The gentleman got my order wrong and so I ended up having to pay for extra cheese that I didn't want. I wanted extra sauce. It barely had any sauce on it and the dessert Pizza was, oh my God, that was like almost twice as much as the. Regular Pizza, right? I couldn't believe it, but anyways, I didn't get what I wanted, and they didn't seem to care or fix it. They just looked at me like it was my fault.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Rachel West
Since I've had Tasty Pizza, I have a hard time enjoying other pizza in this area.This little gem is small but mighty. They make their own dough and sauce. They use REAL cheese. Everything just feels and tastes authentic. Love the pizza, pizza rolls, AND the subs. Totally worth the drive to Waterloo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Lars Warhammer
Everything has very good flavor. Subs, calzone's and the pizza. Chicken Bacon ranch is probably favorite yet preference for ham onion green olive. cheese, dough and SAUCE...all great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GB 80923
Last night we ordered from Tasty Pizza for the first time, the lovely girl I spoke with on the phone “promised I’d love it”; she wasn’t wrong! It was great! Both my husband and I enjoyed it greatly, and we were thrilled that they even delivered clear out to where we live. The pizza was hot, fresh and flavorful and arrived earlier than expected, we definitely will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lucy Meeks
First time order. Delivery was close to time quoted and pizza was great. Hand tossed crust was generous and lots of toppings. Will definitely order again, very impressed they delivered here at Story Lake
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Brown
When I am driving north from the Fort I will jump off I-69 & drive the mile or so to get a sub or small pizza. The menu is MASSIVE. almost everything on it is full of taste. The dough, sauce, cheese...excellent. I live in the Fort, and have had Lexys, Jets, Redwood, and the chain brands...but Tasty Pizza is the best. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce is divine. All 'Meatzza' is very meaty, but the Chicken Garlic Pizza maybe my fave. The building looks like an old dump but don't be fooled...I can't rave enough about the dough, cheese and sauce. Tasty Pizza truly delivers Taste!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Benjamin Gilmour
I drive semi and had a a tire blow out right across from ups on hwy 6 so I wasn't able to make it to the truck stop they delivered to me the delivery girl was very nice and so was the gentleman on the phone taking my order
Food: 5
Service: 5
Destinee Fuleki-Parker
My husband and I ordered from here a couple years ago when we lived in Auburn and then recently we moved to butler so we decided to try them again. And it was one of the best decisions we've made. The food is always delicious and fresh. Their delivery drivers are nice and delivery usually is less than their estimate. I recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza or the chicken club sub and their nacho cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hermila Hernandez
I order a sub, and it was hot and delicious! It came with chips and a pickle 😋 😋😋🤤 I will order again soon!
Tyler Bohler
Best pizza place around, recommend fur sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Club, Pepperoni Pizza, SM Garden Salad
Saw you were a new listing on door dash and decided to give a try, all 3 subs were awesome, and the pickles and chips are nice bonus , will definitely order again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Austin
Tried calling several times tonight and no one answered the phone, says online they are open and it's only 6pm on a Monday
Service: 1
Tessa Odell
Got mild wings were very hot. I ordered an Italian sub. Coated in garlic. Was not on the menu. Couldn't eat any
Rachel Kope
Customer service here has gone way downhill, rude Young employees and drivers.
Service: 1
Jacob Wallers
The food is good, but the service is hit or miss. They never add the coupons - from their own flier - despite mentioning it when ordering and giving the coupon to the person at the counter. Every time I've asked for an extra topping I've paid for it but not got it, and toppings are often on the light side. The one time I got delivery the driver was cool, but they had to make a second trip because while I was charged for a drink it wasn't put on my order. I love supporting local businesses but it's hard when I don't get what I ask for and pay for.
The gentleman got my order wrong and so I ended up having to pay for extra cheese that I didn't want. I wanted extra sauce. It barely had any sauce on it and the dessert Pizza was, oh my God, that was like almost twice as much as the. Regular Pizza, right? I couldn't believe it, but anyways, I didn't get what I wanted, and they didn't seem to care or fix it. They just looked at me like it was my fault.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Since I've had Tasty Pizza, I have a hard time enjoying other pizza in this area.This little gem is small but mighty. They make their own dough and sauce. They use REAL cheese. Everything just feels and tastes authentic. Love the pizza, pizza rolls, AND the subs. Totally worth the drive to Waterloo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Everything has very good flavor. Subs, calzone's and the pizza. Chicken Bacon ranch is probably favorite yet preference for ham onion green olive. cheese, dough and SAUCE...all great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Last night we ordered from Tasty Pizza for the first time, the lovely girl I spoke with on the phone “promised I’d love it”; she wasn’t wrong! It was great! Both my husband and I enjoyed it greatly, and we were thrilled that they even delivered clear out to where we live. The pizza was hot, fresh and flavorful and arrived earlier than expected, we definitely will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time order. Delivery was close to time quoted and pizza was great. Hand tossed crust was generous and lots of toppings. Will definitely order again, very impressed they delivered here at Story Lake
Food: 5
Service: 5
When I am driving north from the Fort I will jump off I-69 & drive the mile or so to get a sub or small pizza. The menu is MASSIVE. almost everything on it is full of taste. The dough, sauce, cheese...excellent. I live in the Fort, and have had Lexys, Jets, Redwood, and the chain brands...but Tasty Pizza is the best. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce is divine. All 'Meatzza' is very meaty, but the Chicken Garlic Pizza maybe my fave.
The building looks like an old dump but don't be fooled...I can't rave enough about the dough, cheese and sauce. Tasty Pizza truly delivers Taste!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I drive semi and had a a tire blow out right across from ups on hwy 6 so I wasn't able to make it to the truck stop they delivered to me the delivery girl was very nice and so was the gentleman on the phone taking my order
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I ordered from here a couple years ago when we lived in Auburn and then recently we moved to butler so we decided to try them again. And it was one of the best decisions we've made. The food is always delicious and fresh. Their delivery drivers are nice and delivery usually is less than their estimate. I recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza or the chicken club sub and their nacho cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I order a sub, and it was hot and delicious!
It came with chips and a pickle 😋 😋😋🤤
I will order again soon!
Best pizza place around, recommend fur sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Club, Pepperoni Pizza, SM Garden Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
Saw you were a new listing on door dash and decided to give a try, all 3 subs were awesome, and the pickles and chips are nice bonus , will definitely order again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried calling several times tonight and no one answered the phone, says online they are open and it's only 6pm on a Monday
Service: 1
Got mild wings were very hot. I ordered an Italian sub. Coated in garlic. Was not on the menu. Couldn't eat any
Customer service here has gone way downhill, rude Young employees and drivers.
Service: 1
The food is good, but the service is hit or miss. They never add the coupons - from their own flier - despite mentioning it when ordering and giving the coupon to the person at the counter. Every time I've asked for an extra topping I've paid for it but not got it, and toppings are often on the light side. The one time I got delivery the driver was cool, but they had to make a second trip because while I was charged for a drink it wasn't put on my order.
I love supporting local businesses but it's hard when I don't get what I ask for and pay for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Loading...