I MUST SAY, I REALLY ENJOYED THE PIZZA HERE. I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR A GOOD PIZZA PLACE IN THE AREA WHEN I COME TO TOWN FROM CHICAGO AND IF YOU FIND YOURSELF IN THE SAME SITUATION, LOOK NO FURTHER. I TRIED THEIR THIN CRUST AS WELL AS THE PAN PIZZA AND BOTH WERE DELICIOUS. I PREFER THE PAN PIZZA OVER THE THIN (A MUCH THICKER DOUGH THAT'S AIRY, FLAVORFUL, AND MANAGES TO HAVE A CRISPY EXTERIOR WHILE BEING SOFT AND CHEWY IN THE MIDDLE) I NEEDED A BIT MORE SAUCE TO BALANCE OUT THE BREAD AND THEY EXECUTED IT WELL. I HAD A GREAT SERVER THAT WAS ATTENTIVE AND VERY INFORMATIVE WHEN IT CAME TO THE DIFFERENT PIZZA STYLES THEY OFFER. THANK YOU FOR PROVIDING US WITH GREAT FOOD AND A GOOD CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE. SEE YOU NEXT TIME!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Chicago, Chicago Pizza
Brooklynn LeDoux
Best pizza in the Michiana area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Pizza Pot Pie, Vodka Sauce, Slice of Pizza
Ebony Haynes
Let me start by saying I am a Chitown girl born and raised and pizza is my jam. I am not a fan of deep dish, too much for my mind and stomach to process. But since I have been in SB, I have only found 2 pizza places that can compete with Chitown and was looking for a 3rd. I am trying to stop eating dairy and cabs but was craving pizza. Since today was my cheat day, I decided to go for it. I ordered through Dine-In and chose Polito's because they had slices. I ordered one thin crust which is my go-to, and one thick, just to see what it was about. I waited, normal wait time, but when it arrived, it was cold??? Kinda side-eyed it, but I admit, I eat cold pizza, and I have an oven, so I was still willing to try it. After taking it out of the oven and adding a little parmesan cheese to it, it was still just meh. I love a mom and pop local joint, but as for pizza, for me, this was a no.
Food: 2
Tony Laskowski
Good pizza. The salad bar is good too. The service is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicago Pizza, Salad Bar
John Monnin
My wife and I really like Politios. She LOVES the Calzones and I like the pizza. The powdered sugar covered rolls were amazing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tracy F.
Worst pizza I ever had. Ordered the Works Chicago style pizza for carry out. The pizza was not circular and one side of the pizza was bent over itself to fit in the box. The vegetables were chopped up so small like they were put into a blender. The sausage was minimal and was only crumbles. Minimal sauce, so little cheese that you couldn't even tell if it had had any cheese. So disappointed and won't order again.
Troy Davidhizer
Good food and salad bar. Pizza has a very thick crust. Pasta is very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Carrie Gareave
I ordered Chicago style deep dish. It's actually Detroit style or tastes like the original pizza hut pan pizza. The ingredients taste fresh.
Got two stuffed pies for takeout last week when I was in south bend for an errand. They half baked them for me as I was getting them for dinner and left them unsliced. Buddy of mine turned me onto the place as his family always got their pies for family holiday get togethers. I find it interesting they pre bake the mushrooms before use so they don't water out the pizza. The staff was super friendly and helpful. While I waited I watched several take out orders go and it was prob 1-1:30? Was able to have a small slice left on my recommending friends grave as he passed several years ago. Hopefully a small family of animals ate well in the winter cold.
Parking: Parking lot flat and easy to get in and out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks, Salad Bar
Karen S.
Our pizza had rubbing alcohol or some sort of chemical compound on the bottom crust, we couldn't even eat it. When we called,the manager promised a full refund. She said it wouldn't be necessary to bring in the pizza. When we just went in for the refund we were thrown a $20 (which was NOT the total cost) and told we were lucky to be getting that. Definitely do not recommend. What a terrible way to treat your customers. Be careful what you eat from this restaurant, it may contain chemicals. Wish I could give zero stars.
Great pizza and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, super good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Stromboli, Meat Lover Stromboli, Salad Bar, Pepperoni Pizza
I MUST SAY, I REALLY ENJOYED THE PIZZA HERE. I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR A GOOD PIZZA PLACE IN THE AREA WHEN I COME TO TOWN FROM CHICAGO AND IF YOU FIND YOURSELF IN THE SAME SITUATION, LOOK NO FURTHER. I TRIED THEIR THIN CRUST AS WELL AS THE PAN PIZZA AND BOTH WERE DELICIOUS. I PREFER THE PAN PIZZA OVER THE THIN (A MUCH THICKER DOUGH THAT'S AIRY, FLAVORFUL, AND MANAGES TO HAVE A CRISPY EXTERIOR WHILE BEING SOFT AND CHEWY IN THE MIDDLE) I NEEDED A BIT MORE SAUCE TO BALANCE OUT THE BREAD AND THEY EXECUTED IT WELL. I HAD A GREAT SERVER THAT WAS ATTENTIVE AND VERY INFORMATIVE WHEN IT CAME TO THE DIFFERENT PIZZA STYLES THEY OFFER. THANK YOU FOR PROVIDING US WITH GREAT FOOD AND A GOOD CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE. SEE YOU NEXT TIME!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Chicago, Chicago Pizza
Best pizza in the Michiana area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Pizza Pot Pie, Vodka Sauce, Slice of Pizza
Let me start by saying I am a Chitown girl born and raised and pizza is my jam. I am not a fan of deep dish, too much for my mind and stomach to process. But since I have been in SB, I have only found 2 pizza places that can compete with Chitown and was looking for a 3rd. I am trying to stop eating dairy and cabs but was craving pizza. Since today was my cheat day, I decided to go for it. I ordered through Dine-In and chose Polito's because they had slices. I ordered one thin crust which is my go-to, and one thick, just to see what it was about. I waited, normal wait time, but when it arrived, it was cold??? Kinda side-eyed it, but I admit, I eat cold pizza, and I have an oven, so I was still willing to try it. After taking it out of the oven and adding a little parmesan cheese to it, it was still just meh. I love a mom and pop local joint, but as for pizza, for me, this was a no.
Food: 2
Good pizza. The salad bar is good too. The service is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicago Pizza, Salad Bar
My wife and I really like Politios. She LOVES the Calzones and I like the pizza. The powdered sugar covered rolls were amazing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Worst pizza I ever had. Ordered the Works Chicago style pizza for carry out. The pizza was not circular and one side of the pizza was bent over itself to fit in the box. The vegetables were chopped up so small like they were put into a blender. The sausage was minimal and was only crumbles. Minimal sauce, so little cheese that you couldn't even tell if it had had any cheese. So disappointed and won't order again.
Good food and salad bar. Pizza has a very thick crust. Pasta is very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I ordered Chicago style deep dish. It's actually Detroit style or tastes like the original pizza hut pan pizza. The ingredients taste fresh.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Got two stuffed pies for takeout last week when I was in south bend for an errand. They half baked them for me as I was getting them for dinner and left them unsliced. Buddy of mine turned me onto the place as his family always got their pies for family holiday get togethers. I find it interesting they pre bake the mushrooms before use so they don't water out the pizza. The staff was super friendly and helpful. While I waited I watched several take out orders go and it was prob 1-1:30? Was able to have a small slice left on my recommending friends grave as he passed several years ago. Hopefully a small family of animals ate well in the winter cold.
Delicious food!! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Polito's Lasagna, Pepperoni Stromboli, Mozzarella Sticks
It's
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Parking: Parking lot flat and easy to get in and out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks, Salad Bar
Our pizza had rubbing alcohol or some sort of chemical compound on the bottom crust, we couldn't even eat it. When we called,the manager promised a full refund. She said it wouldn't be necessary to bring in the pizza. When we just went in for the refund we were thrown a $20 (which was NOT the total cost) and told we were lucky to be getting that. Definitely do not recommend. What a terrible way to treat your customers. Be careful what you eat from this restaurant, it may contain chemicals. Wish I could give zero stars.