Faytastic Pizza
220 Main St, Shoals
(812) 247-2115
Customers' Favorites
Mozzarella Bread Sticks
Pepperoni Bread Sticks
Cheesy Bread Sticks
Garlic Butter
Pizza Sticks
Meat Lovers
Taco Pizza
Veggie
Wings
blt
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best pizza I've ever had it's always delicious and fresh made with real ingredients and cooked to perfection they also have some awesome sandwiches and a varaity of other foods everything there is great and good priced too. Definitely the best pizza in indiana we've been enjoying it for years and hopefully many more years to come!
Hole in the wall pizza joint. Sometimes great. Ingredients seem to change alot. Sometimes not so great. Had undercooked pizza there several times. It is overpriced. At the same time it's all shoals really has for pizza. If it was more friendly and Ingredients were consistent and cooked enough to get that awesome slightly browned cheesy goodness it would be 5 stars. But it's extremely inconsistent and sometimes the people there treat you like an inconvenience. A smiling...
We have only ordered food here once and it was a pizza. Very busy but friendly service. If you like the taste of homemade pizza, you will like this place. We will be going back. We want to try a few more of their options. We ordered take out.
You May Also Like
Velma's Diner - 304 Main St
![]()
Diner, American, Vegetarian, New American
Bauer Family Coffee Shop and Bakery - 314 4th St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee