Cute as a Cupcake! Cupcakery & Bake Shop

727 Main St, Schererville
(219) 319-0909

Recent Reviews

Mallory Lea

My order was completely wrong. It does not even match the card that was included. I can't even begin to tell you how dry they are. They completely lack flavor, they taste like they have been frozen for months. The owner refused to solve the problem. Her behavior was completely unprofessional. I definitely suggest Wicked Good Cupcakes. They are a little more, but totally worth it. The attitude alone from this place will keep me from ever ordering or suggesting this place to anyone. You would be better off buying box mix aft your local grocery store.

Detrell GRANT

Cupcake was delicious my kids love them! Best banana pudding, not even close.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina

Please list ingredients for customers. There are so many allergies out there.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Kay

Definitely not worth $5 a cupcake. It was falling apart and I’ve had box cake that tasted better.

Food: 1

Christina Harmon

Beautiful shop . Omg my Cupcakes were delicious . I read many reviews saying they were dry . But not at all . Nice texture and the frosting was so good Super nice lady at front . Thank you !! Can’t wait to get

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah P.

The place is super cute. We got some cupcakes and a pudding. The pudding was very good, but the cupcakes were small and dry. Very dry. I was surprised the price of the cupcake for how small it is. Other cupcakes shops might have the same price or little more but their cupcakes are very big. Her cupcakes are normal size.

Danielle Williams

I came for the first time today. It’s my little ones 3rd birthday. I got him the birthday cake cupcake.He hardly touched it after the first bite so my husband and I gave it a try. Very disappointing! Cupcake frosting literally tasted like SOAP and the cake itself was very dry. I wish I had checked reviews before coming here. I don’t plan to return.The customer service was great… but that was the worst cupcake I’ve ever had.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Amrit Nirlep

For the price (almost $4/cupcake), I would expect moist cupcakes. I tried 4 flavors and all 4 were dry and super sweet. The girl at the register was kind, service was no issue. While the cupcakes were decorated cutely, I will not return based off of what we tried. Honestly, cupcakes from a grocery store have been better.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

Succeedin F.

I had the opportunity to visit them this was not my first time but my phone was dead the last visits. The owner is AMAZING I had the opportunity to speak with her when I was coordinating an Event years ago. This is a hidden GEM and I would love to give her ideas to generate more business. I got 3 tasty treats today I got myself the red velvet, I got an Oreo and salted caramel. Sorry we ate them so fast I promise pics next time! Are you also Cute as a Cupcake? Do you like a great selection? Are you looking for a great place to meet a family member or a friend? If you answered YES, This is the place for you! I think it's also a good place to have a committee meeting! It's a great place to discuss a vacation! Perfect place to invite a neighbor, or someone that needs a taste of happiness. After all you see what the pink sign says......

Raemere Mitchell

It was my first time at this location and I will have to say it super adorable inside!! I love the selfie wall they have available to take pictures by but we can’t forget how good the cupcakes were!! I had the cookie dough cupcake and let’s just say to die for and I’m not even a chocolate lover but that chocolate cupcake was amazing and so moist. I also had the Redvelet cupcake and it was absolutely the best Redvelet cupcake I ever had. Definitely will be back again!!

J C

The Red Velvet Orea cupcake was superdry. I ended up throwing it away after two small bites.

Sherry Halsted

Cupcakes were great!!!!!! Very delicious not DRY AT ALL I don’t know what the other reviews are talking about the cupcakes were so soft and bursting with flavor I have to come back!!!

Raelynn Mitchell

Cupcakes were AMAZINGGGGGGG super moist and flavorful. They have so many different flavors and other items you can purchase. I LOVE THIS PLACE I never want to leave.

Eric Acosta

Flavor of the cupcakes are not good. Strange chalky-like under taste. It's not that they're dry or over/under baked, the flavors just don't mesh; if that makes any sense?

Claribel M

I appreciate that cute as a cupcake has vegan options, but I agree with the other reviews that say the cupcakes are dry. Icing tastes great but cupcake was dry. I won't be returning.

Load More

Cute as a Cupcake! Cupcakery & Bake Shop

727 Main St, Schererville, IN 46375
(219) 319-0909