Restaurants near Santa Claus

“Arrived in Santa Claus Indiana early for a family get away. Our hotel Santa’s lodge had a pizza place (fat Santa’s) that was closed even though Google said they were open so we decided to head to subway which also didn’t update their Google. We found a pizza place nestled behind subway in the plaza and decided to give them a try. We were greeted by an older female staff member who gave us a warm welcoming. Pizza was amazing for the price and the breadsticks were amazing. 5 stars for this little pizza place we will be back before our trip is over for some amazing pizza!”

“My husband got the chocolate cool mint milkshake; he said the flavor wasn’t very overpowering but was very good and delicious. He would get it again. I got the birthday cake ice cream; it was good but light in flavor so much so that I almost couldn’t tell it was birthday cake flavored. I would get ice cream here again but would probably venture out and try a different flavor.”

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings”

“Perfect place to bring our kids while enjoying craft beer and daily specials!, Fresh food, and on point service.”

“Pizza was delicious! Big fan of the thinner style crust! Breadsticks and cheese were great as well. The ice cream can’t be beat!”

“Showed up 2 minutes before closing with my family of 5 & was welcomed in with open arms. Despite our late arrival, staff remained very friendly & professional. Food was prepared promptly & was delicious!!! Best Subway experience I've ever had!”

“Cleanest restaurant I have been in. On Wednesday, May 7, 2025, they served grit casserole baked with cheddar cheese and eggs. I ordered it and loved it. My husband also had grits and loved them. We had grits on Friday and ended up ordering the rest of the grits to take home. On Saturday I had strawberries and a half order of haystack. Everything was served hot and delicious, except the strawberries, they were cold and delicious. I will return for sure. Very nice family.”

“Very good food”

“We went in after a long day, and I got the ribeye. It was so good, it just melted in my mouth. I felt bad because we walked in at 8:15 on Friday, and I saw online that they serve until 9:30. They actually stop serving at 8:30. But the staff was super nice to us last-minute folks.”

“My family and I came for the first time and we loved it!!! The food, the environment, the place and service deserves 5k stars 🌟 and above 😉”

“I was born and raised in Evansville and moved to Oakland City in 2021. I always tell people that the best thing about moving here besides my husband was finding the Windmill Chill!!🍦🤍 Truly a hidden gem! 💎”

“We were so impressed with the kindness of the workers. In addition to supporting a very worthy cause, the restaurant was very family-friendly and accommodating.”

“Out of towners: My husband and I just ate at Fleigs and the menu was interesting to say the least. The owner was extremely welcoming, locals were inviting they made us feel like we fit right in. The food was great. We had the onion petals to start. I had the pork tenderloin, it was delicious. My husband had the steak burger and he said one of the best he had. Owner brought out chicken hearts for us to try since I had never heard of them. Hubby said they were good. 😊 We are in town for 2 days and may just go back!!”

“great food at great prices. excellent service.”

“Best place ever, beers are like $3 food is like under $10 service is best friendly, go-getter, funny people you'll ever meet and service is fast had a drink before i even sat down. Probably gonna go tell everyone on facebook and your grandma. Maybe even your neighbor. I love this place and this is my first time so I just know I will become a local here. Especially with these prices🤩 Just come join me, we wear black socks so find us.”

“I ordered shrimp on a beach and it tastes plain and chips are nasty and they didn't give me my cheese dip cost me $24 for one person”

“we first visited the bistro yesterday. if you enjoy a layed back home like place to eat with really great food. you have found it. we had the best smash hamburgers ever in this erea. from bacon ,oinon, and swiss mushroom. i would choose this over snitzelbank. yes ive been there. very overpriced. my husband loves mushrooms . and he could not rave enough . if you want a filling very juicy , thick hamburger you cannot go wrong. this sweet historic house now shinning a christmas pyramid ( i cant repeat german name) lol... it came over from germany and it shines ! please drop in you will not be disapointed. if i could id give this place 10 stars. and prices are very competitive. potatoes are not fried ,but cubed and tons of flavor. everything home made . if you drive on by ,you're misding out.”

“Great food and ice cream! Great pricing! Long business hours! Highly recommend!”

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“Your restaurant was recommended to us seeing we were visiting from Flushing MI. We stopped in on Friday and the waitress was absolutely amazing. Seeing we were still be in the area we made a reservation and enjoyed your Mother’s Day Buffet. Everyone we spoke to was beyond friendly to us and the food was delicious. If we’re ever in the area again we’ll be sure to stop by. Carolyn & Joseph Toth”

“Love this bar! Great owner and fun atmosphere!”

“Drove down here from Loogootee and glad I did. The food is delicious! Very nice restaurant, food was steaming hot. The fried dumplings are absolutely amazing. If you haven't had this, you definitely need to”

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“Delicious pizza and very friendly staff casual dining”

“I came here late at night and they didn't rudely close the lobby or anything like other places. Several people were there when I got there, and came in and out while I was there. Busy for as late as it was. The cashier was super nice and they made me fresh food. It was the best food and experience I've had at an Arby's in a LONG time. When I come back through this area, I will certainly be eating there again!”

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“My friend and I ordered two burgers with home fries and everything was delicious!!
I loved when Mokey Hollow was there because they're my favorite wine and the food was good, but this place nailed it on the food!!”

“Fast friendly service amazing food”

“We were in the area from Kansas City and only eat locally. This was our favorite restaurant of the weekend. Service was phenomenal. Pizza was the best. Highly recommended. If we are back in the area we will stop back by!”