Goodfellas

Name: Goodfellas
Address: 642 Baxter Ave Suite 102, Louisville, Kentucky, 40204, US
Telephone: (502) 398-5704
Price range: $
Rating: 4.3

$ • Pizza, Cocktail Bar, Gluten-Free

Hours:
642 Baxter Ave Suite 102, Louisville
(502) 398-5704

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Goodfellas

Goodfellas is a popular restaurant known for its delicious pizza and friendly atmosphere. Customers often praise the fresh, flavorful ingredients used in dishes like the calzone and pizza. The calzone is especially loved for its light, well-cooked dough and excellent quality ingredients. The pizza receives mixed reviews, with some finding it delicious and others calling it average, but many appreciate the interesting seasonal drinks offered. The cheesecake is frequently mentioned as being amazing.

The vibe inside is comfy yet chic, with a decor inspired by old-Hollywood-mobster themes that create a unique ambiance. Customers feel at home when visiting, and the staff is consistently friendly and attentive, making the experience memorable. The restaurant also offers great deals, such as a lunch special with a massive breadstick, a large pizza slice, and a drink for $10, making it a favorite spot for many.

Some suggestions for improvement include replacing plastic utensils with metal silverware, adding more topping options for calzones, and matching the music playlist to the restaurant’s vibe, perhaps with classic “oldies” or Italian music. Although the lounge area is often closed or reserved, the overall experience at Goodfellas remains positive, with many customers planning to return to enjoy the good food and welcoming environment.