Turtlelini's® Pizza and Pasta

103 S Dixie St, Horse Cave
(270) 786-8686

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alan Longbrake

I love this place. We visit every time we come to this area. The quality of ingredients is excellent. The people are friendly.I know that pineapple on pizza is controversial but the Hawaiian pizza here is top notch. It's probably the brown sugar that puts it over the top.

Paul Cordell

Super friendly staff, overall great experience. Passing through on vacation, and we were hungry for pizza. They were just stocking the pizza buffet when we arrived. Everything was good and hot! And great pizza! Thanks for the hospitality!!

Jason Coogle

As bad as the service an food was I was asked if everything was ok I was beyond nice with a smile when "I told her no words could describe" really not a place to stop unless your just pure hard up. The worst of it that got me to make this review was the red headed lady who got nasty ugly due to fact I had to get my own drinks the place needs management in a bad way. The pizza was so close to a Tony's out of the dollar store freezer it was a very bad experience.I added a pic to show there quility you be the judge.

Hihi Eday

Excellent Service Excellent food. there blueberry cobbler is very yummy. The people are very friendly and make sure you have everything you need. They keep the buffet stocked when they are out of something they put more out fast.

Jalisa Wolfe

The food was wonderful. I had the pizza & pasta buffet. It had a great selection. The owner was very friendly. I wish this restaurant was in my town!

BB Sup

Although the Chicken Alfredo tasted amazing, the portion was way too small to be considered an entree. It was more of a lunch sized serving. We ordered it take out. I don’t really eat very much in one sitting but this was even small to my standards. But like I said, it tasted great.

craig murdock

Very good calzone and pizza. Excellent service too!

Daisy Sharon

We stopped in aftr doing the cave tour n Loved the food n staff..Especially the desserts ?Will definitely will be back on our next trip to Kentucky!!Thank you

raerizz

Passing thru town and we were hungry. Wanted to try something local and not a chain. Popped up on Google Maps and the name made me smile. We had the buffet and the baked spaghetti from the menu. Everything was flavored perfectly and very tasty. I couldn’t stop eating! Staff was friendly and place was clean.

Randy DeMars

Nice little pizza place! The staff are friendly and the food is good! Prices are fair and the buffet is awesome!

Suedrs

My husband and I were looking for a very early dinner (4:30 CT)in an area with limited dinner and non franchised choices. The reviews appeared generally good and the website mentioned a selection of beers and bourbon. In these days of staffing and supply shortages we are careful to be less judge-mental and very patient. We arrived to find the selection to be a Bud, Bud Light and a seltzer. We declined. The lasagna was heavily sauced and the center was barely warm. Tasted “alright”. The chicken in the grilled chicken Alfredo was extremely salty and rubbery so It was picked out. Pasta was cooked properly and Alfredo sauce was flavorful but the center of the dish was cold(didn’t take it up to the counter, just stirred it up as the edges were hot). Can’t address the thin crust pizza or buffet with salad bar as we did not sample those. We were fed at a reasonable price. Reach your own conclusions.

Ellen440

The best little restaurant. We had the Buffet. Excellent flavor, always had a lot of variety, was warm and delicious. The staff at this restaurant are extremely kind, courteous, efficient and hard-working!! Absolutely a wonderful experience for our visit.

ZeeBee Pepper

Best Italian foods for miles around..I specially go there when visiting the area ..The staff is friendly ..I look forward to this treat.

Terrasa Rafferty

Nice, friendly, family atmosphere. Arrived near closing and they welcomed us to enjoy the salad, pizza, pasta, dessert buffet.

Jennifer Jones

Great little spot. We had the lunch buffet of pizza and salad

Loading...

Turtlelini's® Pizza and Pasta

103 S Dixie St, Horse Cave, KY 42749
(270) 786-8686