Waited about ten minutes in the lobby before we were acknowledged, we ordered from here in the past and it was awful but wanted to give them another try after several years because people seem to think it’s good. Got a pizza with extra cheese because I remember how bad the last experience was. This time still very little cheese, very little sauce, the crust takes up most of the pizza and it’s flavorless, the center was paper thin. Very similar to digorno oven pizza crust but the oven pizza has more cheese and sauce. Maybe the pizzas are good if you get specialty pizzas with grippos or ranch chicken but a basic pepperoni with extra cheese it’s not good at all. I’m sure the owners are nice and seem to do a lot in the community but the pizza is a disappointment and won’t waste my money on a third try
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tika Morrison
Savannah and Brad and their entire staff or some of the nicest people I’ve ever met. They go above and beyond to make sure their customers are happy. In addition, they serve the community quite frequently. Not only is their food amazing. Their hospitality is second and none. I would definitely recommend. By the way, my five-year-old son‘s favorite pizza is there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stan Michaels
Carry out & delivery only! Pizza was very fresh. You can tell it's made with high quality ingredients. We got The Florence Pizza & The Cannoli Pizza for dessert! Highly reccomend!
Zack Hetzel
mediocre at best, overpriced, sent wrong food, jets is a similar price and better to be honest
Mark Willenbrink
I’ve wanted to try this place for awhile and see how it compares to other local places like Strong’s Brick Oven and Bourbon House so I ordered a large meat topper with bacon, sausage, and pepperoni. When I opened the box, my first impression was the large looked more like a medium, it looked dry, and there wasn’t much cheese or toppings. The flavor of the pizza was good but it was so thin and unsubstantial that I ended up eating four pieces when I normally eat two pieces most other places. It was disappointing and a poor value for the money compared to Strong’s or Bourbon House. At least you’re getting what you pay for when you go to those places. They could learn a lot by checking out their competition. I will not be back.
Andrea Mynhier
UPDATE - the store reached out to make things right - I understand things happen and we are all human. I commend the excellent customer service and look forward to patronizing again in the near future. Thank you.
Injection calzone was missing the ricotta (seriously, how?!) and another topping and was severely undercooked. Hopefully this was just a one off, because the prior orders were great
Tammie
Amazing food very fresh always.
Chris Shumate
This used to be one of the best pizza shops in our area, but the quality is slowly going downhill. Our pizza today was soggy and their advertised dessert pizza was disappointing and didn't really look as advertised. So sad to see a promising local place decline.
John Brate
I live in Ohio, over an hour away from Florence Ky. After stumbling across their Facebook page a few months ago, Ive been dying to try the pizza, that looks so good in those pictures. I finally made it there today, and the pizza exceeded all my expectations! Everything from the customer service to the construction of the pizza to the taste was excellent. I ordered a 5 topping, build your own deep dish and I could taste each topping in every bite. If you want to experience how good food can taste when it’s made with fresh ingredients, pride and caring, then do yourself a favor, and get here!!!! 69/10!!
Matthew Bruno
Never ate here and girlfriend suggested it. Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Will go again.
I wish I would have taken pictures but the smells on the drive home were too great to wait any longer for. I tried the Florence pizza on their tradition crust, a dep dish sausage pizza and an order of meatballs!
The Florence has an incredible combinations of flavors. First off the sauce is fantastic but when combined with the creamy ricotta, the savory pepperonis and the Delicious hot honey, there’s nothing more you could ask for! My deep dish pizza had sausage in every bite. I love when pizza places are generous with the toppings. The meatballs are one of a kind and hand made from scratch. One bite will tell you all you need to know ! We will be back.
NKY Local Ranking Pros \u0026 SEO
Their Tee Higgins grip pizza is to die for. It is that good, but you have to get their house made ranch with it.
Love all their pizza and products, highly recommended!
Brian Vercheak
Well, I'd been trying to get down to Poseidons for a while now but being unsuccessful because of my work schedule and the recent boughts with the weather and snow. OMG, absolutely 5 🌟 without a doubt! Savannah and her team knocked it outa the park for myself and my family tonight! 🎊🍕😋👍🎉 Thank you so much Savannah!!!!
Luke Yaegel
Great food and service! Delivery was super fast too.
jason kiser
Poseidon's always hits the spot. The quality is great, the folks working there are super friendly, and they support our civil servants and military. I LOVE the Burrow and Higgins pizzas. Their cheesy bread (name escapes me) is delish!
I got a hoagie today - saving it for later though so cannot review it - but what a great, local chain!
Waited about ten minutes in the lobby before we were acknowledged, we ordered from here in the past and it was awful but wanted to give them another try after several years because people seem to think it’s good. Got a pizza with extra cheese because I remember how bad the last experience was. This time still very little cheese, very little sauce, the crust takes up most of the pizza and it’s flavorless, the center was paper thin. Very similar to digorno oven pizza crust but the oven pizza has more cheese and sauce. Maybe the pizzas are good if you get specialty pizzas with grippos or ranch chicken but a basic pepperoni with extra cheese it’s not good at all. I’m sure the owners are nice and seem to do a lot in the community but the pizza is a disappointment and won’t waste my money on a third try
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Savannah and Brad and their entire staff or some of the nicest people I’ve ever met. They go above and beyond to make sure their customers are happy. In addition, they serve the community quite frequently. Not only is their food amazing. Their hospitality is second and none. I would definitely recommend. By the way, my five-year-old son‘s favorite pizza is there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carry out & delivery only! Pizza was very fresh. You can tell it's made with high quality ingredients. We got The Florence Pizza & The Cannoli Pizza for dessert! Highly reccomend!
mediocre at best, overpriced, sent wrong food, jets is a similar price and better to be honest
I’ve wanted to try this place for awhile and see how it compares to other local places like Strong’s Brick Oven and Bourbon House so I ordered a large meat topper with bacon, sausage, and pepperoni. When I opened the box, my first impression was the large looked more like a medium, it looked dry, and there wasn’t much cheese or toppings. The flavor of the pizza was good but it was so thin and unsubstantial that I ended up eating four pieces when I normally eat two pieces most other places. It was disappointing and a poor value for the money compared to Strong’s or Bourbon House. At least you’re getting what you pay for when you go to those places. They could learn a lot by checking out their competition. I will not be back.
UPDATE - the store reached out to make things right - I understand things happen and we are all human. I commend the excellent customer service and look forward to patronizing again in the near future. Thank you.
Injection calzone was missing the ricotta (seriously, how?!) and another topping and was severely undercooked. Hopefully this was just a one off, because the prior orders were great
Amazing food very fresh always.
This used to be one of the best pizza shops in our area, but the quality is slowly going downhill. Our pizza today was soggy and their advertised dessert pizza was disappointing and didn't really look as advertised. So sad to see a promising local place decline.
I live in Ohio, over an hour away from Florence Ky. After stumbling across their Facebook page a few months ago, Ive been dying to try the pizza, that looks so good in those pictures. I finally made it there today, and the pizza exceeded all my expectations! Everything from the customer service to the construction of the pizza to the taste was excellent. I ordered a 5 topping, build your own deep dish and I could taste each topping in every bite. If you want to experience how good food can taste when it’s made with fresh ingredients, pride and caring, then do yourself a favor, and get here!!!! 69/10!!
Never ate here and girlfriend suggested it. Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Will go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I wish I would have taken pictures but the smells on the drive home were too great to wait any longer for.
I tried the Florence pizza on their tradition crust, a dep dish sausage pizza and an order of meatballs!
The Florence has an incredible combinations of flavors. First off the sauce is fantastic but when combined with the creamy ricotta, the savory pepperonis and the Delicious hot honey, there’s nothing more you could ask for!
My deep dish pizza had sausage in every bite. I love when pizza places are generous with the toppings.
The meatballs are one of a kind and hand made from scratch. One bite will tell you all you need to know !
We will be back.
Their Tee Higgins grip pizza is to die for. It is that good, but you have to get their house made ranch with it.
Love all their pizza and products, highly recommended!
Well, I'd been trying to get down to Poseidons for a while now but being unsuccessful because of my work schedule and the recent boughts with the weather and snow. OMG, absolutely 5 🌟 without a doubt! Savannah and her team knocked it outa the park for myself and my family tonight! 🎊🍕😋👍🎉 Thank you so much Savannah!!!!
Great food and service! Delivery was super fast too.
Poseidon's always hits the spot. The quality is great, the folks working there are super friendly, and they support our civil servants and military. I LOVE the Burrow and Higgins pizzas. Their cheesy bread (name escapes me) is delish!
I got a hoagie today - saving it for later though so cannot review it - but what a great, local chain!
Loading...