Pie Five Pizza

12154 W 95th St, Lenexa
(913) 495-9509

Recent Reviews

Blake Martin

Ordered two large pizzas to go. One, the High Five-Meat, and the other the "Jack Stack's The Big Pig".The High Five-Meat was fine but cold (like they made it waaaay before the pick up time) and the other ("Jack Stack's The Big Pig") was just as cold and old but worse. None came with the the Panzano Crust ($1 extra per pizza) as ordered. The crust was flavorless and close to frozen pizza (frozen Digiorno crust would have been better). The ingredients on the High Five-Meat was as described (even with the flavorless crust), but "The Big Pig" was only BBQ sauce, cheese, and what was probably ham burnt ends? But the smallest amount of ham burnt ends ever (see picture of left overs, all pieces were similar, but maybe a few more bits of "ham burnt ends" on some other slices, High Five-Meat also pictured as the "good" one). Supposed to be pulled pork, ham burnt ends, bacon, and pickled red onions on "The Big Pig". Only one of the meat ingredients made an appearance on "The Big Pig".For the price, would 100% recommend going to Minsky's for pizza, especially for 2 larges. The two large deal for Minsky's makes it comparable to this. But at least Minsky's keeps it in a heater until you pick it up and comes with the ingredients. Pie Five was closer and we tried it for that, but the extra distance to Minsky's would have been so much more worth it for the quality. Everyone that had pizza judged me for not getting better pizza. This was just that bad.100% not worth, but still got food so 2 stars. I thought warmth wouldn't matter too much, but the cold and missing ingredients made it so disappointing and annoying for everyone.

Melanie McStanton

First, the pizza is amazing and delicious.I'm giving only 2 stars because our pizza is NEVER the way we order it. We are vegetarians and half the time it comes with meat we didn't ask for and toppings we wanted are left off and ones we didn't want are added.It's ridiculous and I'm not sure if doordash and grubhub orders are hard to read or if the employees are understaffed and working fast so they are more accident prone.

Chase Jacobs

There was nothing crunchy about the stuffed crunch unless it was made wrong. Great pizza regardless.

David Y.

Fresh, fast, high-quality, inexpensive, friendly. First-class operation all the way around. This is a top-notch, new-generation pizza biz, similar to Blaze Pizza and Pizza Studio. Custom build your pie, with easy online ordering. To specify more(+) or less(-) for each ingredient, you can put that in the special instructions, as there are no +/- buttons next to each ordered ingredient. Toppings are not unlimited, like the other places I mentioned, but 5 toppings for $8.49 (11-inch pie) is still a very good deal. I was barely able to finish my pie, and had not eaten for nearly 24 hours. Indoor and outdoor seating.

Andrew G

Pizza was good.Make sure to order through their website and not Google--I learned after the fact that Google marks it up 40%.Pickup was also 10 minutes behind.

Erick Briones

The High Five is super delish. Staff is friendly and service is beyond average. Maddie is extra kool.

Karla Medina-Barraza

Ordered online for delivery. We bought the family meal with cheesy bread stix. Pizza is flavorful. We had to eat it asap because we did notice it gets a bit soggy if left out for a few mins. Cheese bread sticks are amazing!!!

katy lambeth

First timers here! The food was great, but the atmosphere and customer service was impeccable! Big thank you to Keenan, Margot, and Eric!

kylee davis

I work at Ding Tea and I literally love this Pi Five. No other words. Like if I could marry the food and staff here? oh 100%

Amy Texley

Pretty good pizza, especiallyfor fast food. It is quick, made to your specifications and there are many options. They were able to customize my pizza for vegan, buy they can also accommodate gluten free.

Chrissi

The food is always good. Service at this location was also good. Love the dairy free cheese option for my daughter.

Kiki M

Today, 9/7/21, the quality of the pizza and the fantastic customer service made me come and change my old one star review to a 5 star. The stuffed crust pizza is everything I needed it to be. The whole staff was friendly and helpful. They brought our pizza to our table and came back around to grab our trash. This has never happened when I've ate here. I hadn't been in a long time but now maybe I will be a frequent customer.

Zay Nukem

Ok did not like the fact I had to tell the employee to switch gloves when making my pizza I don't eat meat and he handled pork with the previous customer, also forgot multiple topping then added them after pizza was done cooking.

Jason Brown

Friendly staff and quick service. Will be back

Michael Prier

Great food, fast service, friendly staff. Will recommend to friends.

Load More