Marcella's Pizzeria Inc.
$ • Pizza, Pasta
Hours:
3854 IN-10, Wheatfield
(219) 956-0525
About Marcella's Pizzeria Inc.
Customers' Favorites
Marcella's Pizzeria Inc. Reviews
Share your opinion about Marcella's Pizzeria Inc.
Came for the first time on Sat. Drove 45 min to try this place out and we were not disappointed. It was VERY busy but all the workers worked quick and efficiently. We ordered a deep dish with low expectations (as the further from Chicago we get the pizza usually isn’t as good in our opinion) but we were very pleasantly surprised with everything about our pizza. The dough was delicious and cooked perfectly, fresh mushrooms, huge chunks of sausage and a perfectly balanced sweet...read full review
Came for the first time on Sat. Drove 45 min to try this place out and we were not disappointed. It was VERY busy but all the workers worked quick and efficiently. We ordered a deep dish with low expectations (as the further from Chicago we get the pizza usually isn’t as good in our opinion) but we were very pleasantly surprised with everything about our pizza. The dough was delicious and cooked perfectly, fresh mushrooms, huge chunks of sausage and a perfectly balanced sweet...read full review
we took a risk when we got the menu in the mail and it was so yummy, you have new customers for sure! the fried mushrooms and thin crust were so yummy!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 3 - 8PM |
| Friday | 3 - 8:30PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 8:30PM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 8PM |
Marcella's Pizzeria Inc. is a popular spot known for its flavorful pizza and tasty wings, especially the bone-in wings that many consider amazing. The menu includes unique options like the less sweet sauce pizza, which has been enjoyed by customers. The garlic knots are highly praised and considered a highlight of the dining experience. Customers appreciate the good service and friendly environment, with some mentioning the nostalgic feel of the hometown atmosphere. The decor features cool memorabilia related to aviation and TWA/Pan Am. Besides pizza, the restaurant offers other dishes such as antipasto, Alfredo, Italian beef, and curly fries with cheese, all receiving positive reviews. While prices are considered a bit high and the space could be larger, guests often mention that the food and service are consistently great. Overall, Marcella's Pizzeria Inc. is a favorite for game day orders, casual dining, and those seeking flavorful Italian-American food.