Nice little local pizza joint. Really like their cheese sticks and chicken bacon ranch calzone. Pizza was good, but I'm a fan of white garlic sauce, I wish they had it. The garlic sauce they do have just wasn't quite enough, so maybe we'll try something different next time. Their website has an email address, I thought I could email my order, but don't do that. Good thing I called. We will definitely be ordering from here again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lakesha McBride
If you want dessert or have a sweet tooth I HIGHLY recommend the Tasty Pizzert specifically the Apple!! It was so so sweet I could taste just about everything on it! Definitely hit the sweet tooth! and the price isn't bad either!!! 10/10 šš
Joseph Reed
By far the best pizza in Dekalb county Iāll order this day in and day out if I could. The cookie is amazing as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Polina Nothnagle
The food is always hot and fresh, and it's so delicious! Their delivery option is very helpful in a last-second dinner pinch, and they were so friendly and sweet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holy Trinity
Absolutely spectacular pizza and pizza desserts it's a must order if you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly Stackhouse
Have always ordered delivery from them call today to place a delivery and the lady tells me I canāt place an order because I never picked up my carry out order. One Iāve never done carry out we have only ever done delivery but to automatically assume and refuse service is wild! Do better! Even after I explained to the lady we have never done carry out and only ever do delivery she says Iām sorry my manager says I canāt take your order! Shitty Business and customer service. Support a better family restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Deb Keezer
Weāve been ordering from Tasty Pizza regularly for about a year now. Today I ordered our usual on line. I received a phone call from them to let me know that they were almost out of one of my toppings and asked if I wanted to add anything else or change it to another topping. Now that right there is excellent service in my opinion. This place and all of the people working there are amazing. THANK YOU EVERYONE!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crystal Edgar
I order here like 3 times first time excellent 2nd time they messed my order up called them they made it right. 3rd time they messed my order up again. I didnāt call I just let my kids eat it. Today I call to get their special and sheās like we can only do it if you have coupon!! Ok so I hung up on her and im done!! If you go to their website for their specials thatās were I found it! Donāt have coupon
Izzy Schoonover
My husband and I ordered delivery Friday night I got the turkey sub and it had an odd taste to it, and my husband had a sausage roll that didnāt taste right About half hour later, we had upset, stomachs and vomiting wonāt be ordering from here again
Food: 1
Service: 3
John James
The gentleman got my order wrong and so I ended up having to pay for extra cheese that I didn't want. I wanted extra sauce. It barely had any sauce on it and the dessert Pizza was, oh my God, that was like almost twice as much as the. Regular Pizza, right? I couldn't believe it, but anyways, I didn't get what I wanted, and they didn't seem to care or fix it. They just looked at me like it was my fault.
Since I've had Tasty Pizza, I have a hard time enjoying other pizza in this area.This little gem is small but mighty. They make their own dough and sauce. They use REAL cheese. Everything just feels and tastes authentic. Love the pizza, pizza rolls, AND the subs. Totally worth the drive to Waterloo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Lars Warhammer
Everything has very good flavor. Subs, calzone's and the pizza. Chicken Bacon ranch is probably favorite yet preference for ham onion green olive. cheese, dough and SAUCE...all great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GB 80923
Last night we ordered from Tasty Pizza for the first time, the lovely girl I spoke with on the phone āpromised Iād love itā; she wasnāt wrong! It was great! Both my husband and I enjoyed it greatly, and we were thrilled that they even delivered clear out to where we live. The pizza was hot, fresh and flavorful and arrived earlier than expected, we definitely will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lucy Meeks
First time order. Delivery was close to time quoted and pizza was great. Hand tossed crust was generous and lots of toppings. Will definitely order again, very impressed they delivered here at Story Lake
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Brown
When I am driving north from the Fort I will jump off I-69 & drive the mile or so to get a sub or small pizza. The menu is MASSIVE. almost everything on it is full of taste. The dough, sauce, cheese...excellent. I live in the Fort, and have had Lexys, Jets, Redwood, and the chain brands...but Tasty Pizza is the best. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce is divine. All 'Meatzza' is very meaty, but the Chicken Garlic Pizza maybe my fave. The building looks like an old dump but don't be fooled...I can't rave enough about the dough, cheese and sauce. Tasty Pizza truly delivers Taste!
Nice little local pizza joint. Really like their cheese sticks and chicken bacon ranch calzone. Pizza was good, but I'm a fan of white garlic sauce, I wish they had it. The garlic sauce they do have just wasn't quite enough, so maybe we'll try something different next time. Their website has an email address, I thought I could email my order, but don't do that. Good thing I called. We will definitely be ordering from here again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you want dessert or have a sweet tooth I HIGHLY recommend the Tasty Pizzert specifically the Apple!! It was so so sweet I could taste just about everything on it! Definitely hit the sweet tooth! and the price isn't bad either!!! 10/10 šš
By far the best pizza in Dekalb county Iāll order this day in and day out if I could. The cookie is amazing as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is always hot and fresh, and it's so delicious! Their delivery option is very helpful in a last-second dinner pinch, and they were so friendly and sweet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely spectacular pizza and pizza desserts it's a must order if you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have always ordered delivery from them call today to place a delivery and the lady tells me I canāt place an order because I never picked up my carry out order. One Iāve never done carry out we have only ever done delivery but to automatically assume and refuse service is wild! Do better! Even after I explained to the lady we have never done carry out and only ever do delivery she says Iām sorry my manager says I canāt take your order! Shitty Business and customer service. Support a better family restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Weāve been ordering from Tasty Pizza regularly for about a year now. Today I ordered our usual on line. I received a phone call from them to let me know that they were almost out of one of my toppings and asked if I wanted to add anything else or change it to another topping. Now that right there is excellent service in my opinion. This place and all of the people working there are amazing. THANK YOU EVERYONE!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I order here like 3 times first time excellent
2nd time they messed my order up called them they made it right.
3rd time they messed my order up again. I didnāt call I just let my kids eat it.
Today I call to get their special and sheās like we can only do it if you have coupon!! Ok so I hung up on her and im done!! If you go to their website for their specials thatās were I found it! Donāt have coupon
My husband and I ordered delivery Friday night I got the turkey sub and it had an odd taste to it, and my husband had a sausage roll that didnāt taste right About half hour later, we had upset, stomachs and vomiting wonāt be ordering from here again
Food: 1
Service: 3
The gentleman got my order wrong and so I ended up having to pay for extra cheese that I didn't want. I wanted extra sauce. It barely had any sauce on it and the dessert Pizza was, oh my God, that was like almost twice as much as the. Regular Pizza, right? I couldn't believe it, but anyways, I didn't get what I wanted, and they didn't seem to care or fix it. They just looked at me like it was my fault.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Since I've had Tasty Pizza, I have a hard time enjoying other pizza in this area.This little gem is small but mighty. They make their own dough and sauce. They use REAL cheese. Everything just feels and tastes authentic. Love the pizza, pizza rolls, AND the subs. Totally worth the drive to Waterloo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Everything has very good flavor. Subs, calzone's and the pizza. Chicken Bacon ranch is probably favorite yet preference for ham onion green olive. cheese, dough and SAUCE...all great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Last night we ordered from Tasty Pizza for the first time, the lovely girl I spoke with on the phone āpromised Iād love itā; she wasnāt wrong! It was great! Both my husband and I enjoyed it greatly, and we were thrilled that they even delivered clear out to where we live. The pizza was hot, fresh and flavorful and arrived earlier than expected, we definitely will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time order. Delivery was close to time quoted and pizza was great. Hand tossed crust was generous and lots of toppings. Will definitely order again, very impressed they delivered here at Story Lake
Food: 5
Service: 5
When I am driving north from the Fort I will jump off I-69 & drive the mile or so to get a sub or small pizza. The menu is MASSIVE. almost everything on it is full of taste. The dough, sauce, cheese...excellent. I live in the Fort, and have had Lexys, Jets, Redwood, and the chain brands...but Tasty Pizza is the best. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce is divine. All 'Meatzza' is very meaty, but the Chicken Garlic Pizza maybe my fave.
The building looks like an old dump but don't be fooled...I can't rave enough about the dough, cheese and sauce. Tasty Pizza truly delivers Taste!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...