Pizza tasted fine and was made as requested but it was not kept warm. I picked it up within 5 min of the scheduled time I was told and it was ready but the pizza was barely warm so they need to do better with heat lamps.
Michael T
What an awesome people. Due to a misunderstanding while phone ordering, upon picking up I discovered I will have a medium pizza instead of the XL one that I ordered. They were very courteous and offered me an additional XL one at very steep discount (ended up having the medium pizza for free)! The pizza dough itself is perfectly delicious, toppings are fresh and overall the food and the people are amazing. I will definitely come back for all my pizza “needs” in the future!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenna Reynolds
Pizza is always good. Fantastic patio when it is nice out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks
Michael T.
What an awesome people. Due to a misunderstanding while phone ordering, upon picking up I discovered I will have a medium pizza instead of the XL one that I ordered. They were very courteous and offered me an additional XL one at very steep discount (ended up having the medium pizza for free)! The pizza dough itself is perfectly delicious, toppings are fresh and overall the food and the people are amazing. I will definitely come back for all my pizza "needs" in the future!!
doug miley
All good but NO parking anywhere! $10 valet parking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Trey C.
Pretty laid back place but can get busier nights and weekends. Love both dining in and take out - always fairly speedy pie-making. Beats the heck out of the chain spots around the area. Go there at least twice a month for our family's pizza fix.
Aaron
Pizza and breadsticks are amazing! Garden special or gourmet meat are the best pizzas there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Biggs
Looked forward to a nice pizza & beer night with friends after Christmas and there was no one to serve us our alcohol!!?? Why on earth does someone schedule like that? No, I don’t need alcohol but one of our favorite things to do with friends is pizza & beer nights.Westfield parking is HORRIBLE and we left even though we always love their pizza. Not inclined to deal with both issues again.Parking: AWFUL!! What city plans all of this with no parking??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Guess What
Never had a problem at this restaurant. The one in Carmel on the other hand is a joke. This restaurant is nothing but five stars. But just as a reminder, their wait times and delivery times are beyond the delivery or take out kind of restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Larry T.
First time ordering from Greeks Pizzeria. Unfortunately it wasn't a good experience. I ordered a pizza for home delivery. The pizza toppings were very sparse. In addition, the delivery driver forgot our salad and stated he would be right back with our salad. WRONG! We waited nearly an hour and no salad. Called in and got my money back and was told my salad was still on the way. WRONG! They called me 20 minutes later stating if I really wanted my salad it would be at least another half-hour or longer. Told her to forget it at this point. Very disappointing to say the least.
Ordered a small pizza and two orders of wings to go. The pizza was basically a big dough ball 1/2 crust/dough and 1/2 cheese and toppings. The toppings were very sparse and overall the pizza was of very low quality.I also ordered wings, which were the size of my pinky finger - literally. They weren't all like that but probably 50%. They were tasty though. The bill for all of this was $34, which was about the poorest value I have ever experienced. Never again!
Food: 1
Service: 5
Alex Mac (MacFly)
Overall, just a great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: GP BBQ Chicken Pizza, Cheese Sticks, Cheese Bread, Small Cheese Pizza, Breadsticks
David B.
Great outdoor space in suburban Indy for pizza. We were staying in a near by air bnb and discovered this place. Close to a great walking trails to keep the kids busy. Recommend the pepperoni pizza. Even the dog loved the crust.
Todd Short
Zero stars. I placed a big order for $135.00 for carry out at 2:15 for 6:15 pick up. I got there and they said it would be another 15 mins. I asked to speak with a manager. Austin came out with a terrible attitude towards me. He obviously doesn’t know customer service the way he talked to me. Again, I placed this order at 2:15 and other carry out orders were going out before mine that were placed at 5 something. I asked the young girl what time that order was placed. I will not be coming back, all because of Austin.
Scott Edwards
Tried to eat here. They had a baseball team filling the dining room which is fine of course but they had their pizzas taking up two tables where no one was sitting. Normally don't pizzas go on the tables where you are sitting? So you wasted two tables and lost our business. Duh!
Pizza tasted fine and was made as requested but it was not kept warm. I picked it up within 5 min of the scheduled time I was told and it was ready but the pizza was barely warm so they need to do better with heat lamps.
What an awesome people. Due to a misunderstanding while phone ordering, upon picking up I discovered I will have a medium pizza instead of the XL one that I ordered. They were very courteous and offered me an additional XL one at very steep discount (ended up having the medium pizza for free)! The pizza dough itself is perfectly delicious, toppings are fresh and overall the food and the people are amazing. I will definitely come back for all my pizza “needs” in the future!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is always good. Fantastic patio when it is nice out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks
What an awesome people. Due to a misunderstanding while phone ordering, upon picking up I discovered I will have a medium pizza instead of the XL one that I ordered. They were very courteous and offered me an additional XL one at very steep discount (ended up having the medium pizza for free)! The pizza dough itself is perfectly delicious, toppings are fresh and overall the food and the people are amazing. I will definitely come back for all my pizza "needs" in the future!!
All good but NO parking anywhere! $10 valet parking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pretty laid back place but can get busier nights and weekends. Love both dining in and take out - always fairly speedy pie-making. Beats the heck out of the chain spots around the area. Go there at least twice a month for our family's pizza fix.
Pizza and breadsticks are amazing! Garden special or gourmet meat are the best pizzas there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Looked forward to a nice pizza & beer night with friends after Christmas and there was no one to serve us our alcohol!!?? Why on earth does someone schedule like that? No, I don’t need alcohol but one of our favorite things to do with friends is pizza & beer nights.Westfield parking is HORRIBLE and we left even though we always love their pizza. Not inclined to deal with both issues again.Parking: AWFUL!! What city plans all of this with no parking??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Never had a problem at this restaurant. The one in Carmel on the other hand is a joke. This restaurant is nothing but five stars. But just as a reminder, their wait times and delivery times are beyond the delivery or take out kind of restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
First time ordering from Greeks Pizzeria. Unfortunately it wasn't a good experience. I ordered a pizza for home delivery. The pizza toppings were very sparse. In addition, the delivery driver forgot our salad and stated he would be right back with our salad. WRONG! We waited nearly an hour and no salad. Called in and got my money back and was told my salad was still on the way. WRONG! They called me 20 minutes later stating if I really wanted my salad it would be at least another half-hour or longer. Told her to forget it at this point. Very disappointing to say the least.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered a small pizza and two orders of wings to go. The pizza was basically a big dough ball 1/2 crust/dough and 1/2 cheese and toppings. The toppings were very sparse and overall the pizza was of very low quality.I also ordered wings, which were the size of my pinky finger - literally. They weren't all like that but probably 50%. They were tasty though. The bill for all of this was $34, which was about the poorest value I have ever experienced. Never again!
Food: 1
Service: 5
Overall, just a great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: GP BBQ Chicken Pizza, Cheese Sticks, Cheese Bread, Small Cheese Pizza, Breadsticks
Great outdoor space in suburban Indy for pizza. We were staying in a near by air bnb and discovered this place. Close to a great walking trails to keep the kids busy. Recommend the pepperoni pizza. Even the dog loved the crust.
Zero stars. I placed a big order for $135.00 for carry out at 2:15 for 6:15 pick up. I got there and they said it would be another 15 mins. I asked to speak with a manager. Austin came out with a terrible attitude towards me. He obviously doesn’t know customer service the way he talked to me. Again, I placed this order at 2:15 and other carry out orders were going out before mine that were placed at 5 something. I asked the young girl what time that order was placed. I will not be coming back, all because of Austin.
Tried to eat here. They had a baseball team filling the dining room which is fine of course but they had their pizzas taking up two tables where no one was sitting. Normally don't pizzas go on the tables where you are sitting? So you wasted two tables and lost our business. Duh!