Now under new ownership, My Dad's Pizza is not the pizza we all know and love and grew up on. If they had planned on changing the entire menu they should have changed the name. We ordered an 18 inch pizza expecting it to taste like My Dad's and we were highly disappointed.
The crust was different, the sauce was different and the toppings were all different. Also, there's no way that pizza was 18 inches, more like 16.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Jordan Wyant
I’ve had My Dad’s pizza my whole life. Whatever I received tonight was not it. It was thin, salty and so greasy you could barely eat it. Bring back the old recipe please I’m begging. Cause whatever it is right now is not it.
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Richard Burks
They had a Halloween special for one topping 18” for 15 dollars wasn’t even a 16” pizza was cold because they forgot to make our sandwiches the usual pappys way definitely not the old my dads or even when Larry owned it pizza was awful. Why did you change something that didn’t need changing
Andrew Bayes
I've gown up on My Dad's. Through the good and bad phases. I recently ordered a pizza back to back weeks. Both times I was very unhappy with the pizza. I was hoping that the first week was just an accident but it wasn't. Something has changed about how they make their pizza and it is not for the positive. Both times the pizza was paper thin, hardly any toppings at all and even less sauce and cheese. My dad's has always has a huge amount of topping and cheese but now is almost non existent. When the new owners took over everything was still so good but the last two times have not been a good experience. I knew something was up when the pepperonis were on top of the cheese, which had never been the case. I'll give it another shot but whatever change they've made should be reverted asap. I want to love My Dad's again but not if it continues like this. I called and was offered a refund but wanted to still supper the business so I declined. I just hope things go back to how they were.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Matt Alberts
Pretty good pizza at reasonable prices.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nicole Williams
Ordered for delivery the order was repeated back to me and when received it was missing an item I called to tell them the manager on duty said repay for the missing item and they would re deliver it now and I wrong but the item was already paid for as well as repeated when ordered to have to repay another amount for there mess up Mr pancake may want to evaluate your management and staff.
randy cordle
Love the libwich
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Libwich
Keli S
Tried for the first time today. The service was fast and food was hot. I ordered for takeout. The previous reviews are right it is a lot of cheese but I enjoyed the pizza. The cheese sticks are good as well and the dipping sauce reminds me of gattiland but that's not a bad thing for me. Prices were reasonable and you get a good amount.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Pizza
Cynthia McKenzie
Absolutely great pizza. This is like giovannis and original my dad's pizza used to be made. I eat here every chance I get. I live in carter county so not everyday. You'll love this pizza. I was very impressed the first time I ordered. It's always been great every time I order. 12 out if 10 rating.
Wheelchair accessibility: It's level parking so easy access. I think only take out no dining inside. Hopefully soon ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
jeffrey johnson
Holy cheese batman, way too much cheese. Pizza wasn't even enjoyable bc of the lack of anything other than cheese.
A work in progress. That is how I'd describe it. The pizza is good. I wasn't a fan of the Stromboli. It seemed a bit dry. Order was called in over the phone and our name was given about 3 times and even spelled. Then when we arrived it was still wrong. I know it's small items but accuracy is big deal. Over all I'm sure we will ne back and my next review can rise up.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Garlic Bread
J Paul-E
New owners and the best pizza in the area... love it and like the new indoor dining setup
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks, Pepsi Products, Two Items Pizza, Four Items Pizza, Three Items Pizza, Libwich, Pizza
Shanna Carver
Under new ownership and staff was very friendly and food was amazing.Had quit going a few years ago, but definitely worth going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Perry
Very good food. Very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Jeff Mowery
Pickup order was right and food was very good. Would recommend Pizza and bread sticks for sure ?
Now under new ownership, My Dad's Pizza is not the pizza we all know and love and grew up on. If they had planned on changing the entire menu they should have changed the name. We ordered an 18 inch pizza expecting it to taste like My Dad's and we were highly disappointed.
The crust was different, the sauce was different and the toppings were all different. Also, there's no way that pizza was 18 inches, more like 16.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
I’ve had My Dad’s pizza my whole life. Whatever I received tonight was not it. It was thin, salty and so greasy you could barely eat it. Bring back the old recipe please I’m begging. Cause whatever it is right now is not it.
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza
They had a Halloween special for one topping 18” for 15 dollars wasn’t even a 16” pizza was cold because they forgot to make our sandwiches the usual pappys way definitely not the old my dads or even when Larry owned it pizza was awful. Why did you change something that didn’t need changing
I've gown up on My Dad's. Through the good and bad phases. I recently ordered a pizza back to back weeks. Both times I was very unhappy with the pizza. I was hoping that the first week was just an accident but it wasn't. Something has changed about how they make their pizza and it is not for the positive. Both times the pizza was paper thin, hardly any toppings at all and even less sauce and cheese. My dad's has always has a huge amount of topping and cheese but now is almost non existent. When the new owners took over everything was still so good but the last two times have not been a good experience. I knew something was up when the pepperonis were on top of the cheese, which had never been the case. I'll give it another shot but whatever change they've made should be reverted asap. I want to love My Dad's again but not if it continues like this. I called and was offered a refund but wanted to still supper the business so I declined. I just hope things go back to how they were.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Pretty good pizza at reasonable prices.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ordered for delivery the order was repeated back to me and when received it was missing an item I called to tell them the manager on duty said repay for the missing item and they would re deliver it now and I wrong but the item was already paid for as well as repeated when ordered to have to repay another amount for there mess up
Mr pancake may want to evaluate your management and staff.
Love the libwich
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Libwich
Tried for the first time today. The service was fast and food was hot. I ordered for takeout. The previous reviews are right it is a lot of cheese but I enjoyed the pizza. The cheese sticks are good as well and the dipping sauce reminds me of gattiland but that's not a bad thing for me. Prices were reasonable and you get a good amount.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Pizza
Absolutely great pizza. This is like giovannis and original my dad's pizza used to be made. I eat here every chance I get. I live in carter county so not everyday. You'll love this pizza. I was very impressed the first time I ordered. It's always been great every time I order. 12 out if 10 rating.
Wheelchair accessibility: It's level parking so easy access. I think only take out no dining inside. Hopefully soon ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Holy cheese batman, way too much cheese. Pizza wasn't even enjoyable bc of the lack of anything other than cheese.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
A work in progress. That is how I'd describe it. The pizza is good. I wasn't a fan of the Stromboli. It seemed a bit dry. Order was called in over the phone and our name was given about 3 times and even spelled. Then when we arrived it was still wrong. I know it's small items but accuracy is big deal. Over all I'm sure we will ne back and my next review can rise up.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Garlic Bread
New owners and the best pizza in the area... love it and like the new indoor dining setup
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks, Pepsi Products, Two Items Pizza, Four Items Pizza, Three Items Pizza, Libwich, Pizza
Under new ownership and staff was very friendly and food was amazing.Had quit going a few years ago, but definitely worth going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good food. Very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Pickup order was right and food was very good. Would recommend Pizza and bread sticks for sure ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...