Gatsby's on Fourth

500 S 4th St, Louisville
(502) 585-3200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ben Shakman

Moving reviews over from Yelp. Originally published when we were in town for Thanksgiving 2018:

One of the only options for a regular lunch on Thanksgiving Day in downtown Louisville. We came in looking for exactly that and found what we wanted. A few things to know before you go:

1. Yes, you can easily drop $20/pp for lunch here without appetizers, alcohol or dessert.

2. Their menu is very limited.

3. They make a very good burger but the price point is a bit high for what you get.

4. Speed and tempo of service is a bit off. As for somethings and they show up in a minute or two while others required repeated requests and arrive after what seems like long enough that someone had to run to the store.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ashley Brown Pollard

Beautiful restaurant. Breakfast was good, but fruit and cereal needed to be restocked the entire time we were there. The omelet station was the highlight and the gentleman preparing them was spot on with quality and service. Overall good breakfast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Frost

Very nice atmosphere. We had the breakfast buffet. I had an omelet that very good, but some of the food on the buffet was overcooked. I realize that is better than undercooked.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ryan Clark

Eggs are powdered. Potatoes hard and dry. I ate here once for $22 and will never again set foot in this overpriced motel 6 breakfast buffet. Don’t waste your money.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Emanuele Grossi

The continental breakfast buffet is embarrassing, the tasteless and overcooked scrambled “eggs” seem to have been made by mixing some sort of powder with water. Bacon tastes like paper with salt. All this for a whopping $20/person. A 1 star rating is generous.

Lynisha Smith

Pretty decent

Michael Johnson

Love Gatsbys the atmosphere was great. Me and my family definitely enjoyed ourselves there. The guys/women/ that was playing the piano ? was awesome. I definitely will be returning real soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Phillip Lindsey

Love Gatsbys the atmosphere was great. Me and my family definitely enjoyed ourselves there. The guys/women/ that was playing the piano ? was awesome. I definitely will be returning real soon.

Omar Moore

The kick back is still worth the stay!!!

Aunt Krust

Overpriced complete joke. Our Hilton Diamond credit won't even cover this expanded Hampton Inn bfast ...and by expanded I mean they serve more than one meat on a Sunday.

K Cook

Overpriced complete joke. Our Hilton Diamond credit won't even cover this expanded Hampton Inn bfast ...and by expanded I mean they serve more than one meat on a Sunday.

Bridget Lewis

So incredibly pleased with our morning buffet dining service! All staff were extremely informative, helpful, and congenial! Food was fresh, promptly maintained, and delicious! Seating is comfortable and spacious!

Jordan Weiss

Omelet was greasy, terrible coffee. Avoid

Shad Kearns

Great breakfast option inside the Seelbach Hotel. Free breakfast for diamond members, Karen was a great and by day three of our stay Karen knew exactly what we were going to ordering an how we want our coffee just impeccable service

Cade Bisson

It is hotel breakfast, not great but it's food.

Loading...