If you like pizza, you have to try this place. Order by the slice and you will not be disappointed. The slides are HUGE! See the photo below. The garlic knots... OMG they were good! Could have made a meal out of them alone. Also, the service was amazing. CJ was out server... see his photo attached as well. He was great, helpful, and funny. He made our visit even better. One of the best servers I have had in a while! The is definitely a recommended stop!
Timothy Arndt
Huge pizza slices!Just so you know, it seems like they make the slices to order so don’t expect to get it instantly.Still, the service was fast and the staff were nice.The lunch combo comes with two big garlic rolls.They are massive and very garlicky!They’re punch cards are really nice to get free slices and on Tuesday you get double the punches.Beverages are Pepsi products but you can add vanilla, cherry, etcetera to any drink.
Kornei Friesen
Very good pizza.. it’s just bad, that the slices are somehow pre-prepared, so my kids couldn’t get the white pizza. Tastes good and the service was also good. But it’s too pricey for that quality.
jonathan dunavant
Excellent pizza, nice slection of local and craft beers. Industrial style interior, very cool.
Linda DeConti
Awesome pizza. Great place to grab lunch!
Heather M.
After hearing about this place closing, I knew I had to give this place a try. I do thank the owners for announcing ahead of time with so many other places close to the area have closed without notice. Anyhow on to my review. It was quite a busy night for a Wednesday, not sure if it was always like that or because they were about to close. I had called in my order to go but when I saw I could sit at the bar and have a drink. I got 2 giant slices, one cheese and one pepperoni. I wasn't to big on the green stuff that they put on there. The pizza itself was good, not great not terrible but, good. And would eat it again if they were staying open. I also ordered a Beer off their taps since they were out of red wine for their Sangria. The bartender gave me my check when I really wasn't ready to close out. I could tell they were in a hurry with the place being busy so I can understand but, would have been nice if I was asked first. I will say I'm glad I got to try this place one time before they close. The owner did leave a post on Facebook that they have a joyous announcement coming soon, I look forward to to hearing what that announcement is. I do wish the owner and the other employees the best on their new adventures.
Caroline K.
Local pizza place with good pizza and good wings. I would say a little on the pricier side. Casual and low key- we got the 14" pizza (there are only 2 size options, 14" and 18") and it fed 3 of us! We went on a Tuesday late afternoon and there was zero wait. Looks like the place to hang for locals!! Lots of TVs to watch sports games around the bar. I would go again.
Michael Hanks
Great place. Fan of their Local Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette. Pizzas with fresh ingredients definitely hit the spot.
Michael M.
Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place before. I've been a dozen times. I'll keep this brief: lots of seating, great pizza, good beer selection, and make sure you order the garlic knots.
Butchertown Pizza Hall is a unique spot in the area. I love that you can get pizza by the slice and the service is pretty fast. Tuesday's they have $3 tall boys which is a good deal. I can't give 5 stars as it just seems like they go skimpy on the cheese topping for pizzas and I wish they had smaller sizes of the regular pizzas.
Bayly J.
Great lunch spot in the nulu area. Price point is great and portions are MASSIVE. One lunch order can easily feed two. I ordered the lunch special which is a slice of pizza (more like the size of 3 slices) two garlic knots and a soda for $6.99. Can't beat it. Their sweet tea is to die for and freshly brewed! They are very generous with toppings which is a plus in my book. The manager, Aslan, is awesome! Say hello when you go! The only reason for the 4 stars is the food is incredibly greasy. Like dripping off your food. It's not the healthiest option but they do have yummy salads!
Brian F.
Oh so good! We ordered the all meat pizza and the toppings are HUGE! The slices are New York style so 2 was all I could eat. The staff was super friendly and attentive even though it was really busy. I highly recommend!
Zach F.
I have always been a HUGE fan and vocal advocate for this place, I don't know if we went on a bad night like the last three recent times. it was busy when we entered however when we left we were the only ones there. Our service has never been great unless it was Dustin at the bar, but I've always figured that was kind of the feeling of a pizza hall so no biggie. Yet, our server tonight was either having a bad night, way over booked or just didn't care, I want to say over booked because benefit of the doubt. We normally order the 'Merica pizza with wings because you just can't go wrong with bacon and tater tots but we decided to order the calzone and boy were we wrong for it, I'm literally mad I paid money for what we were served. Yes to my own ignorance I read over the red sauce, three toppings and MOUNDS OF RICOTTA with a dash of normal cheese. Again, I'll call myself out for not reading but it was simply-really really nasty. We spoke with the waitress to ask if this was sour cream or cream cheese, she stated she had no idea and I then had to ask her to ask someone - anyone what this was, I was convinced it was warm sour cream, lol. It was already late so in my head I didn't want another one and didn't care for a comp but she had nothing for me, I think she had already clocked out. Now mind you this was my 5th or 6th time coming since opening, I ordered the bone in wings per usual and they were maybe a 3rd of the normal size, so while they were the only thing super tasty, I'm going to pull my American card and want what I'm paying for, it's chicken. All in all, I will be back one more time because we have a gift card amount but you guys I think I'm done here after, I 100% can't recommend this place or take someone from out of town here, The Post has to be the go to. I want to say it is under new ownership or hopefully something to create a mess but when a customer exclaims that the food was really really nasty, at least talk to them, also don't take the glass of water away with never offering me a single refill the entire time while we hadn't even signed the check. We brought 3 people with us and ordered rounds of food and drink, make effort sister that's really good money to be made. I'm not asking for a steak dinner service but sheesh. get well soon. I've made my peace and threw enough bones. No mo'
Corey H
I heard a lot of good things about this place and I wanted to try it. The pizza did not disappoint. They have good signature pizzas. But they were a little different. I wanted a more simple pizza, so I created my own. I got fennel sausage and mushroom. It was really good. Everything had great flavor. Our waitress was really nice to, I will definitely come here again.
Excellent pizza, and garlic knots
If you like pizza, you have to try this place. Order by the slice and you will not be disappointed. The slides are HUGE! See the photo below. The garlic knots... OMG they were good! Could have made a meal out of them alone. Also, the service was amazing. CJ was out server... see his photo attached as well. He was great, helpful, and funny. He made our visit even better. One of the best servers I have had in a while! The is definitely a recommended stop!
Huge pizza slices!Just so you know, it seems like they make the slices to order so don’t expect to get it instantly.Still, the service was fast and the staff were nice.The lunch combo comes with two big garlic rolls.They are massive and very garlicky!They’re punch cards are really nice to get free slices and on Tuesday you get double the punches.Beverages are Pepsi products but you can add vanilla, cherry, etcetera to any drink.
Very good pizza.. it’s just bad, that the slices are somehow pre-prepared, so my kids couldn’t get the white pizza. Tastes good and the service was also good. But it’s too pricey for that quality.
Excellent pizza, nice slection of local and craft beers. Industrial style interior, very cool.
Awesome pizza. Great place to grab lunch!
After hearing about this place closing, I knew I had to give this place a try. I do thank the owners for announcing ahead of time with so many other places close to the area have closed without notice. Anyhow on to my review. It was quite a busy night for a Wednesday, not sure if it was always like that or because they were about to close. I had called in my order to go but when I saw I could sit at the bar and have a drink. I got 2 giant slices, one cheese and one pepperoni. I wasn't to big on the green stuff that they put on there. The pizza itself was good, not great not terrible but, good. And would eat it again if they were staying open. I also ordered a Beer off their taps since they were out of red wine for their Sangria. The bartender gave me my check when I really wasn't ready to close out. I could tell they were in a hurry with the place being busy so I can understand but, would have been nice if I was asked first. I will say I'm glad I got to try this place one time before they close. The owner did leave a post on Facebook that they have a joyous announcement coming soon, I look forward to to hearing what that announcement is. I do wish the owner and the other employees the best on their new adventures.
Local pizza place with good pizza and good wings. I would say a little on the pricier side. Casual and low key- we got the 14" pizza (there are only 2 size options, 14" and 18") and it fed 3 of us! We went on a Tuesday late afternoon and there was zero wait. Looks like the place to hang for locals!! Lots of TVs to watch sports games around the bar. I would go again.
Great place. Fan of their Local Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette. Pizzas with fresh ingredients definitely hit the spot.
Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place before. I've been a dozen times. I'll keep this brief: lots of seating, great pizza, good beer selection, and make sure you order the garlic knots.
Restaurantji Recommends
Butchertown Pizza Hall is a unique spot in the area. I love that you can get pizza by the slice and the service is pretty fast. Tuesday's they have $3 tall boys which is a good deal. I can't give 5 stars as it just seems like they go skimpy on the cheese topping for pizzas and I wish they had smaller sizes of the regular pizzas.
Great lunch spot in the nulu area. Price point is great and portions are MASSIVE. One lunch order can easily feed two. I ordered the lunch special which is a slice of pizza (more like the size of 3 slices) two garlic knots and a soda for $6.99. Can't beat it. Their sweet tea is to die for and freshly brewed! They are very generous with toppings which is a plus in my book. The manager, Aslan, is awesome! Say hello when you go! The only reason for the 4 stars is the food is incredibly greasy. Like dripping off your food. It's not the healthiest option but they do have yummy salads!
Oh so good! We ordered the all meat pizza and the toppings are HUGE! The slices are New York style so 2 was all I could eat. The staff was super friendly and attentive even though it was really busy. I highly recommend!
I have always been a HUGE fan and vocal advocate for this place, I don't know if we went on a bad night like the last three recent times. it was busy when we entered however when we left we were the only ones there. Our service has never been great unless it was Dustin at the bar, but I've always figured that was kind of the feeling of a pizza hall so no biggie. Yet, our server tonight was either having a bad night, way over booked or just didn't care, I want to say over booked because benefit of the doubt. We normally order the 'Merica pizza with wings because you just can't go wrong with bacon and tater tots but we decided to order the calzone and boy were we wrong for it, I'm literally mad I paid money for what we were served. Yes to my own ignorance I read over the red sauce, three toppings and MOUNDS OF RICOTTA with a dash of normal cheese. Again, I'll call myself out for not reading but it was simply-really really nasty. We spoke with the waitress to ask if this was sour cream or cream cheese, she stated she had no idea and I then had to ask her to ask someone - anyone what this was, I was convinced it was warm sour cream, lol. It was already late so in my head I didn't want another one and didn't care for a comp but she had nothing for me, I think she had already clocked out. Now mind you this was my 5th or 6th time coming since opening, I ordered the bone in wings per usual and they were maybe a 3rd of the normal size, so while they were the only thing super tasty, I'm going to pull my American card and want what I'm paying for, it's chicken. All in all, I will be back one more time because we have a gift card amount but you guys I think I'm done here after, I 100% can't recommend this place or take someone from out of town here, The Post has to be the go to. I want to say it is under new ownership or hopefully something to create a mess but when a customer exclaims that the food was really really nasty, at least talk to them, also don't take the glass of water away with never offering me a single refill the entire time while we hadn't even signed the check. We brought 3 people with us and ordered rounds of food and drink, make effort sister that's really good money to be made. I'm not asking for a steak dinner service but sheesh. get well soon. I've made my peace and threw enough bones. No mo'
I heard a lot of good things about this place and I wanted to try it. The pizza did not disappoint. They have good signature pizzas. But they were a little different. I wanted a more simple pizza, so I created my own. I got fennel sausage and mushroom. It was really good. Everything had great flavor. Our waitress was really nice to, I will definitely come here again.