Whistle Stop Ice Cream

Can't really rate it - am surprised it has so many good reviews. Went in and it looked almost like an empty shop - was told at 7pm on a Friday ice cream was closed due to someone not being there. It looked run down and smelled a little strongly of the afghan food they serve there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

first time here the whole family loved it !
nice experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scoops, Waffle Cone, Sundae Ice Cream

Would rate this place zero stars if google maps let me. First of all the picture of the place is very deceiving, it’s just a small ice cream stall inside someone’s house with drab ambience, not like the tables shown. The guy at the counter looks defeated and looks like he already knows the ice cream is bad. Cookies and cream was just cream, no cookies. Bad service and worse ice cream somehow. Hope this place returns to its (possible) former glory, till then I’ll never be going back or recommending this to anyone.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Family of 12 went in and tried 8 of the flavors. All 8 flavors were great. Could definitely tell fresh home made ice cream. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very delicious ice cream but little variety of tastes. Very kind attention. Very nice establishment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

This place was a let down. Barely any ice cream left when we came in. Had some moosetracks and it tasted a bit freezer burnt. I expected more unique flavors and there was only like 1 everything else was standard.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Really good service, could use a littleing cleaning, but all the ice cream is home made.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split

Walked in and walked right back out… it was dirty and had a small selection of flavors. The place needs cleaning BAD. It just looks like it’s been ran through from everyone at Howard Park.It’s a waste of a great location, the owner obviously isn’t very involved and doesn’t seem to care too much about the place.

Atmosphere: 1

Kids loved ir

OK, I don't know who is leading these good reviews!! Was taking our four-year-old granddaughter to Howard Park and she wanted to go to an ice cream shop as well. I look for one nearest the park and of course this is right across the street. When we got there it appeared not to be open but there was a little paper clock on the window saying they opened at 4:00. We went back at four and it still didn't look open, no lights on, etc. but tried the door and it was open. A young man was sitting in the front window at a table working a model or something jumped up and scurried behind the counter, still no lights. We are peering into the dark case, trying to see the ice cream in the semi darkness, which looked like it had been there since May probably. He finally turned the lights on in the case and she made her selection. It made me nervous for you for even to eat that ice cream! This place was so dirty and creepy, I wouldn't recommend it to anybody!

It’s a small lack luster ice cream shop. Not that bad of ice cream though.

A nice neighborhood stop.

Top tier ice cream ??

Real ice cream,really good

LOCATION CLOSED.