My husband and I got the Delmonico steaks and they were overcooked and bland. My husband's was extra fatty. Sent them back and ordered two new meals. The walleye was overly lemony. It simply had too much lemon pepper on it. But it was too much. I had the shrimp alfredo. It was too salty and only had three shrimp. We paid for the meals and I realized I had been overcharged for my glasses of wine. But, I was tired of complaining.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Joseph Hunter
Great food..healthy serving..great rink selection ...ALL personal friendly and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Murph
The filet was cooked to just the right temperature and the pannini was delicious! The garlic potatoes looked grainy and unappetizing. Maybe just regular mashed would hit the spot. Our server, Teresa, was very attentive and accommodating.
PatrickC
My wife ordered quiche. Was only 3 couples in there and took a bit to get it us. When brought out it was absolutely burnt. Edges were black, could not even be cut with knife. Brought to manager attention. They took whole plate back before I could say to leave the rest of it there. I was already finished with my plate when my wife's plate came back. Not much better, bottom was burnt. Needless to say she didn't eat it. First experience at this restaurant and know I would never return. Was not offered anything to compensate for a totally ruined breakfast. Also ingredients listed on menu was not what was in it. It had mushrooms, peppers, and god knows what else. I do have a picture I would be glad to show you
PattiS
This was our 3rd time dining at this establishment. The bartender was fantastic and our wait staff fabulous!! The entertainment is wonderful and you are able to dine, chat with your table and still hear the music. We love this place. I am gluten free and they are always very attentive to my needs.
Husband Chicken over cooked and burnt, my French onion soup was Luke warm, overall very disappointed with our food, this was our 2nd time coming there for dinner, first time food was excellent, this time not a good experience.
DianeR
Our server Gabby was exceptional. Ambiance was quiet and we were able to converse with no distractions. Potato dishes were perfection. My French toast was delicious as was their chocolate cake.
Lynn G
Food was alright. Really enjoyed the flat bread pizza and shrimp Alfredo. The appetizers were very expensive for the serving. It's a beautiful restaurant though and the view is awesome. I'm glad I got to experience this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
maryluber1
Super place for brunch. Everyone enjoyed different selections - salmon, quiche, and caesar salad with chicken. Only one problem - salmon sliding off of bun.
DebbieN
Great staff the dueling piano players were great!! The drinks were very tasty as for the food it was ok! I have to say I'll give them another try I didn't look at the menu very well and I chose poorly so next time I think I'll get a pasta dish those looked great!! I got the flat bread and while it was very good it was very soggy and hard to pick up! But like I said the staff was great and the entertainment was outstanding!!
Ordered dinner, waitress was very nice. Food came without the side advertised. Asked if something could be substituted, she said no. Husband ordered dinner, broccoli was cold and so tough it could not be cut with a knife. It seems they aren't interested in repeat customers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Arian Wiedeman
I had high expectations, atmosphere was nice. Unfortunately food is not good, especially for the price. Came out Luke warm at best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
We met for 3:45pm. We sat immediately and took a little time for the server to come get our drink order. After we ordered drinks it took additional time for her to be able to gather our order. It appears they only had 2 waitresses serving all guests inside the dining room and pool areas. The manager brought our food out and was missing an item. Overall the food was good but service was less than expected especially with the higher prices Edgewater Cafe has. The waitress did the best she could when put in a bad situation from management. Overall 2 Burgers w / fries and a Soup and Salad - $59. Prices are salty for the service you receive.
Gary Kun
Wife had 3 egg breakfast, I had michigan smash burger. Both were excellent. Logan our server was excellent as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marianne L.
Service was good, food was very tasty! Small cafe but tastefully decorated. Only problem was if you are in a larger wheelchair the doorway is so tight that you will scratch the doorway to try to get in.
My husband and I got the Delmonico steaks and they were overcooked and bland. My husband's was extra fatty. Sent them back and ordered two new meals. The walleye was overly lemony. It simply had too much lemon pepper on it. But it was too much. I had the shrimp alfredo. It was too salty and only had three shrimp. We paid for the meals and I realized I had been overcharged for my glasses of wine. But, I was tired of complaining.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great food..healthy serving..great rink selection ...ALL personal friendly and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The filet was cooked to just the right temperature and the pannini was delicious! The garlic potatoes looked grainy and unappetizing. Maybe just regular mashed would hit the spot. Our server, Teresa, was very attentive and accommodating.
My wife ordered quiche. Was only 3 couples in there and took a bit to get it us. When brought out it was absolutely burnt. Edges were black, could not even be cut with knife. Brought to manager attention. They took whole plate back before I could say to leave the rest of it there. I was already finished with my plate when my wife's plate came back. Not much better, bottom was burnt. Needless to say she didn't eat it. First experience at this restaurant and know I would never return. Was not offered anything to compensate for a totally ruined breakfast. Also ingredients listed on menu was not what was in it. It had mushrooms, peppers, and god knows what else. I do have a picture I would be glad to show you
This was our 3rd time dining at this establishment. The bartender was fantastic and our wait staff fabulous!! The entertainment is wonderful and you are able to dine, chat with your table and still hear the music. We love this place. I am gluten free and they are always very attentive to my needs.
Husband Chicken over cooked and burnt, my French onion soup was Luke warm, overall very disappointed with our food, this was our 2nd time coming there for dinner, first time food was excellent, this time not a good experience.
Our server Gabby was exceptional. Ambiance was quiet and we were able to converse with no distractions. Potato dishes were perfection. My French toast was delicious as was their chocolate cake.
Food was alright. Really enjoyed the flat bread pizza and shrimp Alfredo. The appetizers were very expensive for the serving. It's a beautiful restaurant though and the view is awesome. I'm glad I got to experience this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Super place for brunch. Everyone enjoyed different selections - salmon, quiche, and caesar salad with chicken. Only one problem - salmon sliding off of bun.
Great staff the dueling piano players were great!! The drinks were very tasty as for the food it was ok! I have to say I'll give them another try I didn't look at the menu very well and I chose poorly so next time I think I'll get a pasta dish those looked great!! I got the flat bread and while it was very good it was very soggy and hard to pick up! But like I said the staff was great and the entertainment was outstanding!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered dinner, waitress was very nice. Food came without the side advertised. Asked if something could be substituted, she said no. Husband ordered dinner, broccoli was cold and so tough it could not be cut with a knife. It seems they aren't interested in repeat customers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I had high expectations, atmosphere was nice. Unfortunately food is not good, especially for the price. Came out Luke warm at best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
We met for 3:45pm. We sat immediately and took a little time for the server to come get our drink order. After we ordered drinks it took additional time for her to be able to gather our order. It appears they only had 2 waitresses serving all guests inside the dining room and pool areas. The manager brought our food out and was missing an item. Overall the food was good but service was less than expected especially with the higher prices Edgewater Cafe has. The waitress did the best she could when put in a bad situation from management. Overall 2 Burgers w / fries and a Soup and Salad - $59. Prices are salty for the service you receive.
Wife had 3 egg breakfast, I had michigan smash burger. Both were excellent. Logan our server was excellent as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was good, food was very tasty! Small cafe but tastefully decorated. Only problem was if you are in a larger wheelchair the doorway is so tight that you will scratch the doorway to try to get in.