I've tried every single one of Eileen's cookies multiple times. I usually take two bites and throw the rest away. People drop them off at my job as a gift for the employees. I love cookies but these are terrible. They're dry and flavorless no matter what flavor you pick.
Obviously it's a matter of subjective taste because they are still in business and I see people giving them good reviews. I just had to add my two cents. If you're the type of person that likes insomnia cookies there's a good chance you won't like Eileen's. I get them for free and I still won't eat them. I don't understand how people pay for these.
Almost forgot to add: my kid spit it out. I brought home a few for him and they ended up in the trash.
Rob-Karen White
Salesman brought in cookies for a meeting & they were amazing.
Jessica Bechard
Great cookies
Crandria 2001
$2 for just an ok cookie. Not worth it at all. There's literally a Target (with a Starbucks) next door, just go there.
Sophia Jones
Eileen’s is the best! I would consider myself somewhat of a frosting connoisseur and their frosted sugar cookies always hit the spot lol. I’ve placed multiple special orders with them for wedding cookies, birthday cookie cakes and cookie decorating kits etc and they have always been ready on time with a good price point and exactly what I was hoping for. They are also always super friendly whenever we come in! Definitely recommend trying it out ☺️
Markee Freeman
I love this place!!! The cookies are so delicious & the staff are wonderful!!!! Definitely recommend!!
Laura Hough
Eileen’s Cookies are literally the best…and that’s coming from someone super picky about baked goods! I love the almond flavoring of their icing, their decorating is simply amazing, and they can pull off any custom design you can dream up! (Pro tip- buy them by the dozen and freeze them for cookies any time! :) ) They are reasonably priced and worth every penny! ♥️
Haley Marschall
We absolutely love these cookies. Always soft and fresh, as well as affordable. My kids are obsessed with the lemon, we buy the sleeve of twelve (unfrosted), and they are a perfect treat. Also, I love to pick up a bag of the “day old” ones for a discount, they still taste perfectly fresh! Chocolate chocolate walnut is a great flavor to pair with your afternoon coffee ;)
Malora Lake
Was very quick and prompt with my order, and incredibly kind. Will be ordering from here again in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cookies
Shawna Herja
When I'm in town they are always the place I get cookies from. The cookies are always yummy and soft. 10/10 recommend!
A few things other than the cookies being absolutely amazing. Messaged them about ordering custom cookies, they responded within the hour! great communication and they do a great job decorating. Highly recommend!
Daneen Landis-Coover
I recently placed an order with Eileen's Cookies in Manhattan, Kansas, and I couldn't be more impressed with their service and product. Despite giving them only 24 hours' notice, they took my order without hesitation. They perfectly matched the color scheme and font of our company, which was a wonderful touch.
The cookies themselves were absolutely delicious and made a fantastic gift for our client. The staff, whether in-store, on the phone, or through email, were consistently professional and kind. Their outstanding service and high-quality product truly stood out. I highly recommend Eileen's Cookies for any occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 3 Mixed Dozen
Marc Funk
I recently visited Eileen's Cookies. The cookies are absolutely delicious, with so many choices for fresh-made treats. The staff is great—friendly and courteous, making the visit even more enjoyable. Plus, the location is convenient. Highly recommend checking it out!
Phil Schaefer
I bought both an oatmeal chocolate chip and a regular chocolate chip cookie, and they were both bland and tasteless. Do yourself a favor and walk across the street and buy a cookie at Panera Bread.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Janelle Boden
I had boxes made to take to Children's Mercy Hospital, just a small token of appreciation for everything they have done for my grandbabies. The nurses absolutely LOVED them! Jered and Audrey were amazing to work with in making this happen. I will definitely be a repeat customer!!!
I've tried every single one of Eileen's cookies multiple times. I usually take two bites and throw the rest away. People drop them off at my job as a gift for the employees. I love cookies but these are terrible. They're dry and flavorless no matter what flavor you pick.
Obviously it's a matter of subjective taste because they are still in business and I see people giving them good reviews. I just had to add my two cents. If you're the type of person that likes insomnia cookies there's a good chance you won't like Eileen's. I get them for free and I still won't eat them. I don't understand how people pay for these.
Almost forgot to add: my kid spit it out. I brought home a few for him and they ended up in the trash.
Salesman brought in cookies for a meeting & they were amazing.
Great cookies
$2 for just an ok cookie. Not worth it at all. There's literally a Target (with a Starbucks) next door, just go there.
Eileen’s is the best! I would consider myself somewhat of a frosting connoisseur and their frosted sugar cookies always hit the spot lol. I’ve placed multiple special orders with them for wedding cookies, birthday cookie cakes and cookie decorating kits etc and they have always been ready on time with a good price point and exactly what I was hoping for. They are also always super friendly whenever we come in! Definitely recommend trying it out ☺️
I love this place!!! The cookies are so delicious & the staff are wonderful!!!! Definitely recommend!!
Eileen’s Cookies are literally the best…and that’s coming from someone super picky about baked goods! I love the almond flavoring of their icing, their decorating is simply amazing, and they can pull off any custom design you can dream up! (Pro tip- buy them by the dozen and freeze them for cookies any time! :) ) They are reasonably priced and worth every penny! ♥️
We absolutely love these cookies. Always soft and fresh, as well as affordable. My kids are obsessed with the lemon, we buy the sleeve of twelve (unfrosted), and they are a perfect treat. Also, I love to pick up a bag of the “day old” ones for a discount, they still taste perfectly fresh! Chocolate chocolate walnut is a great flavor to pair with your afternoon coffee ;)
Was very quick and prompt with my order, and incredibly kind. Will be ordering from here again in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cookies
When I'm in town they are always the place I get cookies from. The cookies are always yummy and soft. 10/10 recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Cookie, Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, M&M, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Restaurantji Recommends
A few things other than the cookies being absolutely amazing. Messaged them about ordering custom cookies, they responded within the hour! great communication and they do a great job decorating. Highly recommend!
I recently placed an order with Eileen's Cookies in Manhattan, Kansas, and I couldn't be more impressed with their service and product. Despite giving them only 24 hours' notice, they took my order without hesitation. They perfectly matched the color scheme and font of our company, which was a wonderful touch.
The cookies themselves were absolutely delicious and made a fantastic gift for our client. The staff, whether in-store, on the phone, or through email, were consistently professional and kind. Their outstanding service and high-quality product truly stood out. I highly recommend Eileen's Cookies for any occasion!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 3 Mixed Dozen
I recently visited Eileen's Cookies. The cookies are absolutely delicious, with so many choices for fresh-made treats. The staff is great—friendly and courteous, making the visit even more enjoyable. Plus, the location is convenient. Highly recommend checking it out!
I bought both an oatmeal chocolate chip and a regular chocolate chip cookie, and they were both bland and tasteless. Do yourself a favor and walk across the street and buy a cookie at Panera Bread.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
I had boxes made to take to Children's Mercy Hospital, just a small token of appreciation for everything they have done for my grandbabies. The nurses absolutely LOVED them! Jered and Audrey were amazing to work with in making this happen. I will definitely be a repeat customer!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...