10 Best Italian Restaurants near Henderson

“My husband and I moved to Henderson a couple of years ago from Detroit, and ever since, we’ve been a little disappointed in the variety of food options here — especially when it comes to sushi. We really missed having a solid, go-to sushi spot. A couple of months ago, we finally tried Crust and Roll. I’ll be honest — we were hesitant at first. Sushi in a small Kentucky town? And in a small building outside of town that’s not much to look at? We weren’t sure what to expect. But let me tell you — we were completely wrong. This place has better sushi than anywhere we’ve tried in Henderson, Evansville, or Owensboro. The quality is incredible, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming. The variety on the menu is impressive, too. We originally went just for sushi, but decided to try the pizza — and it was exceptional. Now when my husband wants pizza and I want sushi, we can both get exactly what we’re craving. 10/10 recommend!“

“We usually like Fazolis, however we stopped yesterday to try the subs. Me and my husband got the Italian sub. $10 a piece. We got home and tried to eat them but they were so spicy we couldn’t. We both like spicy. But for one it didn’t say it was spicy, and for 2 it was entirely too spicy. They should advertise if it’s spicy! My daughter got the club, and it only had meat and cheese on it. That’s not what the picture showed. Waste of $30!!! Do better!!!“

“amazing food and experience!“

“Michelle was very friendly and professional. She resolved anything that we were questionable concerning. We were uncertain about some things regarding what we were receiving though she made for sure we received exactly what we wanted and was prompt within her service. The bread sticks were delicious and fresh. The rest of the food we ordered was as well. . Michelle went above and beyond to make sure that we had a truly pleasant experience and was very bubbly and personable. It is hard to come across a person that practices such customer service skills. If we are in the area again we will be sure to stop back through.“

“We run all over the country for work and we love trying local places along the way. When you arrive it doesn’t necessarily look like much. It gets more welcoming inside though. And the best part…the food and service were amazing. We didn’t know what we were in for until the salad and garlic bread showed up. Great! We had chicken cordon bleu and baked ziti. Again, great. If what you’re looking for is great food and service without the frills, this is an awesome option. At least it proved so for us!“

“Delicious food and cocktails!!!“

“Very impressed with the food and service. Thank you Milano's for a great meal and service!!“

“Wanted to try something different so I got the oven baked spaghetti, meat sauce and garlic bread. Thought because of the low price the portions would be small so I ordered two. Got home and very surprised - large portions and will save the second for tomorrow. Will definitely be back in the future!“

“The food was delicious. Pasta Al Forno was very good, hot and crunchy on top with the broiled cheese gramalade.
I did get a free treat for my birthday, but the waiter had to be reminded. The drinks took a bit to get to the table and the cheese for the salad and dishes was forgotten a few times.
Plenty of food to take home for leftover the next day“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“