Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

1010 Stone Creek Dr, Garden City
(620) 805-5086

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Craft Your Own Mac 'N Cheese

Side Salad and a Craft Beer

Tuscan Chicken with Spinach

Old Chicago Chopped Salad

Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls

Farmer's Daughter Pizza

BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger

Spinach Artichoke Dip

Buffalo Chicken Rolls

Chicken Fried Chicken

Photos

+68 photos

+67 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Oldchicago

Doordash

Recent Reviews

The food at this location is what you'd expect of the chain. I ordered the Chicago 7 calzone, which I greatly enjoyed. There are some specialty pizzas I really like. One of the others from my party ordered a burger and received no condiments and we had to wait quite a long time for them. Our drinks needed refills later in the dining experience and we had to ask for those too. The restaurant was maybe moderately busy at this time.

April 2026

Wentbin on tues I believe ordered the Mediterranean pizza to go and had a couple drinks while I waited. The staff was super friendly and cool to talk with the tvs was on sports (good for me😉) but let's talk about the beer selection! Omg the choices! Super impressive also the bartender she new damn near all and their flavor profile and was right lol. Had a good time definitely stop by if ya can.

January 2026

We've been to this Old Chicago many times. On this visit our table was sticky and even after they came to clean it again, it was still gummy.
Tonight we made the mistake of ordering food other than pizza. I had the andouille shrimp pasta & my friend had chicken Alfredo. The andouille was very low quality – think Oscar Mayer, and the noodles were dry. The other dish had tiny nibs of flavorless chicken. I HIGHLY recommend avoiding anything on the menu except...

January 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Garden City, KS

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom