J&J's Pizza Shack

1454 Lincolnway, Valparaiso
(219) 476-1616

Recent Reviews

Sort by
C Thomas

I ordered sausage & cheese pizza 2 times to go. Nice and hot! Delicious! Has become my favorite pizza place! (I haven't eaten in their dining area so I do not feel like I could provide an honest rating.

Food: 5

Rachel Spore

The attitude from the people in this place is ridiculous for a small pizza shop.

Toni Hall

Amazing pizza and salads, delivery guys are always very nice and respectful to OE clients.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Walter Witzke

Really love the line up of pinball. ;)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Reese

My experience at JJ's has been disappointing, to say the least. On three consecutive occasions, our requests for extra cheese were ignored, and the pizzas were sauce-less. The cheese, rather than being stretchy, was stiff and unappealing. I suspect that JJ's may have switched to a cheaper cheese option, compromising the overall quality of their pizzas. As a loyal customer, I am disheartened by this decline in standards and can no longer recommend JJ's to others, and I will no longer be ordering here again..:/

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bill Kehoe

the food is always amazing. by far, my favorite pizza place. always do take out, I have never eaten at the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

tina dumigan

I ordered a small thin crust... Kitchen Sink.extra cheese 🤤 It is so delicious, Happy Holidays JJ'S PIZZA

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Grubb

Called and asked why I got the pizza I didn't order online, know what buttons I've hit, been a customer since I was none, I'm 47 , not really happy about the way I got treated, not a Karen, just not ho happy with the service, but that's now a days, you g kids don't give a shit!Well ........bye

Atmosphere: 1

Doug Zander

Good pizza at Fair price

Kid-friendliness: And we’re a little older kids, but the other kids that were there always seem to have a good time

Wheelchair accessibility: My husband’s in wheelchair we never had a problem

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza

Rich

This place was everything I was hoping for out of a community minded eatery. I was here for about an hour. The entire time I watched they were busy. The people around here LOVED the food. Folks were coming in non stop to pick up orders, calling continuously to place orders. I noticed a strange phenomenon in which as people were carrying food out others were jumping at the chance to hold the door for them. Until my own food arrived I didn't realize why. J&Js stacks topping on their pizza until they are heavy. The customer culture here just knows that a person carrying a pizza from this place needs a hand with the door. I started this review with that thought because if you are looking for dining ambiance this ain't the place. They have a lot of pinball machines and that's cool but I can tell the owners put priority on food which once you try it you will understand. If you are looking for good pizza try this place, just don't be upset about the wait. The wait is because they are busy. They are busy because they are good. Well worth the wait.

Kid-friendliness: Bring cash, let them play pinball

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jerry Whistlebrick

My car broke down while picking up a pizza. The staff members were super nice about me having to leave my car in their parking lot until the next day, and kept their word of but having my vehicle towed.
They're always just so nice, kind, and respectful, no matter what your business is there, not to mention, they're pizzas are .. Fire 🔥!! Go and get yourself and family and friends a good old Kitchen Sink, and you'll know what like and think!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kristine conley

The dining room is not clean.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread with Cheese, Stuffed Pizza

sherry masterson

Pizza was cheesy deliciousness! Super friendly staff. Although there was a dining room with many tables, I didn't see anyone dining in,maybe because of the time of day,not sure. They have arcade games which are always fun to play!! Seems like a family atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Dekoster

My order was wrong I didn't get the things that I paid for when I called back to the store on two separate occasions the lady was very rude with me and and said to me that the customer is always wrong so I I spent money on food that I'm not even happy with and they didn't offer any resolutions whatsoever because they're so close to closing she told me to deal with it and don't bother ordering from you guys again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Steve Rusnak

It's ok. Why would you put canned mushrooms? Why?! Service was perfect. Pizza was like their frozen pizza. Meh

Loading...