Plymouth Rock Café

452 E Christmas Blvd, Santa Claus
(812) 937-4401

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris Atkins

Please bring back the fried chicken!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ivy

Very good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Turkey Plate

Steve von Sothen

Free parking! Free soft drinks! Free sunscreen!

CalebT

I had beef brisket, sweet potatoes, corn, and a roll. Quite pricey ($20), but the food was hot, was cooked all the way, and tasted good. The building was large and clean as well. Easily one of the best restaurants in the park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Beef Brisket

Evan House

While the atmosphere and service are unremarkable, the food items were all delicious and very flavorful. Highlights are the sweet potato casserole, green beans, corn, and pulled pork.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Roasted Turkey Plate, Pulled Pork Plate

Greg White

Worst brisket I've ever eaten. This (in the picture) was a $19 serving.. lol

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Eric Esty

A real Thanksgiving dinner this is not. Instead of big slices you get weird dry shredded turkey. It's okay, not as good as I remember.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Turkey Plate, Pulled Pork Plate

Fred Jan

Not really that great. I like thanksgiving food but theirs is old and dry and bland and not seasoned very well. Sort of just mass-produced cafeteria food. The service isn’t very kind or helpful and lacks knowledge about their menu or restaurant as a whole. It’s kind of dirty and run down, especially for a theme park eatery. They kinda awkwardly watched us the whole time, I don’t know why. Did we look suspicious? And I guess they’re card only, which is a problem for most today, but we had cash and did not have card and they said we’d have to go all the way across the park to get cash converted into a card and that they’d leave the food on counter and said we must hurry. I mean I’m not rushing for that, the food is gonna be cold by the time we’re back, and you’re gonna throw it away now that you got the food out. They didn’t say anywhere that they don’t accept cash. And for two of us to eat just two normal meals that wouldn’t have filled us up, it was almost $70.
I don’t know y’all, just find somewhere better in the park or sneak in food honestly. Your own food will taste better, fill you up, and is cheaper.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Laura

The water rides, 3 wooden coasters, and you can catch Fourth of July, Halloween, thanksgiving, and Halloween all in one park!

Logan Coleman

The food was awesome, the brisket was so juicy and flavor filled. The Mac and cheese was lacking a bit on flavor and it was kinda dry. The cinnamon apples were some of the best I've had. The service was great. I didn't really go at a busy time in the day so it wasn't packed. Around 3:30 ish.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lee Huffman

We had so much fun at @holidayworld & #SplashinSafari 🤩 We’ll def be back 🙌

Chris Cox

Nice food options available that were not the typical food available at a theme park.

Dylan

Not awful, but pretty bland and decently expensive for what you get.

Diana Lynn Rathke

I love Thanksgiving day food. Though, I am from New England & I'm surprised that they didn't have any seafood. At least fish or shrimp. (Though, we bury our lobster, clams, whole potatos & corn cobs on hot coals in the sand.)

Derp88_

Not awful, but pretty bland and decently expensive for what you get.

Loading...