Behind the Times Bakery
411 Main St, Tell City
(812) 772-2095
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Biscuits and Gravy
Snicker Doodle
Cinnamon Roll
Biscuit & Jam
Danishes
Muffins
Scones
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I started coming here faithfully about a week ago. I am more of a gas station kind of coffee guy. Never really thought coffee should cost an arm and a leg. Plus, I always made jokes at high end coffee spot to give me the coffee Jesus drank. But Behind in time made a believer out of me. I love there snickerdoodle hot coffee. It brings me back to when I would have coffee and cookies with my Nana. One of the reasons I believe it's name. Plus the way the coffee is made fresh...
Had the Pig & Pimento sandwich, I've never had one before. It was great. This is small shop has a cozy vintage atmosphere I simply adored. The stuff was small, but overabundance with small town charms. Can't wait to go back.
Love this bakery so much. The brown sugar rhubarb pastry is so delicious. Orange cardamom coffee cake was fantastic. The mini chocolate cake with buttercream & caramel sauce was so rich that it lasted me 4 days.
You May Also Like
Hideaway Tavern - 448 7th St
![]()
Bar, Pubs
Pour Haus - 706 Humboldt St
![]()
Pubs, American, Music Venues, Bar
The Post - 516 Main St
![]()
Tacos, Pizza