Always the best experience and best food for the money. Nothing beats this place. We came for the first time last Valentine's Day and have come for EVERY special occasion ever since. I really think it's THE hidden gem in Indy!
Dennis
Great food, awesome staff thru and thru. Fun spot to enjoy a quality meal on a special night
Lela
Definitely one of our favorite go to restaurants - Very reasonably priced but also absolutely DELICIOUS - Plus fabulous cocktails!! Love the downstairs half booths/half tables - Perfect for a lovely winter evening 🍸✨!!
Robyn
Obsessed, truly. I can't recommend it enough. From the friendly Manager to all the servers, from drinks to dessert, it's a wonderful expereicne.
Olivia Kent
We came in at an odd time at night sure to not get a table, but it turned out being a perfect evening! We had heard about how good the food was - and it definitely lived up to the hype. Service was great and food was even better. Must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Faulds
This was our first trip to Nyla's. We were having a nice send off dinner for our youngest and his wife as they were traveling across the country the next day. We are very glad we chose to do this at Nyla's. The surroundings were quaint and pleasant. The staff was awesome! The food was terrific and, while we live in downtown Indy, we now have a real excuse to drive to Westfield. The food was terrific and we plan to get our friends there soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Bittermann
Their food is amazing - changes with seasons the service is spot on the owners are very nice - always going back ☺️
Kim
The early bird specials were great! We all had something different at our table. Service as well as the cocktails was amazing.
Lisa
Hogan was a great server. Attentive and informative without hovering. We had a variety of dishes and everyone loved what they had for dinner. We started with the delicious deviled eggs - also a hit with everyone. Drinks were delicious and good value. The Rosie Cheeks cocktail was outstanding!
Noel
Nyla's Early Bird Menu is outstanding!!!! Great tasting offerings, excellent service ( our server Emily provided exceptional service!) and great value! The Our experience was so positive that we plan to return with friends and family! A true dining gem in Westfield, Indiana.
Wow! What an experience tonight. This place is a hidden gem to outsiders. Love the interior and style of the establishment that matches the food. Our server Taylor was excellent! Got the goat cheese for an app, outstanding. I don't even like goat cheese! Salad was perfect also. Now for the filet, served on an iron skillet was one of the best I have had. Taylor said to order below the cook you prefer cause it will cook while you eat and she was right. Never had a steak like it before. Every bite was hot! Scalper potatoes one of a kind. I travel here for work often and will make it a must next time I'm in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom
The food and service was very good. Highly recommend the Apple Crisp dessert, big enough to share.
Jen
Service was fantastic, Emily was outstanding and food was SO good! We will be back very soon. Filet was better than many upscale steak houses and sea bass which was also amazing. Highly recommend!
Ruben
I mentioned it was my wedding anniversary when I made the reservation but there was no mention at all. Even the server (same one as us) asked the table behind us if they were celebrating something, which we were not asked. Food was just ok. For it being a “scratch” kitchen, the quality of the ingredients perhaps are of lesser grade. It didn't taste bad at all, but also wasn't necessarily better or more flavorful than other more mainstream “chain” restaurants. I'd consider going back based on the food being ok but it's definitely take it or leave it.
Bob
Friendly and snappy service starting with the front door. In general, restaurant has a very comfortable feeling and is reflected in the decor and their food. Wait staff was friendly and provided their favorite recommendations - always appreciated. Seating was comfortable and well spaced so you have a level of intimacy at your table that lends itself to date night. The multiple bar areas carry the same comfortable, intimate feel. Food is priced right (wife and I enjoyed 2 entrees + bottle of wine for $111 - incredibly reasonable in this day and age.) Selections are spot on - tasty, proper temperature, and great presentation. Highly recommended and very much appreciated.
Always the best experience and best food for the money. Nothing beats this place. We came for the first time last Valentine's Day and have come for EVERY special occasion ever since. I really think it's THE hidden gem in Indy!
Great food, awesome staff thru and thru. Fun spot to enjoy a quality meal on a special night
Definitely one of our favorite go to restaurants - Very reasonably priced but also absolutely DELICIOUS - Plus fabulous cocktails!! Love the downstairs half booths/half tables - Perfect for a lovely winter evening 🍸✨!!
Obsessed, truly. I can't recommend it enough. From the friendly Manager to all the servers, from drinks to dessert, it's a wonderful expereicne.
We came in at an odd time at night sure to not get a table, but it turned out being a perfect evening! We had heard about how good the food was - and it definitely lived up to the hype. Service was great and food was even better. Must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first trip to Nyla's. We were having a nice send off dinner for our youngest and his wife as they were traveling across the country the next day. We are very glad we chose to do this at Nyla's. The surroundings were quaint and pleasant. The staff was awesome! The food was terrific and, while we live in downtown Indy, we now have a real excuse to drive to Westfield. The food was terrific and we plan to get our friends there soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their food is amazing - changes with seasons the service is spot on the owners are very nice - always going back ☺️
The early bird specials were great! We all had something different at our table. Service as well as the cocktails was amazing.
Hogan was a great server. Attentive and informative without hovering. We had a variety of dishes and everyone loved what they had for dinner. We started with the delicious deviled eggs - also a hit with everyone. Drinks were delicious and good value. The Rosie Cheeks cocktail was outstanding!
Nyla's Early Bird Menu is outstanding!!!! Great tasting offerings, excellent service ( our server Emily provided exceptional service!) and great value! The Our experience was so positive that we plan to return with friends and family! A true dining gem in Westfield, Indiana.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow! What an experience tonight. This place is a hidden gem to outsiders. Love the interior and style of the establishment that matches the food. Our server Taylor was excellent! Got the goat cheese for an app, outstanding. I don't even like goat cheese! Salad was perfect also. Now for the filet, served on an iron skillet was one of the best I have had. Taylor said to order below the cook you prefer cause it will cook while you eat and she was right. Never had a steak like it before. Every bite was hot! Scalper potatoes one of a kind. I travel here for work often and will make it a must next time I'm in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service was very good. Highly recommend the Apple Crisp dessert, big enough to share.
Service was fantastic, Emily was outstanding and food was SO good! We will be back very soon. Filet was better than many upscale steak houses and sea bass which was also amazing. Highly recommend!
I mentioned it was my wedding anniversary when I made the reservation but there was no mention at all. Even the server (same one as us) asked the table behind us if they were celebrating something, which we were not asked. Food was just ok. For it being a “scratch” kitchen, the quality of the ingredients perhaps are of lesser grade. It didn't taste bad at all, but also wasn't necessarily better or more flavorful than other more mainstream “chain” restaurants. I'd consider going back based on the food being ok but it's definitely take it or leave it.
Friendly and snappy service starting with the front door. In general, restaurant has a very comfortable feeling and is reflected in the decor and their food. Wait staff was friendly and provided their favorite recommendations - always appreciated. Seating was comfortable and well spaced so you have a level of intimacy at your table that lends itself to date night. The multiple bar areas carry the same comfortable, intimate feel. Food is priced right (wife and I enjoyed 2 entrees + bottle of wine for $111 - incredibly reasonable in this day and age.) Selections are spot on - tasty, proper temperature, and great presentation. Highly recommended and very much appreciated.
Loading...