Amy's Pizza

140 E Country Ln, Shipshewana
(260) 768-7323

Recent Reviews

Vince Lombardi

Very disappointed in the pizza. No recommendation here.

Suzann Olson

Pizza was good, and fokes were friendly.

Doug Hall

Friendly staff and charming atmosphere. Family friendly. Decent pizza.

Chellsea Weaver

Great place to eat. It's a family owned business and doesn't have a lot of help but they manage just fine. The food is great for the price.

What’s Next

We was very happy with our pizza and my wife said it was the best pizza she has had in a while. We would definitely recommend Amy’s!

Geoff Kent

Decent. Need more staff for dine in help however the ONE person that was there did a very good job and was very polite

Dennis Jock

Was open from 4pm to 8pm. Called at 4:05pm for a delivery order and was told 7pm was the earliest it could be delivered! I chose to pick it up. The pizza tasted like a sub par frozen one. I'm guessing they have a monopoly in the small town. Wouldn't get food from here again.

Family, Food & BBQ

Pizza was ok. Thought the crust and sauce needed more flavor. Didn't think the prices were to bad though. Place is kinda hard to find and is very dark in the parking lot

Tara York

pizza is ALWAYS hot and soooooo good. this is the ONLY place I'll order thin crust pizza from. My family drives about 20 mins (40 total) to get pizza from here despite having a couple places in town that serve pizza.

Ginny Lyon

We decided to try Amy's Pizza while we were traveling and we're glad we did.The owner waited on us, she was very nice. The food was delicious. Couldn't ask for more.

Robert Smethers

Bomb. Best pizza around

Jim Topping

Very cute place, pizza was good. Nice little non chain pizza place.

Ryan Low

It wasn't very busy. The food was reasonably priced. And the pizza was delicious

Daniel Connor

ordered meat pizza philly steak sub pizza burger and deep fried ravioli. everything was very good. highly recommend

Deborah Hite-Segler

Pizza, breadsticks and cheese sticks not that great.

Load More