Millie's Market Cafe

$$ • Soup, Cafe, Salad

225 N Harrison St #301, Shipshewana
(260) 768-7334

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Reviews for Millie's Market Cafe

It's literally one of the best restaurants I've been to. Most restaurants I review on here are because they weren't good, to say the least. This one was different. So for a bit of back story, I went to the Philippines for about 40 days, and when we got back home in Indiana, most food I wasn't satisfied with because the food here just isn't the same, but here, man I fulfilled me. The mushroom and Swiss is literally the best sandwich I had ever had. The wait times aren't long full review

Every time we're in Shipshewana, we stop here for lunch. The menu is basic: you mostly get sandwiches to choose from, along with chicken fingers, good soups and pies. Although simple, everything is made with an Amish twist. Homemade bread is used for all sandwiches, including the hamburgers. Plus, this is a place that characterizes the phrase "Service with a smile." You can find it on the top floor of Davis Mercantile.

Food is always tasty atmosphere is calm the food came quickly. The only negative was the waitress she only took our order brought us our food and drinks but never came back and ask for refills.

More Reviews(58)


View all photos


Monday 11:30AM - 3PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 3PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 3PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 3PM
Friday 11:30AM - 3PM
Saturday 10:30AM - 3PM
Sunday Closed