always fast, polite and courteous.
Shop is clean and always smells sooo good

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp is available inside

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Fresh Baked Cookies

Tifini Ashby

I will tell everyone I know about this bakery! The price was great. The cake looked and taste amazing. ⭐️Highly recommend ⭐️

Tiffany Martin

Second celebratory cake we have ordered and ate and yet again delicious. Super moist, fresh and so good.

Lacy Jo Switzer

Totally Baked Sweets accommodated our small wedding dessert order for us last minute! We ordered an array of desserts with some special requests, and the order was ready and available for pick up earlier than expected on date to pick up. Delicious desserts! Great customer experience! Highly recommended!

Dana Carey

They are very friendly & down to earth plus the food is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Autumn Gibson

Love this small town charming bakery! The people I can tell work very hard and are great at answering questions, making recommendations, and displaying great hospitality. Got a frappe which was a delicious and a much needed pick me up! Prices are reasonable. Strawberry cookie was amazing and unique. Choc muffin was yummy. Will be back to try the fruit pizza and macaroons. Encourage everyone to support this up and coming business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Baked Cookies

Jamie Strothoff

If you want amazing, melt in your mouth desserts, this is the bakery to go. The staff is very helpful and owner definitely knows her GOD given craftsmanship. For such a young business you would think she has been in the game for decades. Her style is unique, crafty and delicious. I can't really put a review on the how delicious the cupcakes, cookies, pies are..... it's just something you have to experience for yourself. You have a customer for life. Thank you.... Jamie Lee Strothoff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Boone

Great ppl and great sweets.!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Baked Cookies

Loading...