Pizza was average at best. Ordered two subs and were very soggy for carry out and it’s 4 minutes away; pizza was still hot. Certainly not worth $30 for a NY style cut in squares. We never checked a box for squares and the description shows slices?? 2 pizzas 2 subs $81 is a joke. Watch the check out process because a 20% tip is added and you have to notice it. Not a review person but felt others need to know.
Dia Ramahi
Just to let all know ... They don't pay the employees that work for them. I feel like NO ONE SHOULD BUY FROM THEM.. Oh let's not forget they wanna call me and act innocent. Hahaha . after they stole MY MONEY . iRS. Any lawyer willing to help me with a law suit please let me know.
Monae McIntyre
We stopped by Poseidon’s Pizza on a Sunday afternoon while we were in the area and were surprised to find out they are delivery and carry-out only. The staff was very friendly and helped guide us through the menu, which we appreciated.
We ordered a Chicago deep dish veggie pizza and a thin pepperoni hot honey pizza. The veggie pizza had good flavors in the sauce and toppings, but the crust was a bit dried out. On the other hand, the thin pepperoni hot honey pizza was absolutely delicious!
Overall, it was a good experience, and we’d definitely come back for the pepperoni hot honey pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Bryan Jacobs
With 3 kids in sports you tend to do quick dinners or on the go options often. This is our first time trying this place and wow! Not only is the food fantastic, but the service was amazing! I will definitely be coming back to this place even though I live 30 minutes away. Highly recommend. If you are GF, grab cauliflower crust pizza. I've had a lot of them and this was the best cauliflower crust I've ever had. 10/10, 100/100 would definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Powell
Finally tried Poseidon's Pizza today and so glad we did! The Buffalo Soldier Pizza (Buffalo Chicken) and the Joe Burrow Pizza were delicious! I could barely wait to get home to get a slice! Also, that Capicola Hoagie I was greeted by a very helpful and nice employee with a very warm smile and while I waited, I got the chance to look around the waiting area (very classy by the way), to notice that Poseidon's Pizza does a lot to give back throughout the year with their Food Drives for school aged children. I would much rather support local businesses that support their community! Not only was my husband and myself impressed, but our picky 8 year old LOVED it! So it was a win-win-win! All around, I was pleasantly surprised by this place and know without a doubt, that this is where we will be getting our Pizza fix from here on out!
We ordered a steak hoagie and on the website it said it had garlic on top, and it didn't. It looked nothing like it was advertised. I was really hoping we found a new hoagie spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
ally gale
horrible management
Hayden Sutphin
Awesome place! Staff is super friendly and making excellent pizza! Tried the chicken and waffle pizza for the first time! Now my new favorite go to! Highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls
Fareed Koury
Best pizza in Northern KY & Cincinnati! Quality ingredients every time, I average ordering a pizza once a week and it’s always consistently good! Joe Burrow pizza is my go to! Love the fact the owners, Brad and Savannah, are always there and show appreciation for their customers. It’s always nice to support small business owners in our community!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Nathan Storer
I didn't much care for the atmosphere inside. Maybe because it was hotter in there than it was outside and it was 80° out that day, but I got taken out so it didn't matter too much. Buuuut the deep dish was really good! If I'm back in town I'll definitely be stopping by this place again
Poseidon's Pizza is by far the best carryout in the tri state. They are in a league all their own. I typically make my own pizzas because I am always disappointed with carryout. Poseidon's is the only place I will order from.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matty Mo
Great every time. Very consistent. Never had a bad pizza from here!
Larry Edmister
The owner left a personalized note for us to celebrate the arrival of our baby girl!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina Hendrickson
We ordered different pizzas for our daughters HS graduation party. Savannah was great to work with and very accommodating. The pizza was delicious. I would highly recommend them for an occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Timothy
The pizza was delicious. We had several kinds and everyone loved them. It's takeout only.
Pizza was average at best. Ordered two subs and were very soggy for carry out and it’s 4 minutes away; pizza was still hot. Certainly not worth $30 for a NY style cut in squares. We never checked a box for squares and the description shows slices?? 2 pizzas 2 subs $81 is a joke. Watch the check out process because a 20% tip is added and you have to notice it. Not a review person but felt others need to know.
Just to let all know ...
They don't pay the employees that work for them.
I feel like NO ONE SHOULD BUY FROM THEM..
Oh let's not forget they wanna call me and act innocent. Hahaha . after they stole MY MONEY .
iRS.
Any lawyer willing to help me with a law suit please let me know.
We stopped by Poseidon’s Pizza on a Sunday afternoon while we were in the area and were surprised to find out they are delivery and carry-out only. The staff was very friendly and helped guide us through the menu, which we appreciated.
We ordered a Chicago deep dish veggie pizza and a thin pepperoni hot honey pizza. The veggie pizza had good flavors in the sauce and toppings, but the crust was a bit dried out. On the other hand, the thin pepperoni hot honey pizza was absolutely delicious!
Overall, it was a good experience, and we’d definitely come back for the pepperoni hot honey pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
With 3 kids in sports you tend to do quick dinners or on the go options often. This is our first time trying this place and wow! Not only is the food fantastic, but the service was amazing! I will definitely be coming back to this place even though I live 30 minutes away. Highly recommend. If you are GF, grab cauliflower crust pizza. I've had a lot of them and this was the best cauliflower crust I've ever had. 10/10, 100/100 would definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finally tried Poseidon's Pizza today and so glad we did! The Buffalo Soldier Pizza (Buffalo Chicken) and the Joe Burrow Pizza were delicious! I could barely wait to get home to get a slice! Also, that Capicola Hoagie
I was greeted by a very helpful and nice employee with a very warm smile and while I waited, I got the chance to look around the waiting area (very classy by the way), to notice that Poseidon's Pizza does a lot to give back throughout the year with their Food Drives for school aged children. I would much rather support local businesses that support their community!
Not only was my husband and myself impressed, but our picky 8 year old LOVED it! So it was a win-win-win!
All around, I was pleasantly surprised by this place and know without a doubt, that this is where we will be getting our Pizza fix from here on out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Capicola Hoagie
We ordered a steak hoagie and on the website it said it had garlic on top, and it didn't. It looked nothing like it was advertised. I was really hoping we found a new hoagie spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
horrible management
Awesome place! Staff is super friendly and making excellent pizza! Tried the chicken and waffle pizza for the first time! Now my new favorite go to! Highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls
Best pizza in Northern KY & Cincinnati! Quality ingredients every time, I average ordering a pizza once a week and it’s always consistently good! Joe Burrow pizza is my go to! Love the fact the owners, Brad and Savannah, are always there and show appreciation for their customers. It’s always nice to support small business owners in our community!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I didn't much care for the atmosphere inside. Maybe because it was hotter in there than it was outside and it was 80° out that day, but I got taken out so it didn't matter too much. Buuuut the deep dish was really good! If I'm back in town I'll definitely be stopping by this place again
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Poseidon's Pizza is by far the best carryout in the tri state. They are in a league all their own. I typically make my own pizzas because I am always disappointed with carryout. Poseidon's is the only place I will order from.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great every time. Very consistent. Never had a bad pizza from here!
The owner left a personalized note for us to celebrate the arrival of our baby girl!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered different pizzas for our daughters HS graduation party. Savannah was great to work with and very accommodating. The pizza was delicious. I would highly recommend them for an occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was delicious. We had several kinds and everyone loved them. It's takeout only.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...