AJ's NY Pizzeria

301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan
(785) 587-0700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sean Stroub

They did a great job delivering 25 pizzas to a venue for a wedding party. Great food, timely service.

Ricardo Padilla

They had a dinosaur and choo choo train so good restaurant 👍

Ryan Hammontree

Pizza was really good but the toasted ravs were amazing!

J LH

As close to NY pizza as you are going to get, pretty good and lots of options.

Travis Trachta

Fantastic pizza, available by the slice or the entire pizza, with a great outdoor seating area. The staff was very friendly and took care of our needs.

Debbie Beaman

Great pizza and atmosphere

Hannah Gerberding

Excellent customer service and food was great!

Jan Van Dyke

come here atleast once a month 👌🏻 never had one complaint...

Jeff Beaver

Great local pizza place

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jim Aguirre

Love all the food in this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Bricks, Buffalo Wings, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Brad

Super great food and really spectacular service. Our waiter, Austin was on it, he was quick and made helpful quick suggestions.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bradly Kunberger

The baked Zita was amazing. 11.99 for this huge portion, which practically fed us all. The cheese in it was super yummy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandon Fisher (Brandon Fisher)

I’m on the fence about the pizza but it was ok.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kaila Williams

Great pizza by the slice, amazing salads, even better garlic knots, craft beer options, back patio with an incredible mural. There’s a lot to like about AJ’s. If you’re craving pizza and beer, this is the place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Big Apple, Jalapeno Popper Pizza, Popper, Cesar Salad, AJ's Grilled Cheese Pie

Gennie Gaudet English

So let me start by saying it's a college town. It's at the edge of that part of town verses smack dab in the small tight streets. The staff were very friendly . Now it was slow when I came in so not sure how they are when it's a game night or weekend which I'm sure they are slammed. Now Hunter took my order and was so helpful and informative and didn't let my eyes be bigger than my stomach lol. Jackson was friendly and listen to me chatter and explain about the RFTW (comes to junction City every May) . Friendly open environment and family friendly. My food smelled great and looked great. I'd give 4.5 if they existed cause my only complaint was the sauce was a tiny bit too sweet for NY style and tiny bit off spice level wise. Other than that wasn't burnt bottom and folded (the NY style test!) the inside was nice but the outside patio was great on a beautiful weather night. Music and lights all around. A mural on the wall to see and people watching ability. There's parking on the back and front sides. I can't compare to other 'local' pizza places in the area but I'd recommend AJs to anyone no matter who you are! I took a video of the outside and the patios and street since not much on Google but seems to need to be cut in half it's too long. Will add later

Parking: Front street slot spots and back open lot. Varies times of day. During the day there is a 2 hr limit until 5pm.

Kid-friendliness: Open area and inside and outside seating options. Music was chill no bad language. Lots to take in to see. If you have kiddos on the spectrum be aware there is lots of stimulation at 1st but it's chill once settled. There's plenty places to visit while waiting for food or go up street to walk off some energy.

Wheelchair accessibility: The front door and gates both entrance from parking lots and the street so no steps. There is an incline for access if you park on street.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Manhattan Margherita Pizza

Loading...